The puppet Bubba J that appears on Arguing with Myself was made at the last second. In fact, Dunham claimed that the paint was still wet when he was using Bubba J in his performance.
The puppets that appear on this DVD are (in order of appearance) Walter, Sweet Daddy Dee, Bubba J, Peanut and Jose Jalapeno.
After one of José's insults, Peanut jokingly threatens to turn him into guacamole. Though jalapeños could be included depending on one's preference, guacamole's base ingredient is avocados.