"The Simpsons" When Flanders Failed (TV Episode 1991) Poster

(TV Series)

(1991)

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Another classic of the earlier Homer vs Flanders days
richspenc12 August 2017
Warning: Spoilers
This is the second episode, well more than the second time, but the second episode where the main episode theme was the rivalry between Homer and Flanders ("Damn Flanders!"). A saying commonly under Homer's breath but also funnily under Reverand Lovejoy's breath too in this ep. This is also the second episode where Ned does one of his frantic emergency calls too Lovejoy with Lovejoy murmering under his breath about how Ned won't stop bothering him about stupid little things (the background to this issue between them is explored more deeply in further down the road season 7 episode "In Marge we trust" when Reverand explains to Marge, the church's new "listen lady", about how Ned has been hounding him for years. We get a background montage of Ned's nonstop calls to Lovejoy over nonstop trivial matters, one funny one being "I swallowed a toothpick!" and one even funnier one being "I was talked into doing this dance called the bump, and then my butt accidentally touched the butt of another man!").

In this ep, where Homer so badly wants to avoid Ned that he avoids going to Ned's backyard BBQ, and going to a BBQ is something very hard for Homer to resist, especially when the smells from the cooking burgers almost literally carry him over to Ned's backyard and Homer finally walks over there and grabs a plateful of burgers without any interest whatsoever in socialising and starts stuffing himself. Then Ned presents a roast chicken, his new job opening his Leftorium (the first time and far from the last time of that place being mentioned or showed in Simpson episodes), and the wishbone pull between Ned and Homer. Homer pulls off the biggest half much to his delight and secretly wishes for Ned's " stupid" Leftorium to close as we see in Homer's wish bubble. Then his wish bubble of Ned losing his home, and then for a moment Ned's tombstone but Homer quickly decides "no, too far". That's something I liked about the Simpsons, they had their limits on how mean they were to make their characters, and wishing death on someone was a step too far. More recent 21st century shows like " Family guy" probably would've showed someone's tombstone wish bubble then had him enjoy that thought and stay with it.

As the ep continues, Bart decides to take karate, and while Homer takes Bart to his class at the mall, he relishes in Ned's empty Leftorium store, laughs about it at home, and refuses to tell other left-handed people he knows about Ned's store, including Moe who longs for a left handed cork screw, and Mr. Burns who longs for a left handed can opener. I liked the dinner table scene where Homer laughs about Ned's store being deserted, and Lisa, referring to Homer, uses the German term "schadenfreude" meaning one taking pleasure in the misfortune of others (then Lisa saying "sour grapes" was the opposite of "schadenfreude" and Homer responding "boy, those Germans have a word for everything"). Later though, when Ned's store really gets its business threatened, Homer stops laughing and is hit with guilt. Homer gathers other Springfieldians to chip in to help Ned. The ending had a good homage from the great 1940's film "It's a wonderful life".
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Homer Simpson Vs. Ned Flanders!
g-bodyl8 August 2014
This is the third episode of the third season of the Simpsons and I really liked it a lot. This episode highlights the rivalry between Homer and his neighbor, Ned. Or more so between Homer and his dislike for Ned and his riches. It was funny to see how Homer tries to thwart Ned's plans, but it's also nice to see that Homer has a heart, even for his enemies.

In this episode, "When Flanders Failed," Ned opens a store in the mall called the Leftorium which sells products for left-handed people. When Homer gets jealous, he wishes that Ned fails. When his wish comes true, Homer feels guilty and tries to repair the damage he caused.

Overall, this is a decent episode and one that highlights the jealousness Homer has for Ned. It can be a little sappy at times, but on the whole it's a pretty good episode. I rate this episode 9/10.
11 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Those Germans have a word for everything
snoozejonc12 July 2022
Ned Flanders opens a store for left-handed people.

This is strong episode with good humour and character moments.

Ned Flanders brings out both the worst and best of Homer Simpson in this very funny rollercoaster of mean and good spirited behaviour.

I love the parody of 'It's a Wonderful Life' and the sub-plot involving Bart supposedly taking Karate lessons is full of ironic humour.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Homer's brutal honesty
safenoe13 January 2024
Warning: Spoilers
Let's be honest, who hasn't had the desire to secretly wish ill-will on someone they don't like, and really, it happens and okay, that's what Homer did in When Flanders Failed when he wished for the failure of Ned Flanders's new business The Leftorium, a store which caters for left-handed people. But in When Flanders failed, Homer went way to far because his bad, bad thing pretty much jinxed The Leftorium, but really in all brutal honesty, how many people who wishes such stuff would be regretful like Homer did, I'm not so sure.

Anyway, all's well that ends well with The Leftorium becoming profitable.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Ned Goes Down
Hitchcoc14 April 2022
Flanders invites Homer to a barbecue. There Flanders announces he is quitting his job and opening a store for left handed people. Of course, it's a failure but Homer had tried to put a curse on the business and sees the family's demise as his fault. It is actually sort of sad.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Missed the mark
papavana10 August 2018
This episode really did a disservice to Homer. It's one thing to show that he doesn't like Flanders but to make the animosity towards him was too much. He only shows remorse at the last second. Homer plays a poor antagonist anyway; it's just not in his character.
6 out of 33 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed