Pretty disappointing finale that barely feels like a season finale. As an episode on its own it is quite eventful but many moments honestly felt contrived with characters arriving in with perfect timing.
Dr. Jacoby leaves incriminating evidence (the necklace) in a pretty easy to find place
Maddy dressed as Laura is filmed and stays in the same location so that Jacoby can be lucky enough to find her, and the attacker comes at the perfect moment so there are no witnesses.
Dale Cooper undercover was pretty fun. He's definitely my favorite character by far in the show. I love how interested he is in Twin Peaks and how he enjoys all the little things, and the whole dream aspect is very interesting. But he's also pretty lucky, dream side apart, the fact that Jacques just spills everything and trusts this complete stranger because of a good story. I mean it's not unbelievable but you'd think he'd verify first? Anyways Kyle MacLachlan is definitely one of the best actors on the show, though the show doesn't have that many great actors, which is to be expected from a TV Show of this era.
I also like James Hurley, and I thought his relationship with Donna Hayward was quite good. Uncovering the secrets from Laura and how it changes and affects their relationship is pretty well done and intriguing. It's nice to see he's also getting consequences and questioned for all the stuff he's been doing, though I didn't expect he's leave so much cocaine hanging around.
Comparatively I've found Audrey Horne to be the most annoying character on the show, though she is not a bad character, but I dislike how much focus she's given. That being said I like the direction her character is going in, getting too deep into trouble. It'll be interesting to see what happens.
I loved how Andy's gun training actually payed off. It was a nice fun surprise I enjoyed. His kiss with Lucy was so funny, and I loved the reveal that she was pregnant. At least there's one answer in this finale for why certain characters were acting weirdly.
Eye patch girl's suicide was so weird. It's not really sad as it should be, it's almost a bit comical. Honestly her storyline is just the silliest thing, kinda enjoyable at times but I could do without it. I guess she was part of the soap opera influence on this show, which I understand, but I still feel like she seems mostly pointless so far. Most of the interesting part of her character is just her relationship with Big Ed.
I really like the entire storyline with Hank, Jocelyn, Catherine, and Ben Horne. It's all very twisted with multiple agendas for each characters, and though it's hard to follow at times, it's probably the most intriguing and complex part of the show, supernatural elements aside. That being said, another thing that annoyed me with the convenient timing was Hank saving Bobby by shooting Leo at the right time through a window. By the way, Leo was probably one of the worst characters. He was such a one note villain character and the actor was one of the worst on the show. And then again of course Catherine comes right in time to save Shelly from the ridiculous timed bomb villain trap Leo set up.
Peter and Catherine coming back together came so out of nowhere but honestly it felt pretty believable. Sad ending with Peter going to try to save his wife in a place she isn't. Catherine can be quite unlikable but she's definitely one of the better characters, and I think she's one of the better acted too.
Probably the biggest issue with this episode, unless I'm missing something, is Leland going to the hospital to kill the suspect and knowing who the suspect is. Plus the fact that this important suspect for a murder case is just left without supervision, and Leland can just freely walk in to kill him. (Edit: Wow this was actually explained, but the second part about there being nobody guarding him still holds up).
The last thing I will mention is the final scene. Probably one of the most annoying and cheap cliff hangers in a prestigious show like this. Seriously you're going to fake out kill your protagonist? Arguably worse is that he's literally shot 3 times, so it's kind of hard to believe he actually survives. But of course he will. Aside from that this also brings up more questions like how an armed man is able to get into the hotel freely.
(Spoilers for Season 2 premiere: Turns out that he had a bullet proof vest, which is even more of a cheap cop out for a cliffhanger, but he was still shot once and is bleeding out, yet he was awake for a while and his friends came in time to go to get help. Come on, this is sloppy and lazy. Plus he still mostly acts the same after he was shot, so this was literally pointless and solely for shock. I hope we don't see more writing like this in the rest of the series. Also many of the cliff hangers didn't even lead to anything, most people who seemed like they died survived, and were also just cop outs for shock value. Despite that, I thought that premiere was the best episode so far though, so it doesn't bother me too much.)
This episode honestly was my least favorite one. It feels like it's trying to tie too many things together quickly and they end up feeling forced, whilst also having certain things for shock value which will not hold up in the next season, most notably the final cliff hanger which I thought was just cheap. That being said the show is consistently pretty engaging, with fun quickly characters, a great tense atmosphere, intriguing ever evolving town of mystery and of course the main murder case. I love how this seemingly normal perfect town is slowly revealed to be rotten with several conspiracies and secrets beneath the surface. Cooper is a perfect protagonist for this show, and he made very fun to watch. Even though Laura Palmer is dead she's very interesting posthumously. Honestly I would probably dislike the dream aspect if it were used today but true to the creativity it's executed with, and the fact that this was so original at the time I will accept it for what it is, and I do like the style a lot. The show is well shot which is not something that can be said for almost all TV show of the era, and I like the music a lot even if it's overused at times. Yes this deserves some praise for its influence, but so far I do think it's over praised, and a lot of things haven't aged too well. On its own this episode is not that weak but it also being the finale really hurt season 1 for me. Though I want to make it clear that I find this show to be really good overall so far. Well, while also being lenient because of the time it was made and how influential it was because nowadays this show wouldn't be considered that good in my opinion. To me this is a weak finale but not bad by any means. The season as a whole does work effectively as a murder mystery, and is well made, though it has its flaws, and is a bit dated, but because of its influence I am being lenient. There are some dumb things though, like many of the things I mentioned this episode, or one of the more glaring ones in the previous episode, like a parrot remembering a full incriminating conversation and repeating it perfectly into the tape recorder before being shot. Yeah... that was a bit silly to say the least. But at the very least this is a fun, engaging, even tense TV show, with a unique style, and I do think it's worth the watch if you like it's style.
Episode Rating: (6.5/10)
Season Rating: (7.5/10)
5 out of 11 found this helpful.
Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink