- Wayne: I'm no good at prayin', Ya know. Not real prayin'. I guess after what happened last night I should believe in You. But it's not gonna be that easy. 'Cause if You're really out there, then I'm in a lot of trouble. I appreciate the angels and all, but I'd just as soon pass right now. Thank You.
- Tess: A miracle is a very fragile thing. And if you don't take care of it you can let the truth get twisted out of it. And that's when it becomes dangerous.
- Monica: God is real, Wayne. And the miracle is real. And God wants the people of this church to know the difference between the truth you all saw, and the myth that has replaced it.
- Monica: God loves you. He came into that church on Christmas Eve to tell you so. He took away your disbelief. If you walk away from Him now you do so knowing exactly Who it is that you're turning your back on. And if a man walks away from God, where else is there to go?
- Tess: The sad truth, baby, is that, wherever there's an opportunity, there's an opportunist. And nothing brings 'em out faster than a good old-fashioned miracle.
- Joey: [to the baby left in the nativity manger] Are you who I think you are? You're late. Everybody's gone.
- Charlie: There is no God; you know it and I know it. Now don't get me wrong, I wish there was a God. 'Cause, man, I could use one right now. But all I got is me. And that's what I believe in.
- Joey: Excuse me... Do you know my phone number? I know it has - two 7s in it but I'm not sure about the other numbers. I think there's a 4...?
- Wayne: I didn't know God was in the T-shirt business now.
- Monica: He's not.
- Wayne: Well, somebody is. And if that's what a miracle's all about then I'm not interested in God.
- Monica: What you're not interested in is this religion created by Charles to take advantage of a lot of vulnerable people right now. It's been going on for centuries. People trying to explain the unexplainable, and give their soouls over to someone who claims to speak for God.
- Parishioner #4: Please, will you tell God - that we're sorry?
- Monica: You can tell Him that yourself. That's what He was trying to tell you on Christmas Eve. He is listening.
- Monica: You've been fakin' the miracles for a long time, Charlie. What's it like to finally see the real thing, hm?
- Monica: It was a Christmas present. It was a little glimpse of Heaven. A gift from God for the faithful people of this church, whose roof may be leaky and whose organ may be ancient but, whose doors have always been open to the sick, and the poor, the lost, and the simple.
- [touches Joey's back where he holds the baby; referring to Charllie]
- Monica: But you took the gift and you let someone ruin it. You worshiped a feather and an angel instead of God. You sought out fame instead of the needy, and you embraced the loud arrogance of pride, and became deaf tot he tiny voice of a small baby in a manger. But the rest of you turned your backs on the truest love of all, and you exchanged the miracle for a lie.