"Star Trek: Voyager" The Gift (TV Episode 1997) Poster

(TV Series)

(1997)

User Reviews

Review this title
18 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Fair well to a favourite character
Tweekums13 January 2010
Warning: Spoilers
After gaining an unwilling passenger in the previous episode Janeway must decide what to do with Seven of Nine and defend her decisions against charges of hypocrisy; after all is there any difference between the Borg forcing other species to join their collective and Janeway forcing Seven to remain on Voyager without her connection to the Borg. The captain argues that Seven isn't in a position to make a decision as her Borg implants are controlling her and that she can't decide whether or not to stay on board until her humanity is restored. It isn't just Seven who is having to come to terms with her changing nature; Kes's telepathic powers are increasing to the point where she is able to effect matter at a subatomic level which is danger to the ship and crew.

While there is some action this is first and foremost a character driven episode where we are given an interesting insight to the captain's thinking and the nature of humanity. After three seasons it was a shame to see Kes depart from the series, Jennifer Lien did a good job in the role.
23 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A Highlight of all Star Trek
verser-230 August 2006
Warning: Spoilers
This episode touches on one of the main focuses of Star Trek: the definition and refinement on human nature. Every episode that has touched on this subject has almost always been a highlight of Star Trek. Similar to the birth of a human from a positronic brain, or the evaluation of the Prime Directive, this episode tackles humanity.

Janeway distinguishes herself as a Picard, and other greats, to have a human imperative that steadfastly has the need to employ humanity. Seven of Nine is portrayed perfectly as a human conscience wrapped in a shell of conformity, only cracked from a woman with a conviction: humanity has a will, and a need to be realized among all who have the potential and willingness.

However even more dynamically, Janeway evolves the sense of realizing humanity in Seven of Nine. Seven wants to return to the Borg, citing its her freedom to choose so, as a human. Janeway evolves humanity against the charge of hypocrisy, stating that no human would choose to be enslaved by the conformity of the Borg, and that Seven is not completely human yet. Janeway adds another definition to humanity as defined by Star Trek, in her assertion to Seven of Nine.

The sub-plot for Kes is somewhat abrupt, changing appearance, abilities, and even her state of matter within a few episodes.

Spoilers herein: you have been warned.

Kes' new powers are abrupt, however the saving grace is the ability to portray it as an ascension, as seen in an episode of The Next Generation: the idea that past the accomplishment of warp, there is another accomplishment for species. That accomplishment is the ability to perceive matter, space, and time as one unified state of existence.

This acts as an interesting deus ex machina for the plot, sending Voyager through a "super-warp" that shortens their journey by ten years. It's a relief though, after many failed attempts for an expedited method home for the crew.

On the basis of a "popcorn" entertainment episode, this episode may be a seven out of ten, but on a grander and deeper scale, this episode reverberates as a continuation of a higher sense of Star Trek, adding a well-deserved two more stars! Seven of Nine + 0.222 = ~9/10 stars! (7/9 + 0.2 = ~.9 = ~9/10)
31 out of 39 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Goodbye - Hello
brueggemanntami19 February 2022
Warning: Spoilers
I both love and hate this episode. Every time I re-watch the series, it upsets me. And yet I still think it deserves a high rating.

Kes was my very favorite character on the show. I enjoyed watching her grow from a naïve child to a dedicated nurse. Her connections to all of the other people on the ship made for deep and strong friendships. I think they could have taken her farther and explored her telekinetic gifts in a different manner. She still had so much to offer and this could have led to some great storylines. However, they chose not to. At least she wasn't killed off and they let her go out in a transcending manner. Moving on to something better? Perhaps. They had her leave the ship to protect and help the people that she cared about so much. That part did fit the nature of her character. Taking care of others was essential to her being.

Jennifer Lien was a very talented actress. They truly did her wrong in the way that she was dismissed. It ruined her life. She was beautiful and had that fantastic husky voice. Kes was a fascinating character with so much potential. But she was never going to be a sex object. She had not been established as that type. She was portrayed as a highly moral, dependable and intelligent person. That was not the direction the writers were taking the show. They wanted higher ratings, and sex sells.

Thus they introduced a blond bombshell in first skimpy, then clingy form fitting clothing that displayed off every curve to it's full potential. Jeri Ryan is also a talented actress. I was glad when they finally decided to let her show that instead of the Borg Playboy Bunny they originally brought her in as. Seven of Nine added to many good Voyager plots and I did like her. However not the way and reason that she was introduced to the show.
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
One of the most genuinely emotional episodes
ashleybmeyer19 September 2011
Warning: Spoilers
This is an awesome episode that adds an extra layer of humanity to Voyager's characters, for three reasons:

The sarcastic humorous tension between the doctor and Tuvak hits it right on the nail in this episode. Check out minutes 6-10 to see what I mean.

And Seven O'Nine performs several of Voyager's most intense emotional scenes as she realizes that she's been severed from her Borg family. (And the audience questions the fairness of Janeway's decision to forbid Seven from trying to return.)

And then we see what's probably Kate Mulgrew's and Jennifer Lien's real-life emotions transfered into the intense conversation Janeway and Kes have at the end of episode. No spoilers; you should watch it yourself.
24 out of 25 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
An abrupt goodbye to Kes, but a great philosophical episode
weluvbd11 August 2019
Warning: Spoilers
Following up on the two-parter Scorpion, this episode continues the story by saying goodbye to Kes, and beginning Seven of Nine's journey on Voyager. This was one of my favorite Voyager episode, and it was genuinely emotional (it was also focused on a dialogue between 3 strong and compelling female characters - Janeway, Kes, and Seven). The parallels between Kes and Seven are powerful. While Kes has ended her time on Voyager - and is able to move on to become something "larger" - Seven has just begun her journey, on the ship and as an individual. Although others have criticized this episode for effectively "replacing" Kes with Seven, I think that was the point. Kes had reached the pinnacle of her individuality, while Seven is only just beginning to become an individual. Seven needs Voyager - she needs the community and support - but Kes does not.

All in all, a beautiful episode, and a beautiful goodbye to Jennifer Lien's Kes.
10 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Kes Gets Her Number Retired
Hitchcoc29 August 2018
Warning: Spoilers
Things start cooking now. Kes apparently was forced off the show because of budgetary and artistic problems. This episode accentuates the fact that Kes is developing powers that could destroy Voyager. Seven of Nine is slowly brought back to her human form, losing more and more of her Borgianism. We get to experience her pain as she transitions. One important thing is that the "Gift" given by Kes is really significant.
9 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
I rewatched this last night in Dec 2020 and is better than DSC.
marianthenightman4 December 2020
I rewatched this episode last night ,instead of a new episode from Discovery (s3 e8) and I liked so much so I don't regret a thing ,VOY and DS-9 deserve an HD treatment for sure.
10 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Mom Janeway.
thevacinstaller6 August 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Well, they had to come up with something for Kes and this certainly classifies as something ---- That something turns out to be an evolution into a life form that is dangerous for the 9-5 work week aboard Voyager. Kes has transformed into something (?) and is now experiencing the realities past the point of the sub atomic (?).

The SO9 subplot was interesting ---- I am not sure if it was the writers intentions but I perceived her emotional responses as outbursts you would expect from a 6 year old girl who is angry/afraid/traumatized. If you think about it ---- her emotional evolution should not have progressed past the point of her assimilation. Janeway is also acting like SO9's mom in this episode ---- making her decisions for her and testing her by seeking her help with repairing the voyager.

This wasn't masterclass star trek but it was interesting to see the beginning of the emotional journey becoming an individual had on SO9.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A woman for a woman
tomsly-4001525 December 2023
Well, that's it for Kes. They really made it quick to get her of the show. It all feels rushed without explanation on why Kes suddenly developed her telepathic skills in such an extreme short way.

But, the showrunners didn't dump her in exchange for Seven of Nine in skin tight jumpsuit. Jennifer Lien had real life problems, which negatively impacted her work as many participants of the show later said. It was hard to work with her. And later she completely broke down, her life became a mess although she claimed she never regretted to leave the show and had no hard feelings. From drinking and driving to exposure to minors. Also, if you google her, there is not much left of that young and fragile woman. She looks like a different person. Sadly, Lien's life went downhill, but obviously she never let others help her or opened up on others. In real life she was a completely different person than the character she played on the show.

Also, back when Voyager was aired, #metoo wasn't a thing yet. Today you would not add a female character anymore to such a show that is put into tight clothes to attract young male viewers. At least Star Trek redeemed itself when Annika reappeared in Picard and played a crucial part there. Grown up, tough and focused on character.

The transformation of Seven of Nine from Borg drone to human is unfortunately too fast. They could have shown so much more character building if they showed us this transformation in the coming episodes with all up and downs. This whole episode feels rushed: Kes turns into an omnipotent energy being from now to then, flings Voyager 10,000 light years closer to the alpha quadrant and out of Borg territory which comes in quite handy in eliminating a major threat. And Seven of Nine suddenly is human and has accepted her new life. It's quite a hard cut in this series to start a new chapter.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Decent episode that had a couple problems...
GreyHunter25 December 2019
Warning: Spoilers
As a transitional casting episode, The Gift introduced us to one of the primary plot arcs for the next season or more, 7 of 9's sometimes-difficult reversion to being as fully human as her residual Borg implants will allow. The secondary plot, Kes leaving the ship (and show) actually seemed somewhat underdeveloped, with so little explanation that it almost felt like a hurried deus ex machina to help usher the character off as quickly and with as little fuss as possible. Aside from an emotional scene with Janeway, this particular plot had little power and less resonance.

In the 7 of 9 arc, I found a couple things troubling. One, Janeway (and the engineering people) was extremely negligent in keeping a close eye on *everything* 7 of 9 was doing. Posting some random yellow-shirt to hang around was hardly a believable security measure from Captain Janeway, given the treacherousness the Borg had displayed JUST ONE EPISODE AGO and the clearly-fervent connection 7 of 9 felt for the Borg even when disconnected from the Collective. It made no sense, especially when Janeway introduces 7 to the engineering group and implied that 7 was trustworthy and sincere and didn't need to be treated with suspicion (at least our lovely resident half-Klingon was smart enough to do so.) Another problem I had was how *terrible* Janeway was at argumentation. Though she references the danger 7 represented a couple times, she seemed to be speechless at 7's clearly fallacious arguments about how she's being treated. Janeway doesn't bother to point out that 7 had brought it on herself, or that there were clear differences between being thrown into the brig and being forcibly assimilated, or that the Borg had already demonstrated that they'd take Voyager without a second thought (a Borg should easily understand the logic there) or even that 7 was demonstrating why she shouldn't be immediately set free even as she stood in that cell. That was just bad writing and not in keeping with what we've seen of the character of Captain Janeway.

My last problem comes from the end of the episode, where we clearly made a time jump into the future. It was lazy. All of the sudden, Janeway feels 7 can be trusted, the Doctor has pared down her Borg physiology as far as he could, and 7 seems to be practically friendly. That's an awful lot of character development y'all just skipped over, buddies. Tacking that ending on made your jobs easier, to be sure, but it also worsened the series by taking the easy way out.

(Also, why did Tuvok not receive a security alert immediately after 7 took control of room in Engineering? He would never have turned those off -- he's Vulcan and meticulous about his job as Chief of Security. And, without any further information being shared as the situation is resolved, the captain is talking to him as though he'd been privy to everything that had been happening all along.)
11 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Goodbye to Jennifer, Hello to Jeri
XweAponX6 October 2013
Warning: Spoilers
Out with the old, in with the new?

Jennifer didn't even know she was "Being Replaced" with a Borg until she got the script for this episode. I can't forgive Berman for this, I never have. But then again I never knew this until recently, at the time, sure I was very disappointed.

Voyager could have and should have kept both characters, even if one of them was only a recurring character, like Icheb in the last 2 seasons. But poor Jennifer was so heartbroken she quit acting, actually went on to become a real Doctor in Real Life.

On the other Drone Arm-attachment, this episode carves out Seven-of- Sixty-Nine's transformation from Borg Drone to Quasi-Human.

I never really considered Seven as a regular Drone, her first appearance was from a special chamber in The Center of The Cube. It was as if she had been stowed there by The Queen for a special purpose.

We think of "The Queen" as an Individual, we have to remember her voice is the ONE voice of The Borg, so whatever she says is what The Collective is saying, down to the last Drone. So my hypothesis is that Seven was being groomed to become a third Queen. We've seen the Alpha Queen, Alice Krige and the Beta Queen, Susanna Thompson. Had Seven stayed with The Collective, and her Cube not vaporized by Species 857- 6309, maybe she would become the Delta Queen. She is HUMAN, and The Borg had taken quite an interest in Humans, even recruiting a Borg King, Locutus.

And we know that Picard had kept his connection to The Borg even years after his encounter.

So The Borg had given Voyager quite a Gift. If you consider this, the title of this Episode takes on a double meaning. Maybe even on some level, The Collective Gave Voyager Seven to help them get through the Delta Quadrant. Otherwise, Voyager would have been Assimilated.

So Janeway gets right to work on Seven after The Doc takes out much of her Implants.

Meanwhile, Kes is developing some startling Kinetic Powers due to her interaction with Species 857-6309. We saw some of this when Kes came into contact with the Ocampa in the Second Caretaker's Array, but it didn't hold. But now, it is all coming back to her, and she can even reach into Seven's Brain and remove a failing Nano-Implant.

She can look down into Matter and see the Quantum beneath the Quantum, or look up at the stars and see the Quantum Above our Quantum. Infinity means just that, there have to be Quantum states below the ones we can now detect, or above our plane of existence. Otherwise, the word "Infinity" means nothing.

But it is too much for her to control, if she stays on the ship, she could destroy it.

Kes Gift to Voyager was a 10,000 light year ride across Borg Space, The Borg's gift to Voyager was Seven.

At least this is what I thought when I finally saw Seven, all "Gussied Up" to look like a Human, standing next to her Alcove in Cargo bay 2. At least she had Great Implants.

What possible use have the Borg for any Human Sexual Traits anyway? When we first saw them and as described by Q, "Not a man, not a woman". The Borg use another means for reproduction, even re-creating various Individuals. We know that the Alice Queen was seen in three places, the Susanna Queen on at least two, and in the end we had the Alice Queen to Herald Voyager's Exit from the Delta Quadrant.

And at least an episode was written later to have Kes return to Ocampa, even though she had aged too rapidly and became a Bag Lady. But I consider that as the effect of Kes harboring the mind of The Warlord- See the 3rd Season Episode "Warlord". His anger is what burned her up and made her age, and after that anger was diffused, maybe the aging effect stopped. But we never got to see that. But it is a viable explanation, as Tuvok told Kes that the effects of her "adoption" by the Warlord could not be calculated.
13 out of 27 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
7 of 10
Ar_Pharazon_the_golden11 April 2019
Warning: Spoilers
Because the main plot with 7 of 9 is good, but the secondary one with Kes is kind of ridiculous.

Janeway makes another controversial, if not downright unethical decision, by forcibly unborging the Borg prisoner against her...their wishes. Disagree as one may with the captain, it makes for an interesting story, helped by Jeri Ryan's fine performance as a confused ex-Borg.

Meanwhile, Kes has to leave the show, but that does not mean it has to happen through some Buddhist-like ascension. A couple of episodes of build up do not justify this sudden "fabulous secret powers were revealed to me" moment. Sure, she had met other Ocampans who had extensive telekinetic and telepathic powers, but since they had not become Jedi Force ghosts, why should she? Not to mention that only a few episodes before she had grown old and died aboard Voyager without ever acquiring these powers. It's not much to ask for continuity in the space of 6 episodes. Nonetheless, the fact she does leave the ship can't be a bad thing - she was quite decent at the role, but it wasn't really getting anywhere (was Harry Kim getting anywhere though, one might ask).
4 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
"I believe something crucial is happening to me."
sugarmountainf4 September 2018
Warning: Spoilers
["The producers are kicking me out to make room for Jeri Ryan of the spray-painted-on cat suit!"] Thus is the end of the drop-dead gorgeous Jennifer Lien. They couldn't have TWO beautiful women compete against Kate Mulgrew. I will miss that face, that husky voice.

Oh, the episode. Well, there's the standard writing by people who never took a physics class in their lives.

There's wooshing in the vacuum of space. The hull is destabilizing. The molecular bonds are breaking down. But after the cause stops, everything miraculously repairs itself, and onward goes Voyager! And another shuttle craft is lost, but this is not important as they grow on trees in the shuttle bay.
16 out of 37 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Kes goes a bit 'Gary Mitchell'
snoozejonc15 March 2023
Seven of Nine struggles to adapt to human life, whilst Kes' powers increase considerably.

Kes' powers go off the chart, making Tuvok nervous and contriving a situation that suited the show runners' agenda back in '97. These scenes are well made, but the timing and suddenness makes it feel forced in to the show narrative to remove a character from the series.

The scenes involving Seven are easily the highlight of the episode, with well written dialogue and memorable performances from Jeri Ryan, Robert Picardo and Katie Mulgrew. It's good that the writers do not apply black and white logic to the situation, but make it more complex with the varying perspectives on the Borg and Janeway's actions.

Visually it has some very memorable imagery, particularly the effects that involve Kes' transformation and the semi-Borg makeup applied to Ryan.

Whatever the true reason Jennifer Lien's departure from Voyager might be, I personally think she did good job in the role and was not always helped by the material provided for the character, such as the short lifespan and romance with Neelix.

For me it's a 7.5/10, but I round upwards.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Is Janeway a hypocrite?
planktonrules20 February 2015
Warning: Spoilers
This episode concerns two females aboard Voyager. Kes' psychic abilities continue to improve--and Tuvok is concerned because they are so powerful and, at times, almost god-like. The other plot involves Seven of Nine. Her Borg implants are now being rejected since she's no longer a part of the collective. The Doctor can either let her die or remove them. But this is like playing god and violates the Prime Directive, as they take them out despite her objections. Does this make Janeway a hypocrite? Perhaps...but also an expedient one. Overall, the title of the show, "The Gift" has meaning for both of these women and is a fascinating show with interesting ethical dilemmas. Well worth seeing...and a show you really MUST see due to its impact on the rest of the series and its characters.
9 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Regressive
chadtoland4 February 2021
Warning: Spoilers
The producers' motivations are quite clear in this episode. Ratings were down, the bikini resort on the holodeck wasn't cutting it, putting Kes in a tight uniform wasn't working, so they hired a super model to play a naive woman in a skin tight one piece. Sad! It's also simply not a good episode. But, as much as I hate 7 of 9 out of principal, she's honestly a more interesting character than Kes. Treating the actress with more dignity might have helped.
7 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Janeway of Borg
phenomynouss22 July 2010
Warning: Spoilers
The secondary storyline involves Kes leaving the ship because they couldn't handle having so many characters now that they bring in Seven of Nine, and rather than get rid of Neelix, the guy everyone hates, or Harry Kim, the other guy everyone hates whose actor actually can't act, they get rid of Kes.

Meanwhile, Seven of Nine discovers she's been disconnected from the Borg Collective. SHe is a prisoner of Captain Janeway of Starfleet. There is no other way to put it.

Probably the worst part is that Janeway tries to justify her ill treatment of Seven by claiming that the Borg did it first, and they took her away and stole her identity and assimilated her. In exchange, Janeway says she is giving Seven her old life back.

Except she's not, she's FORCING it upon her. Seven of Nine does not want to become her old self again; she wants to return to the Collective. There are plenty of logical reasons not to do so, dealing with security against the Borg, but none of these reasons are addressed even in passing.

Seven of Nine was once human, therefore she should become human again. That is the message of this episode and of Janeway.

There is actually precedence in this case; when someone abducts a child and raises them as their own. That child cannot simply be torn away from their "parents" and given back to their biological parents; this can cause severe emotional distress, and causing them to suffer for the crimes that are entirely the fault of their "parents", and not themselves.

In the event that the child becomes an adult, they cannot decide at all; the adult can choose their own path.

This does not excuse someone kidnapping someone else's child and raising them as their own, but that does not make it in any way legally OR morally acceptable to take a person away from their entire way of life and bring them back to the life they had when they were a child.

But since this is Voyager, that's of course the exact RIGHT thing to do, and it all works out in the end and Seven of Nine is happy. It's not a miracle, it's just bad writing!
11 out of 61 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
one for the other
rdvljunk25 March 2021
Warning: Spoilers
Exit the anoyingly always seriously good/obedeant and irritating Kes (only exceeded in irrritation levels by Neelix, they were a good couple) and replace her with a tough-chick blonde in a cat-suit, with a body that will make every teen-age boy never want to miss another episode. Freud would have had his thoughts about this....

So Kess almost literally disappears in her goodness, to be replaced by a body with a mind of its own that can gave some weight against Janeway....

It is all a bit silly and one of the lesser episodes of voyager.
4 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed