"Star Trek: Deep Space Nine" Improbable Cause (TV Episode 1995) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
Tinker, Tailor, Cardassian, Spy
XweAponX29 July 2012
Warning: Spoilers
Avery Brooks helms this episode which highlights Andrew J Robinson as "Mister Elim Garak."

Garak's daily discussion with Bashir is about Literary Works: Some of the finer concepts of Cardassian Writing are looked at, primarily that in a Cardassian Mystery Novel "All of the Characters are Guilty, but the Mystery is, which Character is guilty of what, and when." Bashir counters with the Bard of Star Trek, William Shakespeare. Garak is unimpressed that Caesar did not guess that his best friend Brutus would betray him.

This episode and the next are reflections of both of these Shakespearian and Cardassian concepts. A Bomb goes off in Garak's shop and The Sisko assigns Constable Odo to find out why/how/who.

Odo does indeed find out why and how, but the "who" is another matter: After a suspect is blown into microscopic kibbles and bits by the Rihannsu (aka, Romulan) intelligence organization the "Tal-Shi'Ar," It becomes evident to Odo that Garak blew up his own shop. Odo meets with his secret Cardassian "source" who tells him that Garak's assassination attempt is part of a larger picture that involves Romulans somehow: And several Obsidian Order agents that Garak knew were also killed, or, rather, they suffered unfortunate natural deaths or accidents all on the same day.

Garak had actually known this, which was why he "blew himself up." It certainly appeared as if somebody was targeting members of The Obsidian Order, and Garak is worried about his "Mentor" Enaubrin Tain (Paul Dooley). Tain's housekeeper/confidant Mila (Julianna McCarthy) confirms this: Tain had left suddenly and she charges Garak to find him.

And so what promises to be an "interesting trip" begins: Odo gets a Runabout and with Garak in tow they set out to find Tain.

But when they get to the planet where they may find Tain, a Romulan Warbird De-cloaks and tractors in their Runabout. And they are greeted by none other than Tain himself, who was the one responsible for cleaning up all of his own "loose ends," one of which was Garak.

Tain is actually pleased that Garak has survived, and offers Garak the opportunity to join him: The Cardassian Obsidian Order along with the Romulan Tal-Shi'Ar have secretly created an invasion fleet, to go into the Alpha Quadrant and wipe out The Founders.

As Tain says, "The Federation has shared the location of The Founders home-world with The Romulans, and they have shared it with me."

Odo immediately becomes a prisoner, and Tain assigns Garak to interrogate Odo: And so we know what it going to happen, but we will have to wait until the next episode to find out.

This episode clears up some hints that were dropped: In the episode "Defiant" Thomas Riker in the stolen Defiant attempted to destroy the Omekla III Shipyards in the Orias system: We now know what they were building. But it is the interaction between Odo and Garak and then Garak with Tain that keeps us glued to this: If the goal of a series is to make us care about the characters, then this Deep Space Nine episode was a smashing success: In fact, the characters of Odo and Garak were so well-conceived that we had no choice but to become involved in their stories. And I myself was intrigued by this Enaubrin Tain fellow, and why was he so important to Garak? We begin to find here in this episode which is planted at the exact center of the series Timeline.

The noted Character actor Leland Orser is Lovok: An interesting Romulan Commander- And a Romulan with even more secrets. And so, we already begin to see the connotations of Bashir's and Garak's discussion about literary works: The Cardassian reference was this episode, coming up is the Shakespearian reference.
12 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Who is trying to kill Garek?
Tweekums30 April 2010
Warning: Spoilers
This is a superior episode of Deep Space Nine which features some of Garek's best lines, Andrew Robinson does an excellent job elevating this secondary character to make him one of the series' best characters.

When Garek's shop is destroyed and he narrowly escapes with his life the obvious suspect is soon captured but Odo releases him so he can pursue him back to the people that hired him, he doesn't get far though before his ship explodes. As always Garek says that he can't have been targeted due to his past in the Obsidian Order as he was never part of that organisation... although nobody believes that of course. When Odo checks with a Cardassian source he learns that five of Garek's colleagues died on the same day his shop was bombed. Fearing for the life of his former mentor Garek, along with Odo head for Cardassian space where they learn his mentor was never in danger and has some interesting new friends who are planning an action that may lead to war.

Highlights of this episode include hearing the lesson Garek takes from the story of The Boy who cried Wolf and the revelation of who was really behind the bombing of his shop. Guest star Paul Dooley does a fine job as Enabran Tain, the former head of the Obsidian Order, who is perhaps even more devious than Garek.
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Intelligent Engaging Script
Hitchcoc16 October 2018
In this episode, Garek finds that someone has tried to kill him. There is an explosion in his tailor shop and he is hurt. In the process of finding the one who did this, he is hooked up with Odo as they head for Cardassia. We are made privy to a lot of information about both of them as they parry and thrust with their minds. Garek seeks a man who he should despise rather than embrace, but whose life he wishes to save. As this episode concludes, an interesting alliance takes place. On to the next part.
8 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Secondary character, "Garek," takes center stage
garrard17 April 2006
Paired with "The Die is Cast," "Improbable Cause" offers Trek fans two of its finest hours, in terms of acting, story, and special effects. The episode allows more development of the space station's Cardassian tailor, brilliantly underplayed by Andrew J. Robinson, revealing that he has more up his sleeve than threads and needles.

Responding to a request from his mentor, Enabran Tain, superbly performed by stage and film veteran Paul Dooley, Garek is forced to interrogate a captured Odo in order to find out information that can quell the movements of "The Founders," the shape-shifting race to which Odo belongs. As the story develops, Garek pulls out all the stops in his questioning of security chief Odo, prohibiting Odo from reverting to his liquid state. This makes for some intense banter between the two.

Also in the cast are Juliana McCarthy, late of "Sisters", as Garek's housekeeper who is more to him than just a former employee of his parents.

Besides the expert acting from all concerned, the two episodes provide the first glimpse of major space battles to be seen on the series. It is obvious that the budget for this episode, along with "The Die is Cast," was significantly higher than previous ones.

These two are must-sees for fans of great science fiction drama.
30 out of 30 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
An expose of the strengths of Garak and Odo.
thevacinstaller31 March 2020
Warning: Spoilers
This is a great episode. I have always enjoyed following smart characters that are written elegantly by creative writers. We have two of the smartest characters on DS9 entangled together trying to uncover the conspiracy.

When I originally watched this episode I had no idea that Garak actually blew up his own shop but it fits so well with the character once Odo revels his knowledge of it. In Garak's own way this extreme response could be considered a compliment of the highest order to Odo's talent as an investigator.

Plenty of memorable moments peppered throughout this episode. The shuttle scene of Odo speculating on the close relationship between Garak and Tain and Garak's 'fishing' response trying to find a weakness within Odo to potentially exploit was fantastic.

The scene between Bashir and Garak about the 'Boy who cried wolf' message being up to interpretation was priceless.

This episode nicely ties into the previous O'Brien episode involving the Romulans attempt to destroy the wormhole to stop the Dominion threat.

The banter between Garak and Tain towards the end of the episode was great. A verbal dance off with each combatant possessing a complete understanding of the other. I like how Odo is completely fearless and describes how uninterested he is in the dealings of former spy masters and how boring he finds the verbal back and forth exchange to be.
8 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
...never tell the same lie twice
snoozejonc6 June 2022
Odo investigates an explosion at Garak's shop.

This is a strong episode with an interesting story and character development.

All plots involving Garak are intriguing due to the mysterious way his character is written and the great dialogue exchanges he has with other characters. Half the fun is not knowing what's going on and enjoying listening to him avoid telling people.

Andrew Robinson is on top form here with some great banter involving Alexander Siddig's Bashir and Rene Auberjonois' Odo.

The plot unpicks a decent mystery that builds towards a strong reveal and a highly eventful second part of the story.

It's an 8.5/10 for me but I round upwards.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Oh, that tricky Garak.....
planktonrules24 December 2014
The bromance between Dr. Bashir and Garak is almost cut short when someone tries to blow up Garak. He manages to survive but the question now is WHO is trying to kill him. Why? Well, he IS Garak! Naturally, Odo heads the investigation and the trail leads several directions--to an assassin who is himself soon killed by the Romulans and it all ends with someone in Cardassia named Tain (Paul Dooley). What's up with all this? After all this, you learn quite a bit--and that it's only the first in a multi-part episode.

All in all, this is a decent episode--full of intrigue, explosions and Odo being grouchy. Worth seeing.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed