The nineth song sung is "Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas" by Gerald Broflovski (Kyle Broflovski's dad), Ike Broflovski (Kyle Broflovski's adopted brother), Kyle Broflovski, Sheila Broflovski (Kyle Broflovski's mom), Eric Cartman, Liane Cartman (Eric Cartman's mom), Adolph Hitler, Jesus, Sharon Marsh (Stan Marsh's mom), Shelly Marsh (Stan Marsh's sister), Stan Marsh, Mayor McDaniels, Carrol McCormick (Kenny McCormick's mom), Kenny McCormick, Mr. Garrison, Mr. Hankey, Mr. Hat, Mrs. Crabtree, Nurse Gollum, Principal Victoria, Santa, Satan, School Bus Driver, and Wendy Tastaburger.