"The Sopranos" Two Tonys (TV Episode 2004) Poster

(TV Series)

(2004)

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
Back to business
MaxBorg8913 May 2008
Warning: Spoilers
Just like Season Four aired 16 months after the end of the previous series, the gap between 4 and 5 was 15 months, leaving fans in a more anxious state than usual. Their patience was rewarded with what many consider the finest season ever of The Sopranos, a fact that is confirmed by its victory in the Outstanding Drama Series category at the 2004 Emmys. Sure, the last series is easily as dark as this one, but for sheer emotional resonance Season Five is the best of them all.

The recurring theme of the fifth series could be summed up in one word: preoccupation. It's a topic that is laid out in the most exemplary way in the opening shots: there's the traditional look at the Soprano home driveway, the house, everything. But wait, something is missing: there's no Tony Soprano picking up the newspaper. That's because he still hasn't lifted a finger to fix things with Carmela, and so the first big question of the season is raised: will Tony and Carm get along again? On the work front, new kinds of worries shape up, as several old-school hoodlums who were locked up in the '80s are being granted parole. Among these people, three will leave a mark on the show: Feech La Manna (Robert Loggia), a hot-headed old-timer whom Tony and Jackie Aprile Sr. once robbed in order to get made (remember? Ralph Cifaretto told the story to Jackie Jr. in Season 3); Phil Leotardo (Frank Vincent), a conservative New York gangster; and Tony Blundetto (Steve Buscemi, director of the hilarious episode Pine Barrens), Tony's troublesome cousin and oldest friend. In addition, Chris and Paulie keep arguing over money and respect issues, effectively ruining a lot of sit-downs. Finally, the most worrying fact: Tony tries to get Dr. Melfi to take him back as a patient after telling her what his true feelings are, causing her to develop a theory about "two Tonys".

That's the title's explanation: over the years we have been allowed to observe two sides of the same person - one tender and caring, the other cheerfully brutal when necessary. The two aspects are mutually paradoxical, and similarly to Melfi the viewers are attracted and at the same time repulsed by the protagonist's violently contradictory nature, which is the main charm of the show and reveals its darkest extent in this season.

That, however, is just the most obvious interpretation of the title, provided by Dr. Melfi. On another level, Two Tonys refers to the fact that the fifth series is almost entirely about the relationship between, you guessed it, two guys named Tony: Soprano and Blundetto. And considering the actors embodying the roles, it's gonna be a memorable ride.
32 out of 40 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Just help me understand it
snoozejonc31 October 2022
There is a Tony size void in the Soprano house and Dr Melfi delivers some home truths.

This is an excellent start to the fifth season that sets the scene well.

The opening sequence brilliantly shows all you need to know about Soprano family life since the season 4 finale. This sets the tone for an episode where Tony's absence from the home is a recurring topic.

Largely the episode features more of the great character reflection that makes the show so good. I love the little moments like Tony observing the look of attraction between Carmela and the Ranger, the way he casually takes some OJ from the fridge, and the general sense of insecurity developed about his masculinity through various scenes.

Ironically the type behaviour Tony exhibits to assert himself as an alpha-male forms the basis of a fantastic exchange of dialogue between he and Melfi. This is a great scene, wonderfully written to present the truth to someone in a direct but respectful way, however it also shows a plausible reaction when that truth causes pain. It has great comic timing with the premise of someone insisting they can handle a dose of honesty when they most definitely cannot. James Gandolfini leads the episode brilliantly as ever and Lorraine Bracco makes a strong contribution.

The presence of the bear will most likely have been analysed to death by people theorising if it symbolises one side of Tony's personality or the perceived dangers left by his absence. Whatever the writer's intentions, it certainly works as catalyst for good banter and character moments. AJ's reaction to it for one is absolutely hilarious.

More humour (some of it pretty sick) is derived from the scenes of conflict between Christopher and Paulie. This little arc between the two characters had been simmering since the third season and it comes to a head in an extremely dark comic incident. Michael Imperioli and Tony Serico are on great form and bounce so well off each other.

For me it's a 9.5/10 but I round upwards.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Two Tonys (#5.1)
ComedyFan201019 March 2014
Warning: Spoilers
Carmela and AJ are now in trouble as a bear visits them. Tony is worried and gets a guy to sit on the porch with a gun. Tony tries to get with Dr. Melfi, but she tells him she doesn't like his values. And so that night he takes over guarding Carmela from a bear. Paulie and Chris have a problem about bill paying which results in a death.

Was great to see Dr. Melfi again. Only I think I got happy too soon as it didn't work out, hope we still to get to see more from her. And I wondered how she couldn't know the two Tonys. She is the one who should know him greatly.

The death of the waiter was so damn sad. Probably one of the killed people I felt the worst for on the show.
7 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The right way they show how psycoanalysis works.
inesmoltedo29 May 2006
*spoiler* .I like the way the series shows some scene of psycoanalysis and how it works. I don't even see this perfection in The Prince of tide.How very important is the infancy for the future adult. If you don't know where you came from, who you were, you can be very confuse about your present.

The way the traumas are inherited by descendant are shown perfectly. I can't imagine how this will finish since Tony's life I don't believe will change too much in the short time. Will see. The script writer are genius, they works with too many characters. Its difficult. I know. I'm a writer my own.

Congratulation for the Tonys award !.-
14 out of 49 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Steve Buscemi?
tureluur-9917012 September 2023
As much as I like this show and this episode too, I wonder why Tony's cousin had to be played by Steve Buscemi. Apparently all actors are of Italian descend so that must be the reason. But as an actor, Buscemi really isn't very good. For example he has a tic that I first noticed in Boardwalk Empire: he pressed his lips together after having spoken a line. He probably developed that in real life because of his weird teeth. But as an actor one should get rid of those things: you're supposed to be another person!

Beside that, Buscemi is a very odd cast in this maffia role, with his pale, skinny, meek appearance.

I'm extremely grateful James Gandolfini is the main character in this series!
2 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
My favorite line in this episode "THATS MY MONEY PAULIE" lmao
Neptune16517 July 2022
Warning: Spoilers
Aside from the reasons you stated here, there is another reason Melfi rejects Tony: she's out of his league. For all of Tony's masculinity and dangerousness, he's kind of a dumb lug. Melfi would get bored with him intellectually. Hilarious how these guys just randomly kill a civilian and simply run from the scene of the crime. Pilot episode Carmella would have shot the bear, wish we saw more of that instead of making her a damsel in distress. I think that Paulie taking half of the money for the cheque was more a thing of them ultimately squashing the beef, with the 50/50 showing them being on equal terms, neither of one being submissive to the other. Carm fell hard for the animal control guy. What does that tell you about how desperate she was for attention from any man other than Tony? And AJ's teacher? Whatever happened there. Great Episode to the start of the season what made Tony Think he can date Dr Melfi after he admits on cheating on his wife Multiple times and his Violent behavior.
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Trsfgg
thorodinson-501302 May 2021
Warning: Spoilers
8.2🌟 This is good episode it gives some fun with beer in house. And that Christopher and Paulie little conflicts. But i Don't like that they killed poor innocent waiter with out any reason and he jus doing his job he was telling he has kids in his home. I feel so bad at that time. Any way it serie it is Interesting to watch the things between Tony.
1 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed