Smallville (TV Series) Aqua (2005) User Reviews

The Hero, The Fish and The Shark

[claudio_carvalho · 9/10 · 7 May 2007]

Lois Lane returns to Smallville, and while swimming in the Crater Lake, she drowns and is rescued by Arthur Curry, a student of the Miami University. The have a crush for each other, but Clark Kent is suspicious of AC since he noted his abilities underwater. AC discloses to Clark that Lex Luthor is developing a weapon to the navy that is a menace to the marine life. Clark in principle does not believe on AC, but later he realizes that his fears are correct and he helps AC to sabotage the experiment of Luthorcorp. Meanwhile at Kansas University, Clark becomes close to his Prof. Milton Fine, a man that is writing a book about the evilness of the Luthors.

In this excellent episode, Clark Kent meets the Aquaman, a future member of the Justice League of America. The story is very well developed, with two new characters, AC and Prof. Milton Fine. This time, Clark seems to have definitely ended his friendship with Lex Luthor and will probably disclose other malevolencies of this evil character in his research. The gorgeous Erica Durance wearing bikini is another attraction in this show. My vote is nine.

Title (Brazil): "O Guardião do Mar" ("The Guardian of the Sea")

Meet Arthur Curry... Hero. Protector. Aquaman.

[Rcwilkinson123 · 9/10 · 29 November 2007]

A key DC Comics character comes to town in this exciting episode.

The young main characters are at Crater Lake, when Lois gets knocked unconscious while diving into the lake. However, she is saved by a young man named Arthur Curry. As Clark discovers, contrary to Clark's initial belief of being some sort of terrorist who is just playing on Lois' infatuation, Arthur Curry has unique superpowers when underwater, and works to save the world beneath the surface. "AC" tells Clark that Lex is building a lethal naval weapon called Levithian, which combats opposing submarines underwater, but exterminates all sea life around it. AC convinces Clark to stop this weapon, leaving Lex to wonder what the second streak of water other than AC's came from.

This episode is thrilling because it introduces Aquaman, and because it continues to explore Lex's ethically questionable projects, increasing the already-strenuous relationship of Clark and Lex.

Aquaman to Clark Kent: "Stay Super, Bruh"

[scarlettyforest · 8/10 · 9 January 2023]

This is so 2000s, it rocks in every conceivable way. In the classic "no tights, no flights" Smallville way, Arthur Curry has gotten his own 2000s cool dude™ makeover--but in spite of this, it's still a pretty bang on representation of a teenage Aquaman. Replete with his values and poweres. Plus, the antagonism between him and Lex is a perfect little hint at future Justice League conflict.

Despite this being Aquaman's episode, the standout performance comes from Michael Rosenbaum. Looking back, this is markedly one of the first true "Lex Luthor" episodes, one where he's not a victim, nor is his decision-making a side effect of Clark's lack of honesty. It also is one of the few ones where the writers give Clark a justifiable avenue to distrust Lex in the future. Great monologues all around.

The JLA comes to Smallville (again)

[xPapaDragon · 6/10 · 30 July 2006]

For the second time in as many years we see another member of the J.L.A (Justice League of America) on Smallville. This time it is Arthur Curry A.K.A. Aquaman. He bursts onto the scene to save Lois Lane. She is of course smitten by her rescuer. Clark, denying his true feelings, is suspicious of AC. The more he digs the more he is worried about Curry's reasons for binging in Kansas, when he is a scholarship swimmer from The University of Miami. Clark finds out that AC is in town because Lex is dealing with the military in a project that may kill a lot of sea life. After a rocky start the two team up against Lex. Clark sees that Arthur's heart is in the right place. The episode is a good prelude to what will happen someday for these two. Not the best Smallville and not the worse. It shows Clark that not everyone is what they seem to be which, is a good lesson for the superhero he will someday be.

Clark isn't the only naive one...

[m-47826 · 5/10 · 12 July 2023]

Now I remember why season 5 is one of my least favorite seasons. The writing isn't as thorough as it used to be on the show, and in this episode in particular, the activists speech was laughable. Granted it introduced another big name of the superhero brand. But in this version, Aquaman is not the brightest of the bunch (don't he think destroying Lex's device, and leaving it there. Would pollute the lake more?) and since he only cared about protecting marine life, for his own purposes. His heroic acts, leaned more towards ecoterrorism, than genuine concern for the planet. I liked his mini fling with Lois, though. This is also the episode where Lex is portrayed as the vilain of the story. But on the other hand, the people who call him out on his evilness, are the ones with the darkest secrets... It seems that, after Clark became a human for ten seconds, this year's show runners are out of inspiration. And even though I can appreciate some of the guests, like James Marsters, playing Clark's new professor (and nemesis). The shift to college life isn't done convincingly yet. And I much prefer the « usual » Smallville setting. The little nod to both Clark and Lois's destiny at the end, was great. And probably the only true rewarding scene of the episode, with the opening. Good soundtrack too.