"Perry Mason" The Case of the Mystified Miner (TV Episode 1962) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
A Lot of Mean Ladies
samgslp11 April 2014
The second half of Season 5 has some real gems and "The Case of the Mystified Miner" is certainly one of them. This episode is based on the Gardner novel "The Case of the Spurious Spinster." The only misleading thing about that title is the implication that there is only one spinster.

"Mystified Miner" centers on Susan Fisher, a secretary for the Corning Company - owned by Amelia Corning. She works directly for Mr. Campbell, whose job is not particularly well described. Nonetheless, Campbell's son runs into the office on a Saturday and hands a shoe box to Susan (he says it's treasure that he needs to hide from the pirates, how cute). She discovers that it's filled with genuine treasure indeed - $200 thousand dollars! Before she can notify Mr Campbell, Mrs. Corning calls and tells Susan she's just arrived from South America and to pick her up at the airport right away. This sets off a chain of events that cause Susan Fisher to look awfully bad. Fisher (played by Kathie Browne, who was in 4 episodes of Perry Mason and 3 episodes of Ironside) does a good job playing the trusting but naive good girl. Every time she does something stupid, it's only a little annoying to watch.

The basic idea is that somebody is embezzling from the company, and the murder that takes place is undoubtedly tied into the embezzlement. Simple enough, but the relationships between the characters are unclear which can make the story rather confusing. On the other hand, the episode has excellent pace. From the moment the kid runs into the office with his "treasure," something interesting is always happening and it isn't until the very end that it actually makes sense. Like a lot of Perry Mason epilogues, there's a lot of explaining to do.

Della mentions her age to a mechanic (I can't tell if it's supposed to be a joke or not) and Tragg has a funny scene in Mason's office. There's also a clever tactic employed by Mason to tamper with evidence in a circuitous manner, which winds up being completely irrelevant. Overall, there are a lot of good reasons to watch this one.
34 out of 36 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Perry to client "you're not in jail yet"
ebertip2 December 2020
Before anyone is murdered, Susan Fisher, secretary to Endicott Campbell of Corning Mining, comes to Perry about a shoe box with about $200k in cash that Endicott's son brought into the office as his "treasure," while screaming the pirates are coming. Amelia Corning, the company owner, arrived a day earlier than planned from South America, and Susan tells Perry that she had discussed the shoe box and certain issues about the Mojave Monarch mine with Amelia. Amelia goes missing but a different Amelia Corning arrives the next day. Paul interviews Ken Lowry, the Mojave manager, and learns that something odd is going on. Ken is asked to report time for numerous non-existent workers, get paid by Campbell, and return said money to a po box. Lowry goes along with this (!). The amount of money involved is around $200k. Susan gets some very odd instructions, including a car rental. Lowry ends up dead and Susan is charged. Now, there is no Amelia Corning to be found. Paul implies to Perry that the second Amelia had a passport (and thus was real), but the second Amelia was merely using the passport of the first (real) Amelia. During the hearing, an investigator of Paul/Perry named Abert (really Hebert?) gives damaging testimony and Perry really badgers a different witness. Perry asks for a recess and the "reveal" happens out of court. There is an interesting line earlier, Perry to Tragg: this time you've gone too far.
10 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Real Quick, Now
darbski25 October 2017
Warning: Spoilers
**SPOILERS** Confusing, until Perry had the "governess" on the stand. If the kid was telling the truth, and why would he lie?, she HAD to be lying; WHY is she lying? Her boss (and the gullible Susan's), is a snooty, arrogant, self-important boor, who is also too self consumed and stupid to allow any viewpoint but his own. He's EASY to manipulate. What I can't figure is why it took Perry so long to zero in on Dow.

You've gotta feel for dumb old Lowrey. He was honest and trusting, and that's how he could be used, and ultimately, killed. I agree that Campbell should be fired. All this went on right under his nose, and when old lady Corning decided to come up from South America for a visit, he had his secretary try to get everything set up for her visit; deciding that playing golf was more important?? The two vicious old bats that pulled the swindle, and killed Lowrey are gonna take a fall for Murder 1. Doesn't matter if they "didn't mean it"; homicide in furtherance of felony robbery (fraud) is Murder, First Degree (P.C.187). They made their mistake when they didn't hightail it when they found out about Corning's visit. They HAD to know something was up, and they should have been ready for it; passports, fraudulent I.D.s, whatever they needed to get away. 200 Grand would have done it, too. They were both pretty old, so it should have lasted them till they cashed in their chips. Of course, the state will take care of their retirement, now.
10 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Interesting Plot
Hitchcoc25 January 2022
This was quite a complex effort. It starts out with a loving, but dense, secretary, having a little boy hand her a shoebox with a couple hundred thousand dollars in it. But from that point on there is a constant hammering of facts and deception, to the point where the conclusion is anticlimactic. I would have appreciated things being settled in the courtroom.
4 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
An Erle Stanley Gardner Gem
joenic-2927918 January 2024
By Season 5, it had become a rare treat to see an episode based on one of Gardner's books. And this episode might be one of the best of the season.

Over the course of the series' 9 seasons there were many excellent original episodes created by the writing team however, plot elements exist in Gardner's stories often missing in the former. Having watched each episode multiple times, it is hard to put one's finger on the subtle differences, but they are there. One may be a few more twists and turns.

This episode is based Gardner's novel, "The Case of the Spurious Spinster." The name change may have to avoid confusion with a Season 3 episode, "The Case of the Spurious Sister" that wasn't based on one of his works. The episode includes the great scene stealer, Josephine Hutchinson, prominent 60s actress, Kathy Browne, and the often oily Bartlett Robinson. It is a great ride, and highly recommended.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Wow.
jaysriviera25 October 2017
My word, the Good Lord was awfully good to this "secretary"! Burr always had well endowed, beautiful women in the Perry Mason series, but this girl is exceptional. The addition of the librarian style glasses was almost too much to bear. My my, then add to all of this, the idea that the young lady is a literal killer, and you have a Perry Mason that stands out. Speaking of standing out, well, it would seem we've come full circle, ha, ha.
7 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
The little boy and his treasure
bkoganbing19 November 2019
One fine day Bartlett Robinson's little grade school son comes into his father's office and shows secretary Kathie Browne his 'treasure'. Quite a treasure it was too, $200,000.00 in cash in a shoe box. She's the last one in the office so she locks up the box in the company.

Next day Browne is visited by an old battle axe of a woman who owns the company. She barks out orders and has Browne turn over all kinds of company records for their mining operations.

Turns out she's a phony and when the foreman of one of their mines is killed, Browne is holding the bag and she needs Perry Mason.

This was quite a complicated scheme of fraud and embezzlement with a little kidnapping on the side. The little boy finding the 'treasure' upset a lot of plans.

This was one episode where Perry Mason did not do his revealing in court.
12 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed