"Murder, She Wrote" Lovers and Other Killers (TV Episode 1984) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
9 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
"The Truest Lies You've Ever Heard are in Seattle"
WeatherViolet9 December 2009
Wealthy widow Allison Brevard (uncredited actress) meets her fate when an apparent burglar ransacks her Seattle residence during the opening credits to this episode, assaulting her in the process, and leaving her for dead.

Jessica Fletcher (Angela Lansbury), by now a widow, a retired high school English teacher, and established best-selling Mystery author, has garnered international attention through her newfound celebrity, and begins to accept positions such as guest lector far from her hometown of Cabot Cove, Maine, and her publisher's headquarters, in New York City.

Here, after she travels to Seattle, Washington, to accept a mystery writing instructional position, she finds herself in need of a secretary and petitions for a lady of compatible age with herself, but, instead receiving the services of a cheerful, capable and efficient candidate, but male and younger than expected, in the form of student David Tolliver (Andrew Stevens).

Between adjusting to working with David, and conducting meetings with College Dean Doctor Edmund Gerard (Peter Graves) and his secretary, Amelia (Lois Nettleton), Jessica also instructs her forum on crime and mystery, along with visual aids, such as firing a pistol into the auditorium of students, this releasing a banner, reading, "Bang" (a scene often used among opening introductions).

Professor Todd Lowery (Andrew Prine), a fellow instructor at the college, enrolls in Jessica's lecture course, she at times singling him out for profound questioning. Whether or not Todd has anything to hide, he looks and behaves with increasingly guilty reactions.

Lila Schroeder Kowalski (Lory Walsh), the wife of the athletic Jack Kowalski (Grant Goodeve), becomes involved on one level or another, with David Tolliver, Professor Todd Lowery and Doctor Edmund Gerard, whether or not Jack Kowalski becomes aware, but he is known as possessing a volatile temperament.

Law Enforcement Lieutenant Andrews (Greg Morris), arriving on campus to investigate the situating involving Allison Brevard, links David to the crime, while Jessica, although experiencing doubts, maintains his innocence, by affording David the benefit.

But when Jessica attempts to prove David's innocence, by following him into a storage building, she discovers another body, leaving her not knowing quite what to believe.

And when Jessica receives an anonymous call to meet an informant in a campus building, a perpetrator shoves her down a staircase (a scene filmed in silhouette fashion, this also incorporated into opening "MSW" credits during the run of several seasons).

Still determined to investigate two murders, Jessica tracks down the various suspects, gives David an ultimatum, and manages to assist Lieutenant Andrews in tracking down "Lovers and Other Killers." This episode's title may parody that of the 1970 film "Lovers and Other Strangers," containing an all-star cast, a factor which this program also mirrors.

But, according to IMDb, this "MSW" episode contains the smallest credited cast of the series, while not acknowledging several performers having speaking roles. Its opening graphics also differ from the rest, indicating a separate production method than other Season One episodes, even though it is released as "Season One, Episode 05."

Lory Walsh, whose brief acting career spans from 1977-88, Lois Nettleton, who began her television and film acting career in 1953, and Greg Morris, who began his television and film acting career in 1963, have unfortunately since passed. Greg is the father of actor Phil Morris, who guest stars as David Salt in "MSW" episode 10-05, "A Virtual Murder."
18 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Interesting early episode
foxwhowood5 August 2023
Warning: Spoilers
I only saw a few "Murder, She Wrote" episodes when the show was first run. Now that a nostalgia network is running weekly marathons I've been able to catch up on what I missed. I found this early episode interesting because of the way Jessica's character and the show's format haven't been fully formed. A notable example is the college "lecture" in which Jessica acts like a vaudeville comedian complete with exaggerated voices and a fake gun that pops out a "BANG" flag.

I liked the episode overall anyway--EXCEPT for one jaw-dropper. Jessica fields a call from an unknown person who claims to have important evidence. When Jessica agrees to a meeting, suggesting her hotel room, the caller replies, "No, I know this abandoned warehouse down by the waterfront..."

Jessica is a mystery writer, for Pete's sake! Are we really to believe she'd be stupid enough to meet a stranger in the middle of the night at an abandoned dockside warehouse? When she gets to the warehouse the only thing missing is a flashing neon sign pointing at the stair saying, "Get attacked here."

I don't think the character of David the secretary would have flown in later episodes, which preferred to tie up all the loose ends. He's genuinely creepy and we never know if he was a con man or a just a weird guy with a thing for older ladies. It was also odd that the opening murder is a red herring which is explained away in a couple of sentences.

Anyway this is a watchable early episode, and it's fun to see Peter Graves and Greg Morris among the guest stars.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
An early, dark episode of MSW
safenoe23 June 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Andrew Stevens plays David Tolliver, an aspiring university student who gives Jessica the creeps big time. He enters Jessica's hotel room without her knowledge, and at the end of the episode he professes his love for her as she leaves Seattle (for good perhaps). Quite creepy.

Mission Impossible alumnus Peter Graves plays a senior university administrator Dr Edmund Gerard, who enacts his own mission impossible by having a fling with young and nubile Lila Schroeder (Lory Walsh, who sadly died in 2000) at a hotel away from campus. Edmund's secretary Amelia (Lois Nettleton) is very, very angry about this affair, because she loves him very much and she won't let Lila get in the way. Very creepy.

Lila's husband, Jack, is played by Grant Goodeve, who is a favorite of mine from Eight is Enough.

The two nuns at the beginning of the episode were not credited. Gerard says goodbye to them with a "sayonara" but thankfully Jessica corrected him saying they are Chinese. Kind of like saying bonjour to a German or Irishman I guess.
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
One of my favourite 'Murder She Wrote' episodes
TheLittleSongbird8 July 2017
Have always been quite fond of 'Murder She Wrote'. It is a fun and relaxing watch that makes you think as you try to unwind in the evening. If one wants more complex, twisty mysteries with lots of tension and suspense 'Murder She Wrote' may not be for you, but if you want something light-hearted and entertaining but still provide good mysteries 'Murder She Wrote' fits the bill just fine.

"Lovers and Other Killers", as said in the review title, is one of my favourite 'Murder She Wrote' episodes. While enjoying all the episodes up to this point (with my least favourite "It's a Dog's Life" still being decent), while finding they had a few flaws, "Lovers and Other Killers" is the best of the show since the pilot episode "The Murder of Sherlock Holmes".

As ever, "Lovers and Other Killers" looks good. Very nicely shot with attractive locations and fashions. The music has presence but also not making the mistake of over-scoring, while it is hard to forget or resist the theme tune.

The writing is charmingly light-hearted, gently amiable and down to earth but provokes thought too. Loved the dialogues between Jessica and David, some of the best writing of the season and the part with the fake gun. The story is one of the most complex and cleverest, with some genuine tension in places, such as Jessica being pushed down the stairs and one of the show's best ever endings, loved the dark ambiguity which makes the spine tingle.

Angela Lansbury is terrific in one of her best remembered roles (one of the roles that is most closely associated with me at any rate). Peter Graves is similarly very good and Andrew Stevens proves that he actually does have some acting talent in him.

Overall, wonderful and one of my favourites. 10/10 Bethany Cox
19 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
It relies on a confession...which make it very weak.
planktonrules18 October 2022
Andrew Stevens stars in this one and he plays a VERY odd character....a handsome young man who either is turned on by old ladies or who wants to use them. It's really not clear which but what is clear is that the guy is really creepy...and by the end of the show, he's still a strange cypher.

Jessica Fletcher is in Seattle for some lectures at a university. While the lectures go quite well, a murder of a rich old woman has everyone on edge. Jessica is even more so, as she's recently hired a personal secretary (Stevens) and it sure looks likely he's the killer. Of course, on a show like "Murder, She Wrote", it's never this clear and you know there's much more to the story.

This wasn't a bad episode until the finale...in which the real killer confesses everything to Jessica...even though there's no real proof this person did it. This is a common trope in TV shows like this and "Perry Mason"...but a very weak one, as in real life, this very rarely happens and it seemed like a cheesy way to wrap up the show. A rather weak but enjoyable episode.
3 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A first class episode.
Sleepin_Dragon29 October 2017
Jessica lands in Seattle, met by the University Deen she's set to lecture at his university. She's given a secretary, but is shocked when David turns up. Handsome and amiable, David takes Jessica to dinner, but is arrested upon return for murder.

Lansbury is totally delightful, her lecture shows just how brilliant she is, loaded with charisma but what was that bit with the Chinese nuns all about, they're making her a bit syrupy. Andrew Stevens was very good as David, quite captivating, proved he wasn't just a pretty face. The scenes between the two needs excellent, particularly the last one which was loaded with tension and a definite undercurrent.

I very much enjoyed this episode, more serious in tone then the last few episodes, and all the better for it. This is one of my favourite episodes, it's a classic, beautifully made. The slightly ambiguous ending is also quite original, so often everything is nearly tied up, not in this case.

Classic MsW 10/10
16 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Lovers and other killers
coltras3522 May 2022
While in Seattle for a series of lectures, Jessica is drawn into a dangerous case involving young secretary David Tolliver accused of killing his wealthy older lady friend Allison Brevard.

An intriguing addition to MSW with an emphasis on characterisation. There's more depth in that regard, especially Andrew Steven's who plays a young student. He works as a secretary for Jessica. He's quite charming, probably too much so - there's something creepy about him. He suspected by the Lieutenant, played by Greg Morris ( Mission Impossible), as a killer of an old lady and possibly a younger student. But Jessica believes him innocent, and gets pushed down the stairs for her troubles (snooping around). The ending is quite ambiguous in regard to this young secretary - his face expression darkens.

Quite a serious-toned and darkly entry, love and other killers is quite a departure to the lighter entries and is quite an engaging watch.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Gigolo in training
bkoganbing16 March 2018
This episode has JB Fletcher as a guest lecturer at a western university where the president is an old friend of her and her late husband Peter Graves. Graves is a widower who like so many in the series wouldn't mind rekindling something for both of them.

But Angela Lansbury asks for a student assistant she gets a charming, but mysterious male in Andrew Stevens who seems ready to embark on a career as a gigolo. He comes on to her quite subtly like a mack truck.

But he's also the number one suspect in a pair of slayings of women, one being the wife of a campus jock Grant Goodeve with a bad temper. When Lansbury herself is pushed down a flight of stairs he's in the vicinity.

Stevens is the reason to watch this episode. But also I think you'll spot the killer quite clearly here. Not mysterious at all.
4 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed