"Murder, She Wrote" Deadly Lady (TV Episode 1984) Poster

(TV Series)

(1984)

User Reviews

Review this title
8 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
"Hatred, Defiant and Old: Climb Aboard; We're Approaching Cold"
WeatherViolet18 December 2009
And now, in the aftermath of the pilot episode, which launches the "Murder, She Wrote" (or "MSW") series, we arrive at its first weekly episode to be broadcast.

But first, a few prefatory remarks: I have no connection with the production of this series nor any of its fan sites although it can prove interesting to discover those little mistakes which each and every last one of them contain. As we proceed through this series extending episode reviews, should I mistakingly blunder in mixing up one fact with another, please feel free to correct any mishap, as we strive to communicate "what the episodes are all about" as a sort of learning process, based upon content as our source of information (without familiarity of any first-hand "MSW" production source).

By the series start, we are aware that retired schoolteacher-turned-Mystery Novelist Jessica Fletcher (Angela Lansbury) resides in Cabot Cove, Maine, Seat of Cabot Cove County, for which Sheriff Station is based. Sheriff Amos Tupper (Tom Bosley) investigates Cabot Cove County homicides during the first four "MSW" seasons. At times, a deputy takes center stage during a Sheriff Tupper episode, but for the most part, Amos operates without a steady deputy at his side (except in a couple of cases of a recurring role). In this episode, Deputy Emma (Carol Swarbrick) supports the Sheriff. For the remainder of the series, the Cabot Cove Sheriff does have steady deputies, along with extras to function as suspects or victims on occasion.

During Cabot Cove episodes, Jessica keeps company with an authoritative male confidant, to accompany to community functions and to help to study murder evidence. Throughout much of the series, he is the Doctor, who also provides medical examinations upon the victims, or the newspaper publisher, who helps to research and report upon local murders.

But, during Season One, her confidant comes as Fisherman Captain Ethan Cragg (Claude Akins), with whom Jessica conducts fluent conversations about navigating, knot tying, and anything to do with sailing. This knowledge comes in handy when studying evidence in the aftermath of Cabot Cove's premiere murder.

So, before we get into "Deadly Lady," here's a chance to see whether I mix up these three supporting actors: Jonathan Bailey (Tom Bower) as the fisherman who spars with Ethan, Nils Andersen (John Petlock) as the stranger in town, and Elias Cobb (Robert Beecher) as the Medical Examiner? All right, the remainder seems relatively smooth sailing--at least for now....

One day, Jessica receives a visitor, Stephen Earl (Howard Duff), who presents himself as "Ralph," and volunteers to perform odd jobs in exchange for a stipend. Jessica agrees to employ Ralph to assist with her yard-work while she types a potential manuscript or accompanies Ethan on a boating session. She learns little about Ralph but finds his knowledge refreshing and his company enjoyable.

But Ralph suddenly disappears after a team of four sisters dock their craft in Cabot Cove harbor.

When Grace Earl Lamont (Anne Lockhart), Lisa Earl Shelby (Cassie Yates), Maggie Earl (Marilyn Hassett) and Nancy Earl (Doran Clark) report to Sheriff Tupper that their father is nowhere to be found and believed to have fallen overboard during a storm, Sheriff Tupper suspects foul play, and one of the Sisters Earl confesses to shoving her father, Stephen Earl, to his death.

Jessica realizes that the account doesn't add up, without disclosing the fact that she has met Stephen, a.k.a. Ralph, after he was reportedly murdered and manages to convince Amos to release the suspect on the grounds that no crime has been committed.

Grace, Lisa, Maggie and Nancy "Nan" Earl then check into a Cabot Cove motel, at which Brian Shelby (Dack Rambo) arrives to stay with wife, Lisa, during this time of distress, for whether or not her father was murdered, he is still missing, and Jessica has no idea what has become of Ralph/Stephen.

Terry Jones (Richard Hatch) soon arrives in Cabot Cove to meet his fiancée, Nan Earl, this eventually leading Jessica to question everyone connected with the Earl family.

What Jessica learns is that the wealthy widower Stephen protects his daughters to the point of controlling their lives in a manner overbearing to them. While Stephen has destroyed Grace's marriage, he has also prevented Maggie from marrying, and also does everything in his power to keep Terry away from Nan. Lisa, on the other hand, has no intention of allowing Stephen to come between her and Brian although he is suspected of marrying her for a share of her father's great wealth.

During the course of this investigation, the plot thickens when a body is discovered and has a direct bearing upon the Earl family's in-fighting.

When one of the sisters is subsequently arrested for murder, Jessica places together the pieces of the larger puzzle to realize that she has been framed, but suggests that Amos hold her in a cell at any rate, for her own safety.

This episode introduces to the series Anne Lockhart, Cassie Yates, Marilyn Hassett and Doran Clark, as the Sisters Earl. Each of these lovely actresses goes on to appear in at least three "MSW" episodes, often in chameleon-like fashion, sporting a variety of hairstyles, and interchanging playing innocent or guilty or victim, perhaps. And, as this episode indicates, the four are each invariably paired with nice-looking co-stars in future episodes, whether or not any will serve in the function of "Deadly Lady."

Claude Akins, acting in film and on television since 1953, and appearing in four "MSW" episodes in the character of Captain Ethan Cragg, Howard Duff, film and television star since 1947, and Dack Rambo, performing since 1962, and appearing in three "MSW" episodes as different characters, have unfortunately since passed.
24 out of 24 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
An excellent start to the regular series.
Sleepin_Dragon29 October 2017
A stranger turns up at Jessica's home, offering to work for food and shelter. 'Ralph' arrives the same time as wealthy Stephen Earle is swept overboard during a rough storm, leaving his travelling family members to believe he's died.

The first episode in the regular 45 minute format, allowing less time for plot and character build then the previous 130 minute pilot. We're introduced to Jessica's residence, to Cabot Cove, we meet local Sheriff Amos Tupper.

It's a cosy, safe episode, one that focuses on establishing the show, Jessica's role in the community etc. That said it is definitely well paced, it moves along nicely.

Very strong production values, well acted, and a cleverly crafted ending make this an excellent episode. 9/10
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Interesting start for the first season
TheLittleSongbird7 July 2017
Have always been quite fond of 'Murder She Wrote'. It is a fun and relaxing watch that makes you think as you try to unwind in the evening. If one wants more complex, twisty mysteries with lots of tension and suspense 'Murder She Wrote' may not be for you, but if you want something light-hearted and entertaining but still provide good mysteries 'Murder She Wrote' fits the bill just fine.

"Deadly Lady" was an interesting start for the first season. It is not as good as the pilot episode "The Murder of Sherlock Holmes", which is one of my favourites from the show, but everything has to start somewhere and "Deadly Lady" doesn't fare too badly. It certainly does its job in providing some light-hearted fun with a story with enough to keep one engrossed.

It could have been better however. The four sisters are not fully fleshed out enough to make one care for them properly or be interesting as suspects, and the victim is also someone we don't really get to know other than that he's shifty very early on. More tension wouldn't have gone amiss, the build up to the climax was great and very creepy but this is lessened by the too mildly genial way, even for her, Jessica talks to the perpetrator.

And sorry, the guilty signs in my head flashed like mad the minute the murderer gave themselves away by a chance remark (giving away a detail that only they would know), as someone who likes to be shocked when murderers are revealed it was a disappointment for it to be obvious too early all due to a clumsy example of one of the oldest detective solving clichés in the book.

However, "Deadly Lady" is an appealing-looking episode, nicely photographed and it is hard not to love the quaint Cabot Cove setting. The music has presence but also not making the mistake of over-scoring, while it is hard to forget or resist the theme tune.

The writing is charmingly light-hearted and down to earth but provokes thought too. There are some lovely character moments. Jessica is far more interesting than your standard female detective, Ethan is a fun character with some amusing lines and instead of the bumbling sheriff cliché Amos clearly refuses to be treated like a fool (like with the daughters regarding the inquest).

Love, and always have done, how Cabot Cove is like a community, a close one and never gimmicky or acrimonious or anything like that. The standout character moments are Jessica's scenes with Ralph, namely looking close to tears talking about her husband and when she obliterates his story in a way that would make Sherlock Holmes very proud. The story is not perfect but compelled me enough and had a good atmosphere.

Angela Lansbury is terrific in one of her best remembered roles (one of the roles that is most closely associated with me at any rate), and there are standout performances from Tom Bosley, Claude Atkins and Howard Duff. The sisters/daughters are well played too.

To conclude, interesting start for Season 1. 7/10 Bethany Cox
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A dead man dies twice!
cgvsluis20 January 2022
This was another great mystery for the Murder, She Wrote franchise and introduces the fans to Jessica's long time friend and another Cabot Cove local Capt. Ethan Cragg. We are also introduced to the illustrious local sherif, Amos Tupper, played by none other than Tom Bosley (of Happy Days fame).

The episode starts with a major storm or hurricane... "Oh, please. Three more paragraphs and I can go to bed."-Jessica

"Wouldn't ya think people'd have more sense?"-Ethan

After the storm the search for a wealthy gentleman's yacht ensues. Meanwhile, a "drifter" shows up at Jesica's house volunteering to do labor for food. The yacht is found with four daughters on board with the story of the death of their father. There was very little love lost between father and daughters.

"To tell the truth, I don't think there is a one of us that's sorry to see him dead."-Grace Earl.

"Mozart, food for the soul. An empty head is almost as bad as an empty belly."-Ralph

Jesica figures out who her drifter Ralph really is just in time for a second corpse to show up in town.

Great mystery. I love Jessica's home. It seems to be filled with beloved belongings just like my husband and my home. Jessica really pays attention to details...like the bottoms of people's feet.

"You are dotty. Some times you spin around more in a circle than a Roman candle on the Fourth of July, like now."-Ethan.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A man dies...twice!
planktonrules17 October 2022
Despite "Murder, She Wrote" being set in Cabot Cove, Maine, it made no economic sense for the studio to film in New England. After all, it's on the opposite side of the USA. So, many outdoor scenes in Cabot Cove and Miss Fletcher's home were actually filmed in Mendocino, California, an old whaling town that is now a mecca for tourism. In addition, some scenes were filmed in the area around Mendocino...and much of this episode was filmed at Noyo Harbor in Ft. Bragg, California...about 10 miles north of Mendocino. I know this because I live around there and recognized many of the locations...particularly the harbor where I often go on fishing charters. It's a pretty area...just not all that Maine-ish! Oddly, IMDB doesn't list Ft. Bragg in the episode....just Mendocino.

When the story begins, some odd old guy (Howard Duff) is hanging around Jessica's house. Instead of shooing him away, she makes friends with him and she lets him hang around her home...even when she realizes his story about being a hobo is an obvious lie.

At the same, a boat comes into the harbor with a person missing. It seems that his wife and daughters were on the boar and according to them, he fell overboard in a storm and was lost. However, the story also doesn't add up....and soon one admits to having killed him. But there's a HUGE problem...the guy staying with Jessica is this same man...and he obviously wasn't killed out to sea! But, soon after the man IS found dead! Now, the lady who confessed to killing him changes her story...saying she really didn't kill him and it was all some scheme! What is really going on here?!

This story was interesting but its best aspect is that the ending worked VERY well and made Miss Fletcher seem pretty smart! All in all worth seeing...especially if you live nearby and want to see local hangouts, like me.

By the way, you might notice a lot of fog in the episode. Ft. Bragg and Mendocino are among the foggiest places in the country...and finding fogless days would have been difficult, so I understand why they filmed some foggy scenes.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
First episode in Cabot Cove
raymonddgentry21 June 2021
Warning: Spoilers
At the end, Jessica says there are no burglars in Cabot Cove. A lot of murderers, but no burglars.
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Deadly Lady
coltras3522 August 2023
Wealthy financier Stephen Earl is apparently killed in a storm on a boat with his daughters, who will each receive $25 million at his death. Sheriff Amos Tupper (Tom Bosley) suspects foul play and calls Jessica Fletcher in for her advice and he meets the man's daughters, most of whom seem to have little love lost for him. At the same time, a drifter named Ralph (Howard Duff) comes to Jessica's house seeking work and she gives him some work and befriends him.

She sees a picture of the financier in the newspaper and realizes it's the drifter, which means he didn't die in the storm, clearing one of his daughters who confessed to the "murder." However when his body washes up on the beach, Jessica has to find out who killed him and why.

There's a nice chemistry between Howard Duff and Angela Lansbury - what's really impressive is how Jessica figures out that Duff's character is fibbing about being a hobo, but she still kind to him. The mystery itself is quite good, enough twists and turns. A good start for this classic series.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Cabot Cove my home
bkoganbing6 July 2017
Warning: Spoilers
This second episode of Murder She Wrote introduced us to Jessica Fletcher's beloved Maine fishing village Cabot Cove. We also first see Tom Bosley who had that down home Maine accent down to the max as local sheriff Amos Tupper.

Claude Akins makes the first of a few appearances as fishing boat captain Ethan Cragg and he brings news to Jessica Fletcher of a yacht in distress during a hurricane and he was going on a rescue mission.

The next day Howard Duff shows up at the Fletcher home and says he's a drifter but he proves handy around the house so he fixes things and gets breakfast from Angela Lansbury. When that yacht pulls in with four sisters and some spouses on board Duff leaves abruptly. Later he's found on the beach with two bullets in him and one of Frank Fletcher's pipes. Proving most emphatically he was not on the yacht when he met his demise.

That unexpected fact screws up somebody's murder scheme. Sheriff Tupper and Jessica Fletcher form an alliance to solve this case. Not as easy an alliance as it would later become.

The series was off to an interesting start.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed