"Law & Order: Special Victims Unit" Secrets (TV Episode 2001) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Judgement in death
TheLittleSongbird19 March 2020
If asked whether there is a preference for the early seasons of 'Law and Order: Special Victims Unit' or the later seasons, my answer would be the early ones. Despite the production values being more refined later and some of the all-time great guest appearances being in the show's mid-late period, found myself a lot less frustrated in the early seasons by unprofessionalism, nonsense plot strands, too much focus on soapy personal lives and the chemistry and how one connected emotionally to the material were done a lot better early on in my view.

"Secrets" is a good example of this. If not one of the best. After two very good previous episodes, "Secrets" continues the very good, if falling just shy of amazing, streak and actually even better than the previous two episodes and the best episode since "Taken". Like some of the best 'Special Victims Unit' episodes, it has a very sad case and is a hard-hitting watch (almost too painful at times). It's a difficult subject again handled with care and sensitivity, anybody that likes to be moved watching something will love it but anybody that doesn't like frustrating outcomes might find themselves a bit annoyed after watching.

Almost everything is done right. It is slick and doesn't try to do anything too elaborate or overblown, while keeping an intimate atmosphere that doesn't become too confined or static. Locations are not many but are made good use of. The music didn't sound too loud while having enough presence when used to avoid it from being too low key. The script is tight and intelligently written, with the odd scattering of humour like at the swingers' club which included one of Olivia's best lines of Season 2 and also the interplay between Munch and Fin.

The case of "Secrets" is a powerful one and a painful reminder of how victims (and even people in general) are perceived to be based on their past and the consequences of that and how unfair the legal system can be. The perpetrator is also a real creep, one that one roots for him being given his just desserts and given a much harsher sentence than actually given. Nothing is laid on too thick but one feels the full impact of what this situation can bring. The investigating is plentiful and is always absorbing and rings true. All the cast are very good.

What let "Secrets" down somewhat for me was the outcome of the case. Couldn't help feeling that everything about it was an injustice, a clear case of what it appeared to be from the start which was clear premeditation but everything about the case's outcome (not just the sentence and the victim's treatment, but also that bias regarding her past played a part when really it shouldn't have been an issue and even more the actual indictment) rang false for me and slaps one in the face pretty much. Just my view though, am aware that injustices do happen a lot but that doesn't stop one from feeling angry.

On the whole, having said that, very good. 8/10
8 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
The Wall of Separation Crumbles
bkoganbing5 January 2013
Warning: Spoilers
The SVU squad has a great deal of investigating to do and go down many false leads before finally arresting Dean Nolen for murdering a high school teacher. But the woman's reputation is making prosecuting difficult.

Turns out that the teacher who was a really dedicated one also had a secret life as a total nymphomaniac though she was scrupulous in keeping her lives separate. But the wall of separation is crumbling as one of her students finds some nude photographs on the internet. It does beg the question as to how secret your life can be when you let all hang out on the internet.

In the end ADA Cabot just can't get a murder 2 indictment of Nolen who is a real low life because the Grand Jury can't get past the victim's sex life. The fact that he's already stalked another woman doesn't weigh enough with the grand jury to overcome their biases.

It's sad, but true that in criminal justice the victim often goes on trial in the defense's case. This episode illustrates that quite well.
8 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed