"Law & Order: Special Victims Unit" Mean (TV Episode 2004) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
Mean girls
TheLittleSongbird30 December 2020
Any fan of 'Law and Order: Special Victims Unit' that was a long-term victim of bullying is going to find that "Mean" hits home with them. Was expecting it to be an umcompromising and not easy watch episode, mainly because that is true of a vast majority of 'Special Victims Unit' episodes, but was not preparing for it to be to this extent, even the plot synopsis when watching it for the first time years back didn't really prepare me for that.

My feelings are exactly the same on my rewatches, it actually got even better, as well as admittedly more painful, on rewatch. Was happy though on watching "Mean" more than once because it is wonderful in pretty much every area. One of Season 5's best episodes, one of the powerful and the one that actually hit home the most for me as a victim of long-term bullying myself and in a way similar to the bullying depicted here. In my case it got so bad in my GCSE years that suicide was contemplated. Thank goodness that life did improve since, despite moving on the memories remain still.

This is an episode of 'Special Victims Unit' where everything works. It's well made, intimately photographed and slick with no signs of under-budget or anything. The music didn't sound melodramatic or too constant and the direction is accomodating while still having pulse. The writing doesn't ramble, although as usual there is a lot of dialogue to digest, and really provokes thought, disturbs and brings a lump to the throat.

Loved the story furthermore. Not only because it is truly intriguing and provides a lot of daringly scathing insight into American surburban life and what bullying does to somebody, but it did make for emotional viewing. As said, bullying victims are going to find this a quite harrowing watch, especially if the bullies here are exactly like those that bullied you. The ringleader mirrored my primary bully exactly, except it was more verbal and mental than physical in my case. The end twist was a real shock and was edge of the seat-like. One really feels for the victims and roots for the bullies to be put in their place.

Cannot fault the performances and the courtroom scenes are masterpieces of character interaction and tension. Mariska Hargitay and Lindsay Hollister really shine in their intensely poignant scene together and Olivia and Stabler are such a cheering on-worthy team here. Novak has her meatiest appearance here up to this point of the view, where she is at her most authoritative and understandable. This is the episode where Novak may grow on those that disliked her at first, there are fans of the show out there that fit in this category. Kelli Garner more than convincingly plays a vicious character.

Overall, wonderful. 10/10
18 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Psychotic and Charismatic
bkoganbing21 August 2012
Warning: Spoilers
One of the most horrific examples of bullying and the caste system in high school is in this SVU episode. Three girls take a fourth friend and brutally kill her leaving her body in a car trunk. And then they try to pin it on a girl whom they pick on because she's fat. Since they're not exactly criminal geniuses the squad at SVU gets to the heart of things easily enough.

The girls all go to this posh suburban school and they live lives as these teen princesses, the coolest of the cool kids. One of them, Kelli Garner is the leader and she's both psychotic and charismatic. The other two, Arielle Kebbel and Kimberly McConnell, just go along partly out of fear and partly to keep their social standing.

This episode belongs to Diane Neal as ADA Casey Novack. She really nails one of them in a bit of fast thinking as one of them is testifying on the stand. Neal also makes the right decision not to cut a deal with any of them since even the two followers have their share of responsibility. As she so accurately puts it, they're 'mean little girls'.

This episode also has David Thornton who made many appearances as a really smarmy defense attorney. Thornton's character is one you love to hate, one whom folks make lawyer jokes about with gusto.

Justice might be done, but the episode also has a twist and sad surprise ending showing how systemic bullying can be. Don't miss this one.
21 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
The Meanest Girls In School
bkoganbing17 February 2019
The body of a teenage girl with multiple and I mean multiple stab wounds is found in an isolated spot in Manhattan and Mariska Hargitay and Christopher Meloni catch the case due to the victim's age and the bizarre manner of death.

The investigation leads to a certain clique of some very mean girls in their Westchester High School. Stephanie March takes a real personal dislike to them and thinking fast in court does quite a job. You have to see her cross examination of one of them.

Acting honors go to Lindsey Hollister who plays another girl that was picked on by this terrible trio. Her performance will bring a tear to your eye.
8 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Television At Its Dramatic Best!!!!!
mhearn11 February 2006
Warning: Spoilers
"Mean" is not only the finest episode ever in any of the "Law and Order" series, but is extremely daring television in its stinging indictment of America's suburban lifestyle--indictments unfashionable to make in this overly politcally correct age. It is mericiless in cataloging the more insidious ways school children can now persecute one another--not just through verbal contact at school, but through cell phone and email messages, and cyber photos that violate a person's privacy. The Agnes Linskys of this age have it worse than those in my day. I contend that the writers of "Mean" based their story on the 1992 Shanda Sharer case. Sharer was a twelve year old girl from Madison, Indianna who went out riding one January night with her teen-aged friends--Melinda Loveless, Hope Rippey, Laurie Tackett, and Toni Lawrence, all under eighteen--only to be bound, locked in the car trunk, driven to a remote area known as the Witches Castle, where she was removed, tortured, set on fire and left to die. The motive, like "Mean," centered around jealousy on the part of ringleader Melinda, except that here it was lesbian jealousy rather than heterosexual. A question this episode asks but does not answer is this--In a siutation like this, where Britany, Paige and Andrea deservedly get their judicial comeuppance, why are their parents not prosecuted, tried, convicted and jailed for raising such monsters? They should be, because it was the American suburban Entitlement they heaped upon their daughters from birth that transformed them into the monstrous bitches seen in "Mean." And the cycle of parents still doing this, and girls evolving into monsters, continues today; so that America, rather than improving, only worsens in its mirroring of Agnes Linsky's contention that it is "never going to stop."
36 out of 46 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Everyone will know a mean girl
greyKbarclay21 March 2024
Warning: Spoilers
This is most definitely one of my favourite episodes of Special Victims Unit, and the plot here is something that is universal across people; I do believe that the vast majority of people would've experienced the wrath of a mean girl. This is one of the more comedic episodes of SVU in my opinion, the same dark humour that this show is typically filled with.

This episode came out before the hit film "Mean Girls" did, which only further demonstrates the fact that people have a tendency to think back to high school life. Huang pops in sporadically, as he does in many episodes, with small but vitally important pieces of information. The thing that he says regarding the behavioural differences between female amad males, will make complete sense to the audience, as it is, in fact, true.

This episode, will it may be quite predictable in the way that it is leading, towards the supposed best friends of the victim but they did attempt to lead the audience astray with a long term victim of bullying, but of course we eventually land on the charismatic, sociopathic leading of what turned out to be more of a pack than a friendship group.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed