"Law & Order: Criminal Intent" Mad Hops (TV Episode 2004) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
One of the better episodes
PeterNelson27 May 2008
Even though this episode was one of the ones totally missing Eames (Kathryn Erbe), it is still one to watch. Cool story arc, Vincent D'Onofrio put in another very good performance, and there are a couple guest stars whose presence gives this episode extra interest.

We see John Krasinski in one of his first pro roles, filmed in late 2003. (This would be almost 2 years before starting in his role as Jim Halpert in "The Office.") John was playing a high school basketball player. Having missed the opening credits, I was surprised to see John as one of the high school players, and for that first instant it seemed like it was Jim joking around. (It was like when Jerry Seinfeld and George would flash back to their high school days, and you see these way-grown actors done up in their high school clothes and hairstyles.) Your subjective reaction may differ, but you'll have to agree that John looked a bit too old for the role, at age 24 having a full face and, in the outside scene, in need of a shave. Otherwise, sure, he delivered his lines like a teen--though then again, there were a couple glimmers of more mature facial expressions.

Playing the coach was Jude Ciccolella. In 2003 Jude was in the middle of his long run as Mike Novick on "24." Some this coach character's reactions will remind you of how Novick reacts to things, of course, so those make interesting cross-references to give you insight into Jude the actor. Jude gets to show us other bits, too, since the coach is not bound like Novick to the need for tact, observing White House protocol, and generally being in the service of politicians whose needs Novick must think of before his own. For example, this coach can be a total hard guy at times in ways you don't get to see with Novick. Sure, there are times when Novick gets forceful even with his superiors, but not with the type of disregard Jude has coach showing those he's getting tough with.

Even before either John or Jude show up in the epi, though, it was a pretty engrossing story unfolding. It is a trademark of classic "L&O: Criminal Intent" to present a lengthy sequence of clues before the detectives--or we viewers--have much idea what's really going on. In this epi, for some reason, though, it was particularly fun seeing the clues tumble down as Goren and temporary partner Bishop (Samantha Buck) hop from borough to borough following the leads stemming from the epi-opening murder. Nothing too obvious, nothing too far-fetched. Naturally, Goren figures out a couple things because he knows stuff that Bishop and the captain don't, but they aren't way out over the top.

Favorite Vincent acting moment in this epi: Goren yields to an early interviewee and is personally wide open while this person perceptively and succinctly summarizes the young Goren's probable difficulty with authority figures. At the end of this cold dressing-down of an analysis, Goren is completely taken aback--great moment.

Something visual to remark upon: Get Bishop under the lights in the dark blue morgue together with Medical Examiner Rodgers (Leslie Hendrix), and all that red hair is just blazing.
16 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Basketball's dark side
TheLittleSongbird3 August 2020
Like with the previous episode "F.P.S", "Mad Hops" has a subject that is not an area of expertise of mine and not something that fascinates me on a daily basis. Am not sporty in general even, while hardly inactive. So there was the risk of it going over my head. There wasn't so much of a risk of "Mad Hops" leaving me as cold though, as basketball has been portrayed a good deal in film and television and often entertainingly and interestingly on either side of good and bad.

"Mad Hops" is no exception. By all means though, it is nowhere near one of the best episodes of 'Law and Order: Criminal Intent' and is not one of the best of the mostly solid Season 3. To me, it was a lesser episode of the season (though actually not the worst) but namely because the season's quality was generally at a high standard and brilliant at its best in primarily the second half. If to sum "Mad Hops" up in short terms, it would be decent but not great.

Am admittedly still not the biggest fan of the chemistry/relationship between Goren and Bishop. Excepting moments in "Sound Bodies" and "F.P.S" it never completely gelled enough, the tension between them could have been sharper and wasn't as appealing as well contrasted as the chemistry between Goren and Eames and the spark that was there with him and Eames is somewhat missing. If Bishop was a more interesting character in general, it may have helped.

The ending also did feel a bit too rushed and on the too neat side. The conflict between the coach and the mother could have been delved into somewhat more and had more tension.

On the other hand, the production values continue to be slick and intimate without being too much so. The music is not overdone in tone, placement or orchestration, even in places where there was the danger of doing so (i.e. final revelation). The direction is not dull while still letting the drama breathe. The script mixes entertainment value and tautness very well and handled with tact and intelligence. Enjoyed the amusing jokes. The story is mostly very well executed with an intriguing case. What lifted "Mad Hops" and the story above the ordinary is some nice revealing character development for Goren.

Primarily in his history with basketball, with the conflict between him and the coach revealing a lot and having the tension slightly missing in the one between the latter and the mother. It helps too that the coach himself is a sinister opponent that makes one uneasy for a while about basketball. Goren's attitude towards authority also fascinates. Vincent D'Onofrio can't be faulted and it was interesting for another character to do the dressing down to him and do what Goren does himself when interrogating. Jude Ciccolella is also splendid and relishes making Powell as contemptible as possible.

In conclusion, decent but not great. 7/10
8 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A Player's Dream
pepper_f7 April 2022
Warning: Spoilers
In this episode, Goren and Bishop investigate the murder of a private investigator and are soon lead to a missing basketball player as well.

I really liked this episode although I feel like there should've been more to the conflict in my opinion. I'm not sure what it is but I feel like perhaps the conflict between Coach Powell and the mom should've had more "spark" to it if that makes any sense. I did like how the antagonist sorta delved into Goren's mind just like Goren did. Did like the case overall, it has its usual characteristic twists and turns and whatnot.

Overall, "Mad Hops" is a pretty good episode but I feel like there could've been more to some elements of its plot.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
No heart for the game
bkoganbing19 October 2016
Two bodies turn up in the Criminal Intent episode. The first is a private investigator who was looking into various schools for recruiting practices. This second was that of a promising high school basketball player.

Vincent D'Onofrio is still partnered temporarily with Samantha Buck and it's the PI they get first. It all goes back to high school coach Jude Ciccolella who is ending some 3 decades as a coach in the New York City public school system.

The Board of Education has rules about high schools recruiting, but coaches do get around them. Ciccolella I'm sure is not the only one who flouts the rules.

But it's far more than that. He's got some post retirement plans involving one of the other players that is the reason for the homicides. Kind of creepy when all is revealed.

Ciccolella also gets a bit under Bobby Goren's skin when he discovers that Goren played in school but gave it up. Goren's psyche is very deep as viewers know, but Ciccolella also can't imagine someone not obsessed with the game as he is.

It's an interesting story especially when all is revealed.
11 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Huge Goren fan BUT...
Neuro-49 January 2021
New lil' chickie partner (this episode she swings her crayola maroon ponytail about 20 times). Who decided to create a 20-something hipster chick as an established detective? I love L&O but this jumps the shark.
4 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed