"Law & Order: Criminal Intent" Badge (TV Episode 2002) Poster

(TV Series)

(2002)

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
Twisted
TheLittleSongbird21 November 2019
As well as being someone who loves 'Law and Order: Criminal Intent' (especially in the earlier seasons), and the original 'Law and Order' and prime-'Special Victims Unit', another main reason for seeing Season 1's twentieth episode "Badge" was for Viola Davis. Just find her to be an immensely gifted actress, and among the better ones working today. It also fascinated me seeing her in one of her earliest television roles and even earliest credits.

"Badge" had a very interesting and harrowing-sounding idea for a story, so coupled with my love of the show and that Davis was guest starring expectations were high. Expectations that were not only met but exceeded. Season 1 of 'Law and Order: Criminal Intent' had a good share of great and more episodes and not a bad one in any way, and "Badge" is among the best of the whole season and along with "Maledictus" it is one of the best episodes since "Homo Homini Lupis".

There are many reasons as to why "Badge" is a must see. A big asset is Davis, who is brilliant in a performance that's sinister, oddly amusing at other times and on occasion moving, creating a character far less one-dimensional as one may think considering the type of role she's playing. One of my favourite guest supporting turns of Season 1 and of the show in general. Her character is also one of the most fascinating supporting characters of the season, one where her actions are uncondonable but considered right by her. Another big asset is Goren, absolutely love him as a character and his eccentric ways of deduction but here on top of that it is Vincent D'Onofrio's comic timing that shines, the Boston accent is a scream, as is his impression of a cop that's rude and arrogant, and he is even more eccentric than ever.

Really love that "Badge" is one of those episodes where the perpetrator doesn't crack so easily and where Goren, like when he is psychoanalyzed, is thrown by them, an interesting change. The case was compelling, tight in pace, and how it is solved and how it comes together has always been a pleasure with this show. How the perpetrator is caught is wonderfully elaborate and Eames' role sees some of her most amusing dialogue. As well as the tension and intrigue, it was great that there were entertaining moments. Eames' dialogue, Goren's accent and bad cop routine and one of the show's best guest star lines in the Babyface quip.

Production values are still high, some occasional jumpy editing aside, while the music doesn't intrude and the writing piles on the tautness and intrigue without stopping. Kathryn Erbe contrasts with the ever great D'Onofrio more than nicely and she shines in her chemistry with him.

Summing up, one of the season's best. 10/10
20 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Outstanding
midatlanticmike2 March 2017
Who writes these shows? As with all the rest... this one is brilliant. Innocent people killed... no one knows why. Lots of distracting details. Then an added bonus: Viola Davis?!? One of the best actresses on earth was busy showing her talent long before she became famous. Every Law and Order Criminal intent is good. This one is great!!
23 out of 24 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Twisted values
bkoganbing8 May 2016
The family annihilation of an auditor in the New York City Comptroller's office made to look like a murder/suicide gets the attention of the Major Case Squad in this episode. In fact this was a carefully planned hit done over several weeks in not only the physical murder itself, but careful assassination of the victim's character to show him capable of such an act so it would not be questioned. Or so the planners thought it would not be questioned.

The center of it all is Viola Davis who is a former NYPD officer who now works as school security. Working for the city full time and collecting a pension is called double dipping and against the law. Kathryn Erbe mentions her father got caught at it and had to return monies to the city.

In fact there are several doing it and she's the ringleader. Davis has also found other ways to make her school security job pay quite lucratively.

The women who did this is also a loving mom who is supporting two daughters and her own mother as a single mom. All this is to insure a good life for her kids. What a twisted sense of values she has.

This episode should be seen for the elaborate sting that Goren and Eames use to get Davis and for Davis's own performance.
19 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Detective, arrest thyself!
raeames19 December 2021
Warning: Spoilers
By now viewers who have followed this series from the start will have accommodated themselves to its quirks and maybe even come to love them.

The somewhat predictable attitudes of the characters, particularly Eames, which may reflect the ideological prejudices of the writers. The plots "ripped from the headlines" which gives them a compelling immediacy. The implausible semi-omnipotence of Goren in the arts and sciences, Renaissance Man as a middle-ranking police officer. That's before you touch on his genius in criminal psychology which seems to have a 100% success rate as he closes each episode by obtaining a confession of guilt. He's a character you want to be able to believe in but one aspect of his behaviour makes each episode unrealistic and that's never more blatant than in this one.

He's forever interfering in the details of crime scenes. Just because he puts on a pair of latex gloves wouldn't give him the right to compromise the forensics, which would be dealt with a dedicated team in special clothing and have to be confirmed by a post-mortem.

Yet Goren walks all over each crime scene, prodding the corpse and even pulling things out of it. As if he was a qualified expert and the only one necessary. In this episode he even remarks that the crime scene has been interfered with extensively and concludes that the perpetrator must have inside knowledge, indicating that he or she is likely to be a police officer.

Since this is the way he invariably behaves in each episode, perhaps he should arrest himself.
3 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed