Deadwood (TV Series) A Lie Agreed Upon: Part II (2005) User Reviews

"Wish her aim was as accurate with her thumb" (dialog)

[A_Different_Drummer · 7/10 · 18 January 2015]

Kudos again to the writing team.

After what seems a slow start, the episode catches fire at the end as the viewer realizes, belatedly, that this has been one of the most artfully written scripts in the series.

It is like watching a master weaver make a coat. The threads seems to go nowhere ... until you suddenly have something to wear.

The expression "warp and woof" actually appears in the script, as do many other others of equally dubious historical measure, but, bottom line, this episode is a writers' dream.

Olyphant's character (one of the most righteous and upright characters since the bygone days of the 50s westerns) wrestles with two problems that seem un-related. But to the writers, they are one and the same. And this becomes clear by the conclusion.

Also noticed for the first time how the writing team uses the marvellous Ian McShane like the Chorus in a Greek play, or Mr. Interlocutor in a Minstrel Show. He is both a character on his own, but also the voice of the narrator as he says whatever passes over his mind, and so brings the audience with him.

Art.

"I'd settle for a vigorous hand-holding."

[Hey_Sweden · 8/10 · 17 April 2024]

Seth, continuing to behave more erratically, and Alma face an uncertain future in terms of their relationship. He leaves it up to her to make a decision; meanwhile, he's primed for another confrontation with Al. Jane reappears in the camp, in a drunken state, but pulls herself together after some examination by Cochran, and backs up Seth (along with Charlie and a still-recuperating Sol) when he goes to see Al at the Gem. Tensions between Dan and Silas come to a head, resulting in the death of an incidental character.

The non-stop profanity is amusing, as always, but one realizes that, even when the writers don't fall back on it, the scripts still have quite a poetic and thoughtful quality. That is definitely the case here, especially when Al not only gives an account of the confrontation to Merrick, but muses on the conditions & future of the camp. And there is still time for humor - the placement of a prostitutes' thumb is quite amusing indeed.

The acting from all concerned is once again simply excellent, with a number of the principals given real showcase moments. Ian McShane (Al) in particular does a wonderful job right near the end.

I will say, also, that it's nice seeing Jane again, given the fact that she was missing in action for a while.

Eight out of 10.

disagree with previous

[anthonyleerogers-03867 · 4/10 · 3 July 2016]

a marvelous show, but what happened this episode? It seems like all the characters are slightly changed. Trixie is the most affected, dropping F bombs for no reason and just being aggressive and out of character. I love the shakespearean casserole this whole show is baked in, but for the first time, this episode just lost my interest and seemed like the writing team let the interns do "Pt.2". I hope season 2 gets better. (and its funny, i didn't notice a problem with the setup episode of Pt.1.

Its like everyone is on drugs and their logic is messed up. Seth is behaving more like a robot, but without the underlying fundamentalism that makes him a strong-silent-likeably character.

Of course, just my opinion. Anyone agree?