"Cold Case" Committed (TV Episode 2005) Poster

(TV Series)

(2005)

User Reviews

Review this title
3 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
My mother
jotix1001 February 2010
Warning: Spoilers
Bettie, a young mother, is seen with her son, Otis, in the kitchen of her house. She is a good baker, judging by the many pastries she has made. As a touching finish, she decides to add a flammable liquid to the cake she just got out of the oven and in the process, she ignites, and almost burns the house. It is clear Bettie has a mental problem. Her husband decides to commit her to a mental institution where she is supposed to be helped.

As Bettie arrives in the mental facility, she becomes involved with some of the inmates. Carmen, a talented painter, and Zelda, a woman with a vivid imagination, are her pals since her arrival. Carmen is a rebel. Zelda also speaks her mind. Bettie who doesn't respond well to treatment, is given iced baths, something the doctors decide will help it. Anton, an orderly in the hospital befriends Bettie.

When one of the former inmates is found dead, it is determined she has assumed another inmate identity. The cold case begins the investigation. The issue that triggered the death of Bettie has to do with a lobotomy performed on one of the inmates.

The episode written by Liz Garcia, a frequent collaborator of the series, was directed by Alex Zakrzewski, who also has been involved with the show. The acting is first rate, as most of the episodes clearly show. This one counts with a fine Natasha Gregson Wagner, the daughter of Natalie Wood, who bears an uncanny resemblance to her mother. Also on hand, Diane Ladd, who has appeared in the program before. Rebecca Lowman is appealing as Bettie. Al Pugliesi, Laurie Johnson and Charles Robinson are also on hand in supporting roles.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
The harm we do without knowing better
jsrtheta5 April 2024
Warning: Spoilers
This is the first episode I ever saw of this series, years ago. It was on again today, and it still staggers with its impact.

The story concerns a woman, clearly mentally ill, who was committed to a mental health facility back in the 1950s. She has nearly burned her house down with her and her son in it. She had no harmful intent, but also no appreciation of the reality of her actions and their consequences.

The doctors and nurses are not evil either. They do things with the best of intentions, and the worst of outcomes. In the case of our protagonist, the young mother, they are helpless, clueless. A horror ensues, and the facility is impotent in its efforts at fixing her.

I am being purposely vague, because you really have to see this to appreciate its beauty and its horror. Because there are many things we can't fix, and the harder we try the worse the patient suffers. So does everyone else. We desperately want an answer, a fix. And all too often, there isn't one.

Only watch this if you can handle the ineffably sad. If you can, it is more than worth it.

This is a hard watch, but ultimately worth the time and the tears. It rerminds us of our own inadeequacy.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Most beautiful character of the series Warning: Spoilers
This has been the best Cold Case episode so far, featuring perhaps one of the saddest outcomes. Betty, a sweet and loving mother is victim of her "imperfection" and at the same time she gives everything so her son may have a better life. I did love this episode, sensitive and humane, but at the same time cruel.

I admire the staff's ability to choose and screen actors and actresses to play the roles, in this episode the choice was perfect. I loved the actress who played Betty, beautiful, sweet and true. A pity we don't find many people people like that character in real life.

Thank God the horrible lobotomy is no longer applied to 'imperfect' persons.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed