"Bewitched" Samantha's Secret Is Discovered (TV Episode 1970) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Terrific Mabel Albertson and a veteran character actress walk off with this episode.
mark.waltz23 January 2020
Warning: Spoilers
That's Nydia Westman, an Una Merkel like character actress whose nervous energy in classic comedies of the 1930's and 40's made her a fan favorite even if you didn't know her name. She plays the senile old lady in the rest home where Mrs. Stephens (Albertson) plants herself after she believes that she's fooled herself into thinking that daughter-in-law Samantha is a cauldron stirring, card carrying witch. It all starts off as the battle of the witches (oops, wits) as Samantha and Endora battle over which set of furniture Samantha will entertain her mother in. Endora wants the Louis XV style, and back and forth the different furniture styles flip until Phyllis walks in and faints. Darrin's father (Roy Roberts) is rushed over to find out what is wrong with his wife, and in therapy, Dr. Bernie Koppel (who also played the warlock pharmacist in other episodes), does his best to help his patient. But overhearing her husband and son discussing her case with him, Phyllis decides to disappear, and it's up to Samantha to find her mother-in-law and prove to her that she's A-Okay as well as get forgiveness from the witches' committee who took away some of her powers for revealing her identity to a mortal.

As always, any scenes between the two mother-in-law's are great here as Mabel Albertson and Agnes Moorehead had terrific chemistry working off each other. But the fun really starts when Phyllis is found sitting in a wheelchair, covered in a blanket, resting up and trying to recover the sanity she thinks she is losing. Along comes the forgetful Bryant, and the exchange between her and Albertson is very funny, especially when Bryant helps herself to Albertson's pills and begins to see things (thanks to Samantha's interference), resulting in Samantha making another switch. Realistically, there could have been some serious medical points made about Phyllis having hallucinogenics rather than tranquilizers, but Samantha, knowing that it was her hocus pocus which changed the drugs, guides the doctor's suggestions to make Albertson happy to realize that she was not losing her mid and just happy to be well. It's a fun episode that is another great indicator of why this sitcom had not only the best regulars but recurring players and guest stars as well.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Hidden giveaway
LovesMyGarden4 April 2022
Warning: Spoilers
This episode certainly had it's funny moments, but there was also a moment that paid homage to the show being shot in California, not Connecticut where the Stephens lived. When Sam goes to the 'rest home' to retrieve Mrs. Stephens, she allows the other patient to see oranges falling off, and back onto the tree. Orange trees don't grow in Connecticut but of course they do in California.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
I laughed so hard my eyes were tearing...Very funny!
MyHoneyCJ6 January 2010
I have always loved Bewitched. It's comedy is timeless. Many of today's "comedies" are very dark, or come at someone's expense (by being a joke themselves) but that isn't the case with Bewitched. It can be enjoyed by the entire family which is very refreshing. This episode centers around Samantha's mother-in-law, Phyllis, who in many episodes catches on that something isn't right - or she actually sees some very strange things happening - but she always winds up thinking that she's "losing it." The scenes with Phyllis and Mrs. Quigley had me laughing so hard I was in tears! The entire cast is exceptional and they all play off each other very well. Definitely try to catch this episode, it's very entertaining!!
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Hallucenogenic episode from the long-running series...
moonspinner556 January 2010
My biggest complaint with "Bewitched" was always that it didn't utilize Samantha's magic enough. To see her arrive home winded after a long day of shopping and running errands, it's almost painful to then hear her say she has to make dinner for Darrin and his parents (surely a zapped-up roast with all the trimmings wouldn't be too far out of line!). This episode from the series' iffy sixth season (featuring the new Darrin, the constipated Dick Sargent) gets off to a great start with Samantha and Endora arguing over the Stephens' furniture (Endora prefers Louis XV). With the home decor rapidly changing back and forth between styles, Darrin's mother comes in (without knocking) and witnesses the magic, ending in one of her fainting spells. The redressed set for the Stephens' home is exquisite--and provides a great visual kick--however writers Lila Garrett and Bernie Kahn don't know what to do for a topper. Samantha and Darrin decide to tell his woozy mother that Sam's really a witch, however the Witches Council doesn't approve of this (Endora: "Remember the beating we took at Salem!") and temporarily relieves Samantha of her powers. Meanwhile, Mrs. Stephens ends up in a rest home (which looks like the front lawn of Sam and Darrin's house!) and Samantha decides to rescue her via an odd solution: blame all the hocus-pocus on a bottle of hallucinogens! William Asher's direction skitters along, losing Endora in the parade of different ideas, while Mabel Albertson's mother-in-law looks appropriately confused (after her scene with psychiatrist Bernie Kopell, I was confused as well). Sargent, for his part, is looser than usual, but the main plot--Samantha revealing her powers to mortals--isn't fully realized. After all the magic we've seen her do, a smashed/replaced vase is rather anticlimactic.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
The consequences of the truth
bribabylk14 January 2022
Warning: Spoilers
There's a funny, brief moment in this episode, after Darrin and Sam have confessed all to Darrin's mother about Sam's supernatural nature, that provides a glimpse into what life would be like for the Stephens if the magical cat really was let out of the bag. Mrs. Stephens (Darrin's mother) promises to keep the Big Secret, but of course as soon as her husband walks through the door she blabs, and then, overjoyed to have her very own magical servant--er, daughter-in-law, starts making noises about how whenever she needs something she'll just call Sam to come over and twitch her nose. She's only known about Sam being a witch for three minutes, and she's already envisioning a life of luxury and ease; you can hear it in her voice. Thank goodness a fix is found for this ill-conceived truthfulness blunder; Sam and Darrin would never have had a moment's peace again.

Also, it should be noted that the famously fickle supreme overlords of witchdom, the Witches Council (hey, I thought the witch community was governed by a monarchy; what happened to Queen Ticheba from the 4th season?), change their minds about preventing Sam from using her powers in front of mortals almost as soon as they enact the decree: at the rest home, Sam changes Mrs. Stephens' tranquilizers to hallucinogens, if not right before the eyes of the three mortals present, then certainly under their noses.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
WHAT WERE THEY THINKING?
parkerr863029 February 2022
Warning: Spoilers
At one point or another, a long-running tv series will have an episode or two that makes you wonder what the heck they were thinking! This is one of them.

After Darrin's mother accidentally witnesses Samantha performing magic, Darrin and Sam decide the time has come to confess the truth to her, that Sam is a witch. This angers the Witches Council, who fix it so Samantha can never again perform magic in front of mortals (except Darrin). Thus, old Mrs. Stephens ends up in a nursing home for being hallucinatory. Yuk yuk, that's supposed to be funny. Only it isn't.

Years after the show went off the air, Bewitched's producers and writers told interviewers that they ran out of ideas in later years, which was why there were so many recycled stories toward the end. But they couldn't recognize new ideas when they were right in front of them! Having Darrin's parents find out about Samantha could have opened up a whole new world of comic entanglements in future episodes, but this was not to be.

Consequently, as Samantha's secret stays secret after all, this episode is totally pointless.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed