"Battlestar Galactica" Murder on the Rising Star (TV Episode 1979) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Apollo goes full Perry Mason
Fluke_Skywalker11 January 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Plot; After an intense game of Triad (similar to basketball, but much more physical), Starbuck is accused of murder when one of his opponents, a particularly dirty player, is found dead. Apollo is tasked with defending him and sets out to find the real murderer.

After several months away, I'm back to my watch-thru of the original Battlestar Galactica. With Baltar in custody and the Cylons in the rearview mirror, the focus once again is less on space action (of which there's none here) and more on personal drama. That's both good and bad, as variety is great, but not so great as Vipers squaring off against Raiders. Though the setup is eye-rollingly contrived, the basic execution of the whodunit stuff isn't bad. They make a half-hearted attempt to make us believe that Starbuck could be guilty, but come on! The real story is solving the mystery, and though we're talking Scooby Doo level detective work here it works; at least for me. Stars Dirk Benedict and Richard Hatch each do fine work (relatively speaking) and it was nice to see Herbert Jefferson's Lt. Boomer character get some solid screen time. As always Lorne Greene adds a touch of gravitas and John Colicos devours scenery like a well-coiffed Pac-Man as the evil Baltar.

  • Episode features a few familiar faces in guest stars Brock Peters (To Kill a Mockingbird, and perhaps most importantly, the voice of Darth Vader in the Star Wars radio dramas) and Lyman Ward (Ferris Bueller's dad). 


  • Apparently a shower in the Galacticaverse is known as a "Turbo wash", which sounds like a place you take your car to wash off the winter salt.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Not one of the stronger episodes!
mm-3929 June 2023
Warning: Spoilers
Murder on the Rising Star is not one of the stronger episodes! Starts with a game of triad and the viewer discovers Starbuck has a bitter rival! Not a great sci fi story, but a great 70's murder mystery episode. Starbuck acts recklessly and Apollo act as Starbuck defendant. Apollo is in full Mike Hammer mode as the rival's true character is un raveled with a casino mystery. A 70's formulated murder mystery of trying too draw the true killer out. Well acted, directed, and scripted episode. Murder on the Rising Star is more of a Murder on the Orient Express murder mystery than Battlestar Galactica episode. If your going skip an episode this could be the one, but still entertaining. 7 stars.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Starbuck Is Not Above The Law!
JasonDanielBaker5 February 2015
Starbuck and Apollo engage in a gruelling game of "Triad" (Combination of guerrilla basketball with smash-mouth rugby) with a pair of driven opponents Barton (W.K.Stratton) and Ortega (Frank Ashmore who would go on to appear in the sci-fi series "V").

Ortega has a long-standing feud going with Starbuck all the way back to their days as cadets and dogs him with late hits throughout the much anticipated and widely viewed match, which is televised live across the fleet.

Starbuck is heard threatening Ortega twice and is separated from attacking Ortega by Apollo on the Triad court and then by Cassiopeia in the area near the locker rooms after Starbuck and Ortega have both been thrown out of the game.

When Ortega is murdered in his locker-room Starbuck is seen fleeing the area. His laser pistol is tested and identified as the murder weapon. Adama confines him to the brig pending trial. Apollo acts as Starbuck's defense lawyer and tries to find out who really killed Ortega.

This episode which crosses the genre of science fiction with murder mystery and courtroom drama happens to be one of the more highly regarded of the original series amongst fans of science fiction. So much so in fact that elements of it seem to have been ripped off for the staging of Star Trek 6: The Undiscovered Country in which Brock Peters who plays Solon here also co-starred as Admiral Cartwright.

What we see in this particular episode is some sense of what the justice system in the Colonial Fleet is like. Adama is both Chief of police and judge/jury from what we see here in addition to being it's military Commander-in-chief.

We also see a Colonial warrior with uncharacteristically villainous tendencies in the person of Ortega, a pilot with character traits (gambling, womanizing etc) similar to Starbuck but one who consistently takes things too far.

Ortega is a reflection of Starbuck but the differences in the characters emphasize the heroism of Starbuck and expands the depth of personalities aboard the Colonial fleet. On the original series base human instincts were not as pronounced.

Dirk Benedict was hardly the prize choice of producers in casting the show (Lorne Greene was) but by its end he had become its drawing card. The show perhaps revolved around him a little too much at times yet tended to lag in those moments when he was not on screen.
9 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Murder mystery
keyope25 January 2019
Battlestar Galactica was in a real run of form at this point. This episode is a really good murder mystery with a few nice twists and turns. Starbuck has a falling out with another player in the odd, somewhat camp sports game he and Apollo participate in from time to time. The guy he falls out with ends up dead and Starbuck is the number one suspect. Naturally, instead of hiring a proper lawyer to defend him, he gets Apollo to do it, with Boomer as his investigator.

What follows is a classic Columbo style investigation with a very satisfying finale. One of the best episodes in the series, in my opinion.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed