"Angel" Birthday (TV Episode 2002) Poster

(TV Series)

(2002)

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
9/10
Another Birthday in the Buffyverse
katierose29524 February 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Birthdays in the Buffyverse are not a time for celebration. They're a time to hunker down and pray. Something always goes wrong and wackiness always ensues. (See BTVS season two's "Suprise" and "Innocence," season three's "Helpless," season four's "A New Man," season five's "Family" and "Blood Ties," and season six's "Older and Faraway.") Likewise, alternate realities are usually bad news. (See BTVS season three's "The Wish" and "Dopplegangland.") So, when we get an episode called "Birthday" and Cordy casting ANOTHER lets-change-the-past wish, all we can do is brace for the mayhem. Really, this is an excellent episode that redefines Cordelia. After this she's got the headaches caused by her visions under control, but she's also part demon... And starting down a very dangerous path. If you're planning to watch any of season four, you need to see this episode as it sets up a lot of stuff. It also reinforces how much Angel needs Cordy if he's going to keep fighting and stay connected to the world. Without Cordelia, he'd fall apart. Something that will be revisited again in season five.

Basically, "Birthday" revolves around Cordelia's visions. She has one right in the middle of the party that Team Angel throws her. Cordy is thrown backwards by the force of the vision and is knocked out cold. When she wakes up, she's outside of her body in an astral plane. As the others try to wake her body, they begin to realize how ill the visions have been making her. Wes is afraid that she's dying and Angel demands that Lorne contact the conduit to the PTB so he can beg for Cordy's life.

Meanwhile, Cordy is desperate to tell them about her vision. She tries to write the address of the girl in danger on a wall by briefly taking over Angel's body, but the others don't notice. Skip, the demon from the hell dimension in "That Vision Thing," shows up to talk to Cordy. He explains that the visions will kill her and she must give them up. If she never met Angel, than she'd be safe. She'd be a popular actress, with a legion of fans and no life threatening headaches. After Cordy misunderstands Angel's argument with the conduit, she agrees to rewrite history.

Suddenly, she's starring on her own TV show "Cordy!" and loving the limelight. She doesn't remember her old life. Still, there's a small part of her knows that something's not right. She ends up at the Hyperion and sees the address on the wall. She goes to help the girl and runs into Wes and Gunn. They're fighting demons and after reminiscing about Sunnydale, Wes takes Cordy to see Angel. He has the visions and they've driven him crazy. Cordelia is horrified and kisses Angel. She regains her memory and demands that Skip return her to her old life. He says that it will only work if she agrees to be part demon. Cordy agrees and wakes up in her old life, surrounded by her friends.

There are some great parts in this episode. I'm always happy to "see" Dennis. And Wes is kind of funny as a hard, one-armed demon hunter. (He lost a limb battling that Kungi demon back in "Parting Gifts," since Cordy wasn't there to get the vision.) It's sort of a sign of things to come. And I really like Cordy's cake with the super hero on it. Also, I love Skip in this episode, talking about movies and joking around with Cordy. (And it's sort of ironic that he liked the Agents in "The Matrix," considering Trinity shoots one in the head, as a recall.) Also, Doyle is mentioned several times in this episode and I'm glad that the show remembers how important he was to Angel and Cordy. Plus, I'm always up for some Sunnydale references and Cordy and Wes reminiscing about their kiss in "Graduation Day Part Two" is hilarious.

Mostly, I like Angel and Cordy in this episode, though. Personally, I think that Angel loves Cordelia more than anyone. The thought of losing her nearly drives him insane. His scene at her bedside is really beautiful... In a strange sort of way. He does start it with "Cordelia, you really p*ss me off." Then, he tells the conduit that he's more scared of Cordy dying than she is. "What's that mean?" He asks softly and it just breaks my heart. Cordy meanwhile gives up everything she ever wanted and sacrificed her humanity to ensure that Angel would be safe. I flat-out love them together.

I think the episode is all about facades and not taking things at face value. Cordy's medicine cabinet didn't show Fred and Gunn the truth, they had to find the medicines hidden under her bed. Angel might've seemed to be belittling Cordy to the Conduit, but really he was trying to save her. Cordy had to rip up the wall paper to see the truth underneath of it. Really the list goes on and on. On "Angel" things are often not what they seem, and misunderstandings between the characters will lead to tragic results this season.

On the downside, how is that house number still on the Hyperion wall in the alternate reality? I don't get it. Also, trying to tie this episode in with the season four storyline gives me a headache of my own. And I do think that Angel was kinna harsh with Lorne, but he was upset about Cordy, so I'm willing to cut him some slack.

My favorite part of the episode: The opening credits to "Cordy." If that silly, peppy, incredibly catchy theme song was on iTunes, I'd have already downloaded it.
23 out of 24 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Cordy's Big Life Change
Samuel-Shovel28 June 2018
Warning: Spoilers
In "Birthday", Cordy has a vision that puts her body in a coma and her consciousness straight out into the ethereal. Her friends are unaware of her spiritual existence as she attempts to contact them and warn them about the girl in danger somewhere in L.A. Her body lies in bed unresponsive as the gang tries to figure out what's wrong with her. The more they dig around, the more they realize just how bad her headaches have gotten due to the visions. She is taking extremely powerful painkillers and scans of her head reveal that she is dying.

The Powers That Be send their man Skip to come talk to Cordy. She finds out that Doyle was never supposed to transfer the visions to her and all of this has been a mistake. If she keeps the visions any longer she will die. Skip offers her a timeline in which she becomes a famous Hollywood actress instead. Cordy accepts it and lives a superstar life, briefly...

Something in the back of her mind takes her back to the old hotel where she uncovers a note she wrote to warn the gang. (I'm not sure why this would exist in that timeline but whatever...) Cordy visits the girl and they're attacked by a demon. Gunn and Wesley show up and kill it. In this timeline, Angel has the visions and has gone insane. Wesley has lost an arm; Fred is seemingly still in an alternate dimension. Everything's bad.

Cordy remembers everything after kissing Angel. She asks Skip to return her visions even if they kill her. The two come up with a loophole: Cordy can turn half-demon. This will allow her body to handle this. She wakes back up feeling fine. The episode ends with her having a vision and levitating in the air.

This episode gives us the old "what-if" scenario for Cordy's acting career. She's changed a lot since the early seasons of BtVS when she was quite the drama queen and mean girl. Her arc throughout the two series is possibly my favorite; it's fair to say that she's traveled the furthest in this amount of time. Her self-sacrifice in this episode for Angel is absolutely touching. And Skip is hilarious as always.

I've loved the direction they've taken this season so far. I hope it continues.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Where the writers' treatment of Cordy really goes off the rails
nightwishouge4 April 2021
Warning: Spoilers
I have to admit, I just don't GET Cordy's "thing" at this point in the series. The visions are tearing her mortal body apart, even killing her, and yet she refuses to give them up because she worries that she will no longer be useful to Angel Investigations. I have two retorts:

1) She was already a part of AI even before the visions were passed onto her, and had a history of usefulness as a member of the Scoobies in Sunnydale even prior to that;

2) How are you going to be useful to AI if you're DEAD, Cordy? Then there won't be ANYBODY to tell them about the visions.

Makes no sense. But by a certain point in the next season, none of this will make any sense. So I guess that's consistent.

Keeping with the negative, I also really hate how much Angel dotes on Cordelia. He's always sticking around to cradle her after she has a bad reaction to a vision, while the other members of the team are respecting her autonomy by racing into action based on what she has told them. If her whole deal is that she wants to be USEFUL, shouldn't she find Angel's overprotectiveness, I don't know, patronizing? Like, "Hey, Wes and Gunn are treating me like a valid member of the team, and Angel is wasting time treating me like a kindergartner who got a boo-boo on the jungle gym."

In this episode Angel even threatens Lorne into helping Cordelia after she lands in a coma. Threatens Lorne. Who never does anything BUT help. Without getting paid. Often at great cost to himself. Lorne is the most selfless character on the show. Maybe lay off him, Angel. Maybe realize that YOU'RE BOTH ON THE SAME SIDE AND HE'S PROBABLY AS EAGER TO SAVE CORDELIA AS YOU ARE. I think we're supposed to clap our hands together and go, "Aw, Angel cares about Cordelia SO MUCH he's willing to be a complete jerk for her!" Instead I just think, "Leave Lorne alone, ya bully!" I wish at the end of the episode Cordelia had whacked Angel upside the head and shouted, "Is that really how you think I want you to treat my friends?!" But no, she always takes Angel's side no matter who he is treating unfairly. I guess she likes the attention.

The best part of the episode (apart from the return of Skip) is in watching the alternate-reality Cordelia (a Jennifer Aniston/Courtney Cox type after hitting mainstream success on a sitcom) unravel the mystery of her lingering connection to Angel Investigations. See, in this reality she never met up with Angel at that party from the pilot episode, and thus when she encounters battle-hardened Wes again she has no point of reference for him except as the Watcher she had a crush on for a brief period in Sunnydale. It's really fun to watch her travel to a paranormally-distressed fan's house with only a vague idea of why she's doing it. The premise is so good I wish it had been milked for more than just half a single episode. Imagine if "Birthday" started out with the fake credits for Cordy's sitcom, with neither the viewer nor Cordy having any idea what was happening or why; the mystery slowly unravels as she investigates and starts piecing things together.

Honestly, if I were the showrunner, I would have jettisoned the "Cordy becomes part-demon" story and ran with the alternate reality from here on out. (I wouldn't have taken Wesley's arm, in that case.) It would have been really fun to see Cordy trying to balance the life of a ubiquitous sitcom star with the duties of a demon-fighting do-gooder. To me that would feel much more true to the character than the shallow love interest (and all the other go-nowhere constantly-retconning muckiness that season 4 entails) she tragically becomes.
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
I'm fine you guys. I'll be okay. I'm just... Dead?
SleepTight66627 March 2007
Warning: Spoilers
I'm fine you guys. I'll be okay. I'm just... Dead? - One of 'Cordelia's best centric episode, honestly, it's tough to chose between 'Birthday', 'Slouching Towards Bethlehem', 'Billy' and 'You're Welcome' as I pretty much love them equally. When it comes to the dialog this one is probably the least memorable but then again, it's the most character developing one. 'Cordelia' has another vision only this one knocks her out of her own body, then she meets 'Skip' who gives her the choice between dying or becoming a very popular movie star, as she always wanted to. The old 'Cordelia' would have chosen the movie star life without hesitating, but mature 'Cordy' was trouble choosing until she overheard 'Angel' calling her weak. I am a very huge fan of alternative realities, in this one 'Cordy' is a HUGE star, has her own show called 'Cordy!' (what are the odds?), in that reality 'Wesley' is a lot more hardcore and lost an arm and 'Angel' has gone insane as he now carries the visions (did he have to make out with 'Doyle' or what?) the whole blue room scene has to be one of my favorites of the show, the color was beautiful and so was her kiss that absorbed 'Angel's visions back into her. The whole episode is amazing, 'Cordy' becomes part demon and begins to float when she gets another vision. The show should have made more alternative reality-episodes like this one! SKIP: This is Tammy. She had the visions back in sixteen thirty? TAMMY: Aye. Had 'em well neigh on a year, and a hellish year it was, too. Town fathers called me a witch, wanted to burn me at the stake. CORDELIA: They killed you because you had visions? TAMMY: No, miss. They didn't have to. Last vision I had blew out the back of me skull. We wasn't mean to have the visions, us humans. Look, you want my advice, you listen to our man Skip here. He won't steer you wrong, this one. SKIP: Aw, get out of here. Really. Get out. I've got work. (10 out of 10)
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
What if...?
Joxerlives27 February 2012
Warning: Spoilers
BIRTHDAY

The Good; Cordy's sitcom is great and some excellent crazy acting from DB. Also nice to see Doyle again if only in a clip.

The Bad; Feels a bit laboured in places. How can the message in one dimension still be there in another (Jasmine?)

Best line: Skip; "Get out of here. No really, get out of here"

Apocalypses: 5

Angel Clichés In disguise; 8

DB get's his shirt off; 12

Cordy's tattoo; yep when she's ripping the wallpaper off so that makes 10. Note it's not CC doing the somersault on her show's credits because you don't see her tattoo.

Cheap Angel; 7

Fang Gang in bondage: no although Wes and Gunn use manacles to restrain mad Angel. Cordy: 5 Angel: 11 Wes: 6 Gunn; 3 Lorne; 2

Fang gang knocked out: CC for the whole ep Cordy: 12 Angel: 14 Wes: 5 Doyle; 1 Gunn; 1 Lorne; 2

Kills: Cordy: 5 vamps, 3 demons Angel; 32 vamps, 45 and 1/2 demons, 7 humans Doyle; 1 vamp Wes; 10 demons+3 vamps, 2 humans Kate; 3 vamps Faith; 16 vamps, 6 demons, 3 humans. Gunn; 8 vamps+ 7 demons.

Fang Gang go evil: Cordy: 2 Angel: 2

Alternate Fang Gang: Angel possessed by CC Cordy: 2 Angel: 8

Characters killed: 45

Recurring characters killed; 8;

Total number of Angel Investigations: 6, Angel, Cordy, Wes, Gunn, Fred and Lorne

Angel Investigations shot: Angel: 11 Wes; 1

Packing heat; Wes; 5 Doyle; 1 Angel; 1 Gunn; 1

Notches on Fang Gang bedpost: Cordy: 3 ?+Wilson/Hacksaw Beast+Phantom Dennis Angel: 5; Buffy, Darla and The Transcending Furies Wes; 2; Virginia and the bleached blonde

Kinky dinky: Fred mentions she didn't wear underwear for 5 years. Gunn goes through CC's lingerie. To judge by CC's cleavage exposing outfit on her show this must be sweeps week?

Captain Subtext; If Cordy wasn't around does this mean Doyle's last act was to kiss Angel? Love the CC as Wonder Woman cake the gang get for Cordy, too bad Joss went off the idea of making the film. Gunn comments that Fred is so cool. Wes refer to Gunn as his 'partner'. CC and Angel kiss

Know the face, different character; 4

Parking garages; 5,

Buffy characters on Angel; 16 Wetherby, Collins and Smith. Angel, Cordy, Oz, Spike, Buffy, Wes, Faith, Darla, Dru, The Master, Anne, Willow and Harmony

Questions and observations; So this is a world where CC never joins AI. No Fred so presumably after Wes and Gunn rescue her she goes back to Texas? In a world without Cordy's influence does this mean Merle, Elana etc are all still alive? Pentagrams always bad news. What are Buffy and the Scoobs doing about mad Angel in this alternate reality? CC is now part demon as is Faith, Buffy etc. This is ep 55 so exactly half way through the series.

Marks out of 10; 6/10
4 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Average, just like the character it is focused on...
m-4782626 May 2021
I never liked Cordelia. No matter the amount of character development she may have had. She never stopped being the shallow mean girl from BTVS. The only difference is now, she actually think she's the new Buffy Summers. This « what if » episode was entertaining, if not a little too on the nose. In an alternate universe, she's obviously a big star, in a very corny and surprisingly late 90s, for 2001 sitcom. Yet she still finds her way back to a destiny, that was supposed to be out of reach, had she'd chosen a different path. The ending, is absolutely in the line of logic to her upcoming storylines. So I don't understand the outrage, and the illogicalities some fans see in her last episodes on the show...
2 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed