Italiencele (2004) Poster

(2004)

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
5/10
Romanian showdown
tributarystu22 November 2004
Warning: Spoilers
October was the month which brought to the lucky Romanian public no less than two (different!) domestic films: the oh-so incredibly bad Orient Express and Italiencele, the latter directed by one Napoleon Helmis. Maybe it's just me and my own sensibility, but such a name strikes me as very odd. I've yet to get to the bottom of this mysterious identity, but this work of his is definitely worth a few words.

I don't tend to lower my standards for no movie, be it Romanian or else. Actually, I imagine exactly the opposite happens when I watch a home production, because it reflects the image of a society of which I myself am - more or less - part of. Image is a very powerful thing.

But let's get down to the film.

Spoilers

It would be best described by saying that it starts of like a bomb and reaches the finish line as a snail, even though the thematic is reasonably interesting: the search for a better life and what might happen while taking a shortcut. Quite a few people have left the country after the Revolution in '89, but I don't recall any boom as significant as the "working abroad as gatherers" boom. Gathering what, you may well ask. Well, gathering cherries, strawberries, oranges, and anything else you may consider gatherable. I suppose it's a more productive affair, than many other around here. Of course, the main issue here is still the shortcut. That the two main characters have a rather harsh and unpleasant encounter with the way things sometimes work is fairly predictable from the start. The old saying "It's not about getting there, it's about how you get there" proves to be fundamentally wrong in a rather shattering experience.

But! There's a catch. I don't know how someone may view the film as an outsider. However, I myself, as an "insider", found the whole story and experience a bit awkward to sit through. The script was at best mediocre and such a fact holds the film back dramatically. Moreover, acting continues to suffer to the same undetermined disease, but an antidote might be on its way. Helmis, on the other hand, delivered some handy craftwork and imposed - at times - a lively rhythm. He's someone who we mustn't turn away from just yet.

"Italiencele" is a nearly worthy film, but not quite. It's the viewer's task to decided if he throws it to the garbage can, or not. 6/10
8 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A crazy comedy turned into drama
cinehoolic24 July 2005
The film begins as a crazy comedy but gradually becomes more of a drama: two sisters living only with their father, the former Communist mayor of their village, travel to Spain in search of work. They apparently find their way to Italy but, in the end, things turn out differently again. This vitally narrated film progresses in quick rhythm with snappy shots, absorbing images of the post-Communist Romanian countryside as it goes. The feature debut by this young Romanian director offers another angle on the Balkan mentality - its immediate association with joy and sorrow, its profound insight, explosive energy and humour, which is the driving force of life. Helmis presents Balkan chaos as life's farce which nevertheless does have its relaxing moments. (www.febiofest.cz)
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Another waste of time
xTHrance16 March 2006
Badly written and produced, this is not a movie, it is some sort of a home-made cinema about stupid people...There is no insight, no other idea except depicting the "Romanian reality", or that part of the Romanian reality that I don't think would or should interest somebody. While other directors try hard to make a decent film, some of them come with utter trash like this pretending that it's entertainment or, what is regrettably worse, artistic. It is sad to see, how directors that don't deserve to get their movies made, actually make it and hard working directors, that really have something to say are left behind, because it is considered that their movies wouldn't be "interesting enough". Romanians are used with filth and what is worse is that they seem to like it. They deny movies with and idea, with a strong direction in favor of crappy "home made videos" such as this one.

1/10
6 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Excellent- Old-fashioned storytelling from a country in transition.
tainargb26 January 2006
Set in today's rural Romania, a culture that seems to resist change despite the provocations of recent history, 'The Italian Girls' tells the tale of 2 young women who decide they will find a better life picking strawberries in Spain.

This is a wonderful social comedy. 'The Italian Girls' is a touching film that avoids sentimentality and a political film that avoids extremism or earnestness. The writer/director, Napoleon Helmis has a light touch and a gift for dialogue. The cast create a world that is both real and comic, held together by Mara Nicolescu's (Jeni) spirited central performance.

I laughed and I cried during the film and when I left the cinema I was moved enough to look it up on IMDb and write a review about it! A new cinema with old values seems to be emerging out of Romania, and Napoleon Helmis is definitely one to watch.
8 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Two girls from a village in Romania arrive illegal in Spain and after a year they rerun claiming they have been in Italy where they gathered grapes
mary_ffsss27 June 2005
Well, I saw the movie and thought it was interesting ...the fact that two girls from a village in Romania try to get a better life no matter the cost impressed me.Not many people from Romania afford going abroad and those who manage to go there gather fruit or something else to earn money and to send it home.The funny part of the movie is that he two sisters go to Spain illegal and after a year they come home with an western attitude and claim that instead of going to Spain they arrived in Italy where they gathered grapes. The director,Napoleon Helmis wanted to show the real life and to present the things that actually happen in Romania....even if the movie wasn't a total success it captured my attention and made me smile
3 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed