Manslaughter (2005) Poster

(2005)

User Reviews

Review this title
7 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Fly's third and final part of the Trilogy about the tragedy of the middle class
tariboventola27 August 2005
Warning: Spoilers
Although not a class society in the classical sense, Director Per Fly has depicted the struggles, troubles and worries of the underclass, the middle class and the upper-class of modern Denmark in a trilogy consisting of "Bænken (The Bench)", "Arven (The Inheritance)" and "Drabet (The killing / The murder / The homocide)". While the environments, the surroundings and the living standards of the different classes clearly differ, the true problems that the persons encounter are essentially somewhat the same.

"Drabet" has the middle class as it's point of departure. A grammar school (or senior high school) teacher lives in Copenhagen together with his Swedish wife. Their son, being as old as the students the father teaches, has moved out with a girlfriend. On the surface everything seems idyllic, but things aren't going well at all. The main character, Carsten, is having an affair with an old student, who is approximately of the same age as his son. Being an old left-wing activist, Carsten's life is given a new meaning with the entrance of this young, leftist girl in his life, but his dual role is pushed to an ultimatum when the girl and two other activists kill a police officer in a hit-and-run after a vandalism action. The three get arrested and Carsten chooses to abandon his "supposed" dull life with his wife in favour of supporting the girl in prison. He begs her not to confess to the police who drove the car in order for her not to be convicted for premeditated murder.

From this point on a number of plot twists throws the main character into many moral dilemmas. In pursuit of personal happiness and meaning of life, he realizes (too) late what his actions have had of consequences. When he realizes his mistakes, is it too late for him to turn things around? Can he be redeemed? Can he redeem himself? The style of filming has strong resemblance to the other two films: The mood and dialogue are realistic depicted; There is a focus on emotions through the characters' eyes. The down-to-earth filming is contrasted, but also paralleled, with some 4 dream-like sequences of the main character jumping of a cliff with a parachute, falling, falling with the green land on the one hand and the endless sea on the other - which way will he end? In one sequence his parachute catches fire, but it's only a dream! In the end he lands on the land. But he is all alone.

The actors do a great job. It is however, funny if not silly, why the main character has this Swedish speaking wife, as was the case in "Arven", which is probably a requirement from the sponsor, Svensk Filmindustri (SFI) in order to be able to hit wide on the Swedish market as well. Many scenes are so emotional intense that you feel like curling your toes, but the camera has no mercy, it just keeps filming: We have to sit through the long sequence where the wife finds out about the affair, the sequence where the dead police officer's wife screams at the top her voice in court, the sequence where the main character tells an old friend to keep out of his life. The best scenes in the film are the one without dialogue - the silence is so effectful. Kudo to Jesper Christensen for pulling an amazing performance, almost on par with the sublime one he made in "Bænken".

Fly's "Drabet" can both be seen as social realism, poking to a middle class in Denmark that Has It All, but forgets how to live life, be happy and protect the true values in life, but also a story of ordinary people put in extreme situations. The film has a nice ambiguous ending, although clearly the most optimistic of the three films. What I particularly like about the film is that it isn't moralizing, but it indeed tells a lot about society and hopefully make us re-evaluate our own lives.

The trilogy will be remembered for many years and will hopefully mark a fine start in a long and great film career from director Per Fly.

Strongly Recommended; Rating: 8/10
33 out of 36 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Middle Class Communist on Icarus Wings of Love goes Raskolnikov
martin_g_karlsson19 February 2006
The story centers on a social studies high school teacher. Hes married and has been having an affair with a former student. Hes an old communist and the student is a radical, inclined towards hard-line activism. We might perceive him as her ideological father.

We learn already in the beginning of the film that the student has taken part in an action against a weapons manufacturer, where a policeman ended up dead somehow. The question is how and why, how to deal with it and what the consequences will be? We follow the teacher as he tries to come to grasp with what has happened. He is dissatisfied with his marriage and finds his safe middle class existence lacking. So he latches on to the wings of his love for the young student, and her convictions, and takes off, on an Icarus ride towards societies boundaries.

Its the old 'Crime and Punishment' theme again, set to a Danish middle class and political background. It deals with questions of guilt, romantic love and the meaning of politics. If bombs are killing thousands in Iraq, is it so odd when someone dies in Denmark? Is the main character a thrill seeker, out for the rush of a young woman's love and fiery convictions? Is there any meaning in punishment? How much guilt should one be feeling?

The film weeds a tangled web of morality, desires and politics. However, it is not as tangled, or perhaps not as well untangled, as it could have been. The motives for the different actions undertaken are never really elaborated on. Rather the film is often quiet. Perhaps that is part of the point, a low bass-like sound is humming all through the movie, like a constant, gnarling feeling of guilt. But it still feels like something is missing in the character description. We also understand quite soon what direction the plot is taking, the contours are a bit obvious. It is not hard to predict the moral of the story, or the fate of the school teacher, far ahead of time. Still, it is a compelling and thought-provoking film in many ways. The acting is highly believable and we understand the main characters aggression against petite bourgeois existence as well as his loneliness and sadness over losing it.

Also Id like to give props to the most explicit hand gliding-Icarus analogy since '24 Hour Party People'. Real good stuff. That should be used in even more films, I think!
24 out of 26 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Excellent film but too slow
hansarne21 April 2006
For the last film in his trilogy Per Fly has made a very good film about the Danish middle class. For me the problem is that the two first films in his trilogy about the three Danish classes, Bænken (The Bench) and Arven (The Inheritance) were excellent, while this is just very good. For those not in the know about of Danish society, the Danish middle class is by far the largest class in Denmark and maybe the most boring -at least it seems that way in Per Fly's film. He may have a point but he certainly hammers it home with a lot of looooong, slow scenes. It works, as some of the scenes conveys very embarrassing moments for the characters and in the process makes you, the viewer, embarrassed as well. Still, that concept was better realised in Thomas Winterberg's "Festen (The Party)". The story in Drabet is based on a real life incident: In the 80's a group of seven well-educated middle class men with leftish leanings committed a series of robberies against banks and post offices all over Denmark and Sweden with the aim to acquire money and weapons for PFLP (the Palestinan Liberation Front, or maybe their mortal enemies The Liberation Front of Palestine - sorry, Monty Python reference there). At a robbery against a post office in central Copenhagen in 1988 they shot and killed a young policeman. The group was eventually caught and tried but since it couldn't be established who had fired the mortal shot, no one was sentenced for the murder. The whole group did serve jail time for the robberies but have been free since 1995 - not exactly a hard sentence for the person who pulled the trigger. It is certainly an interesting dilemma how you deal with killing someone - even if it's for a cause you think is just. As usual, the best Danish actor, Jesper Christensen, is doing a delightful job in the lead role, but I still feel the slow pace - even if it's artistically justified - drags a good film from excellent to very good. Still, I'm sure Per Fly's trilogy will stand as a beacon for Danish film-making for many years to come.
21 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Mediocre morality tale from Denmark
zetes1 May 2006
A teacher's activist mistress runs over and kills a police officer. The teacher leaves his wife to stand by his girlfriend. The focus in this one seemed off to me. The atmosphere is of a thriller or a noir, when instead the issues would have been brought out better without these elements (e.g., the lighting and the musical score). I also felt the plot was poorly developed. The girlfriend and the two men who were with her during the fateful night get off nearly scot-free because none of them confesses – and therefore they can't prove which one of them was the driver. Either the Danish legal system is the worst in the world or their detectives really suck, or, probably the true option, the screenwriters don't have a clue how these things actually work. (n.b. – according to one IMDb reviewer, the first option is the correct one!).
6 out of 36 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Morality tale and relationship dynamics refresher
zoschenkooksanna20 January 2016
In this, the third installment in Per Fly's trilogy, again the familiar conservative themes of the primacy of family, and a moral imperative not to shirk responsibilities, yet not to harm others, come to the fore. In a scene reminiscent of shock-jock Jack in Terry Gilliam's The Fisher King inciting a listener to murder, Carsten possibly instigates Pil's violent actions resulting in the murder of a policeman, the arrest of his young activist lover, the end of his marriage, and the start of some predictable but still interesting relationship developments and deepening moral questions. This reviewer did not find it drawn out, rather, the pace was about right.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Interesting film... somewhat sleep inducing
TedEbare25 December 2012
Cinematically, Per Fly's film contains all the elements of excellence accompanied by good performances rendered by the cast. Opening sequences signaled that the audience was on board for a good ride, unfortunately the ride ended all too soon. If this was not part of a trilogy I would have walked out after 30 minutes.

Scandinavian films are known for quiet story telling which I usually appreciate, but this is just badly paced. That low hum within the soundtrack must have been the sound of paint drying on what could have been a good picture. One would think that four screenwriters could deliver a compelling story-line, maybe therein lies a problem.

Considering the high quality of Fly's previous entries in the trilogy ("Bænken" & "Arven") he should have stopped at a duo or hired a objective Editor. Twenty minutes less running time may have provided a tightening and focus necessary to hold our attention. At least it would have made for a better paced film which may have found an international audience. Sadly, Drabet misses the mark of excellence by approximately half a kilometer of footage.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Boring
ida-2827 May 2006
YAWN YAWN YAWN! Ask any so called intellectual movie-critic, and he or she will say that this movie is oh so great. They will say that this movie deals with the dark side of man, with moral dilemmas! That might be true, but at the same time this movie has been seen many times before in Danish movies. Make up something new! Per Fly has been said to be a genius. Yeah well, if a genius is a person who can copy, then he is. The existential themes of this movie is not something new, Kierkegaard and the Sartre (just to mention a few) have written about this a long time ago. And what is up with Charlotte Fich! She is a Drama Queen in this movie. I understand the role she plays, I just don't believe in it. She overdoes it!
6 out of 67 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed