"Star Trek" The Menagerie: Part I (TV Episode 1966) Poster

(TV Series)

(1966)

User Reviews

Review this title
33 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Spock is Guilty of Kidnapping and Mutiny - part one
Bogmeister28 June 2006
The Menagerie parts one and two was the only 2-parter during the 3-year run of the original Trek series and it was because Roddenberry was able to insert most of the footage from the 1st pilot "The Cage." The move was made out of necessity, to combat deadline problems in getting episodes produced (such a sf show back in the 1960s was a hassle to get done on time). One positive outcome back then was that audiences, unaware of the pilot produced almost a couple of years earlier, were treated to a whole new crew and captain for these two episodes on top of the regular cast of characters, as if the producers had spent double the money on these episodes to present a TV epic spanning a dozen years of Starfleet history (though they still used terms such as 'United Space Fleet' in these early episodes).

The wraparound story begins as a space mystery plot: the Enterprise is diverted to Starbase 11 for unknown reasons and very soon Spock is a suspect in these shenanigans. Astonishingly, though even McCoy belabors the fact that Spock's Vulcan heritage makes subterfuge on his part impossible, it does turn out that Spock is indeed acting out some mutinous scheme to shanghai our precious starship and kidnap his former captain, Pike, now horribly crippled. Well, Spock is half human, we tend to forget. Or has he simply gone mad? It may very well be, for he's directing Enterprise to Talos IV, a planet so off-limits it's the subject of the only known death penalty on Starfleet's books. When the jig is up, there's a great scene of Spock surrendering to a flabbergasted McCoy, as Uhura looks on in shock. Even Kirk, usually steady as a captain should be, doesn't know what to make of his first officer's illogical conduct.

In the 3rd and final acts, we begin to see transmitted images of a mission of the Enterprise from 13 years prior, when Capt. Pike was commanding and Spock was one of his officers. We really don't know where all this is going and what Spock hopes to accomplish - and that's another thing that makes this a very good 2-parter - we really need to find out what it's all about in the 2nd part. Not only is Spock facing severe penalties, but it looks like Kirk's career may be finished, as well. Double jeopardy, folks. This is also the 1st televised episode to feature one of those shuttlecrafts (none were available in the earlier "The Enemy Within" when the crafts were really needed). There's also one of those neat matte paintings to convey the ambiance of a futuristic starbase - this was the only way to visualize such things back then. Finally, check out Kirk's smug approach at the start of the episode - boy, do things go sideways on him as the story progresses.
37 out of 39 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Talosian Tricks
MISSMOOHERSELF13 January 2007
In the old commercial for blank audio cassettes, the tag line was "is it real or is it Memorex?" The same might be said for the events in this episode - a compilation and remix of "The Cage," the first pilot of Star Trek. Mr. Spock has cleverly commandeered the ship to take it to the forbidden planet Talos IV in order to allow Capt. Christopher Pike, his first captain who has been burned and paralyzed, to return there. Why the finagling? Because to have any contact at all with Talos IV invites a death sentence. Why this is so is never explained - that bothered me tremendously - but, if nothing else, it adds to the story. After he has gotten the ship to travel to Talos IV, Mr. Spock turns himself in to Dr. McCoy (the senior-most officer present; Capt. Kirk was off the ship) for arrest and says, "The charge is mutiny, Dr.; I never received orders to take over the ship." What follows is a court martial in which - thanks to the Talosians - we learn why it was so important (besides the obvious paralysis) for Capt. Pike to get to Talos IV even at risk of Mr. Spock's death. The illusions the Talosians create, the background music and the entire storyline are fantastic. And Meg Wyllie as The Keeper (the head Talosian) is wonderful. Call me sexist but it never occurred to me to have a woman in that role but she was perfect! The Talosians, having given up almost all physical activity and becoming almost completely reliant upon the power of illusion, are also unisex; you can't really tell if they're male or female and it really doesn't matter. This episode, more than almost any other in the series, makes me hope and pray there are other worlds out there and that there are civilizations that are so far advanced! What a neat thing if this were so! This is one of my favorite episodes and, no matter how many times I've seen it (I even have it on video), it never fails to fascinate me. Meg Wyllie LOOKS like an alien and I do NOT mean that unkindly.
29 out of 33 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Mutiny Without Bounty...
Xstal15 February 2022
Mr. Spock takes leave of his sense, shows emotions behind walled defence, as he kidnaps a Captain, the shell he is trapped in, a mutiny of Enterprise suspense.

The star ship heads for the forbidden Talos IV with the Captain Pike pilot knife and forked into it.
9 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The original pilot revisited - Part One
MaxBorg8925 April 2009
It is a well known fact that when Gene Roddenberry first pitched Star Trek to NBC, the original pilot episode, The Cage, was rejected for being "too cerebral". When the series was given another chance, Roddenberry thought it would be fun to establish the events of the rejected episode as canon, and did so by writing The Menagerie, which has the unique distinction of being the sequel to what was still, at the time, an unaired episode.

This time, rather than exploring a new planet, Kirk and his crew are on Starbase 11, paying a visit to the former commander of the Enterprise, Christopher Pike (Sean Kenney), now horribly disfigured and paralyzed because of an accident. Pike joins his successor on the starship, where an unpleasant surprise awaits: Spock, who used to serve under Pike, has effectively hijacked the vessel and set the course for Talos IV, a planet which is off-limits (the punishment is death) since Pike and Spock's last visit there, 13 years earlier. Naturally, being a logical creature, Spock turns himself in and arranges a court-martial so that he can justify his actions.

There's no need to say more about the plot, since the rest will play out in Part 2. What really impresses is how Roddenberry creates the connection between The Cage and the rest of the Star Trek universe, by coming up with a particular type of flashback (to say more would be too much) that allows everyone, on screen and off, to see what could have been of Trek, had NBC not turned down the original project. In particular, it's fun to see Jeffrey Hunter (who was unable to return in The Menagerie) play Pike as a more serious captain than Kirk usually is and Nimoy's early days as Spock, whose personality hadn't been fully established yet: this is the only time in the entire series that everybody's favorite Vulcan spontaneously grins.

In short, not just a great "mystery" episode, but also a treat for those who can't be bothered to track down The Cage in its original form (it's available as part of the Season 3 box set).
35 out of 36 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Well done first part
russem315 April 2006
Warning: Spoilers
ST:TOS:16a - "The Menagerie Part I" (Stardate: 3012.4), the 16th episode to go into production but the 11th one shown on TV, this is the first of a 2 part episode which took the original Star Trek pilot called The Cage and expertly intertwines it into a current storyline involving Mr. Spock seemingly betraying his captain and ship to take his former captain, Christopher Pike (who was only in the original pilot, whom they later replaced with Kirk) to the forbidden planet of Talos IV - through the Enterprise TV screens you get to see the event of this rejected pilot (an event that is 13 years before the present time - you get to see a more emotional younger Spock too in those prior events!). And the cliffhanger leaves much to be answered and you definitely will want to stay to watch part II. And, all in all, a brilliant two part episode, which was honored with a Hugo Award for Best Television Sci-Fi Program.
19 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
"Whatever he's up to, he's planned it well".
classicsoncall9 October 2010
Warning: Spoilers
That observation of Science Officer Spock by Commodore Mendez (Malachi Throne) is at the core of the brilliance of this episode. Earlier stories in the series may have been good, but this was the first great one. It's well detailed and highly suspenseful, with a mystery that makes the viewer highly anticipate the resolution to Spock's behavior. The writing also solidifies the dual nature of Spock's heredity. As part Vulcan he's incapable of lying, as half human, one must consider whether that part of his make up is prone to treachery and treason. Besides all of that, you also have the intrigue of Talos IV, and why Fleet Command would impose a death sentence for any of it's members to venture to that planet. All very 'fascinating' as Spock himself might be prone to describe it if he wasn't so busy manipulating the ship records on the Enterprise to cover for his subterfuge. With still more to come, the general court martial convened for Spock would have given Captain Kirk the perfect opportunity to use a line that us fans had to wait for, for four decades until the release of the 2009 movie - "Are you out of your Vulcan mind"?
11 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
The Best Original Star Trek Episode - Hugo Award Winner!
bragant14 January 2010
Warning: Spoilers
Imagine that you could have anything you wanted, go anywhere you wished, be anything you'd ever dreamed of being - through thought alone. Now imagine yourself sharing this gift with the love of your life. What would you do? Would such powers be worth your soul? This is the dilemma presented to Captain Christopher Pike in "The Cage" the now-legendary pilot episode of the original Star Trek series. Famously deemed "too cerebral" and "too cold" by NBC brass and rejected, "The Cage" was nevertheless the most ambitious and costly pilot ever made in the history of the network at the time, and Gene Roddenberry did not want to let all that effort and expense go to waste, with the result being this truly classic Star Trek episode, which embeds "The Cage" into a frame story which deepens and extends the emotional and philosophical depth of this haunting tale, a landmark in TV history and one of the first truly serious sci-fi stories ever filmed for the small screen...Star Date 3012: The USS Enterprise diverts to Starbase 11 after Mr. Spock receives an urgent message from the former commander of the Enterprise. Surprisingly, the message cannot be from Captain Pike after all, as he is now confined to a wheelchair, mute and horribly disfigured after a tragic accident. Kirk and Starbase commanding officer Commodore Mendez attempt to get to the bottom of the mystery, but before the matter can be cleared up, Spock - for reasons as yet unknown - commits an act of open mutiny, kidnapping the helpless Captain Pike and hijacking the Enterprise via a brilliantly thought-out and timed plan aided by a few Vulcan nerve pinches. Soon, the Enterprise is headed for the remote, forbidden planet of Talos IV. Mendez informs Kirk that Talos IV is under interdiction, and any contact with the planet by Starfleet vessels or personnel carries an immediate death sentence, meaning that Spock appears to be deliberately destroying himself, and Kirk as well, given that the Captain will be held responsible for the ship's activities. Appalled, Kirk and Mendez give chase in a shuttlecraft, which itself becomes dangerous when the Enterprise refuses to answer their calls or pick up the craft until power and oxygen are nearly gone. Spock - knowing that Kirk must be the one following the ship - is of course unable to consign the Captain to certain death. After ordering the craft to be retrieved and the occupants beamed aboard, Spock reveals what he has done to McCoy and demands to be arrested, after having set the starship on an irreversible course to Talos IV. Upon reassuming command, Kirk demands an explanation, whereupon Spock requests immediate court martial by a tribunal of Starfleet commanding officers - of whom there are three on board - Mendez, Kirk, and the crippled invalid Captain Pike. Spock's encyclopedic knowledge of Starfleet regulations enables him to manipulate the tribunal into allowing him to present otherwise inadmissible evidence. Spock presents video recordings of the only contact ever made between the Federation and the inhabitants of Talos IV - a journey taken 13 years earlier by the Enterprise itself under Pike's command. Kirk expresses doubts about the authenticity of the video due to its extreme detail, but the reality of the events depicted is confirmed by Pike himself, who turns out to have been lured to Talos IV by a distress call from the alleged survivors of a Federation research vessel which crashed there 18 years previously. Among the survivors is Vina, a stunning beauty said to have been born just before the disaster. Pike is attracted to the girl and allows her to lure him to an isolated spot, whereupon he is waylaid and captured by the Talosians, a race of androgynous humanoids with enormous cranial capacity and the power to transform thoughts into virtual reality. After Pike's capture, the rest of the "survivors" vanish as none of them really existed except Vina. The episode ends when the tribunal learns that Spock's "evidence" is in fact being transmitted to the Enterprise directly from Talos IV, in violation of Starfleet regulations. Starfleet orders an immediate halt to the transmissions, and we wonder what will happen next...To be continued in a review of "The Menagerie: Part II"!
11 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Spock commits treason for his old captain
Tweekums10 September 2015
Warning: Spoilers
As this two part story opens the Enterprise diverts to Starbase 11 after Spock claims to have received a subspace message from his former captain, Christopher Pike. It soon becomes apparent that Pike couldn't have sent any message as he has been severely injured and can only communicate 'yes or no' by beeping once or twice. As Kirk tries to get to the bottom of what is going on Spock sends orders to the Enterprise which enable him to take Pike to the planet Talos IV; going there is the only capital offence in the Federation for reasons that are so serious they remain classified! Kirk and the commander of the star base pursue in a shuttle and when they get to the Enterprise Spock is placed in custody but the ship continues to head to Talos IV. During his court martial Spock starts to show them details of the only visit by a Federation ship to Talos IV; the time the Enterprise, under the command of Capt. Pike went there thirteen years previously. We see how they were lured there by a false distress signal and how Pike was captured by aliens. To discover what happens next we'll have to watch part two!

This, the only two part story in the original series, nicely uses scenes from the original pilot, 'The Cage' in an almost entirely new story. There is a good sense of mystery as surely the ever reliable Spock would be incapable of breaking any rule, let alone one so serious, unless he had a very good reason. We are also treated to the sight of Spock overpowering Star Fleet computer engineers prior so he can give plausible orders that will enable him to take command of the Enterprise. Once his trial begins and we start to see scenes that were originally part of 'The Cage' it is nicely explained how we can see recordings of the action form viewpoints where there wouldn't have been cameras to record the scene or even private moments that wouldn't be recorded at all. The thirteen year time gap serves to explain why most of the crew of Pike's Enterprise have been replaced and why the uniforms have changed. Overall this was a fine episode that made good use of material from the original pilot and set things up nicely for the concluding part of the story which will tell us the truth about the planet Talos IV and why Spock would risk everything to take his former captain there.
10 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
One of the Best Episodes in the first series
csm-781199 August 2020
This two part episode is simply superb. It's a great early showcase for Mr Spock's character and has a fascinating story at its centre. Like Captain Kirk we implicitly want to trust Spock even though we aren't sure what's happening at the beginning. This is intelligent and gripping sci fi that is well ahead of its time and that makes you think. It also has an excellent guest starring appearance from Jeffrey Hunter in the form of the well used footage from the original pilot episode.
8 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Mr. Spock Hijacks The Enterprise & Kidnaps Christopher Pike
Rainey-Dawn22 December 2016
Season 1, episode 11. A 2-part episode. Mr. Spock says there is a message from Christopher Pike and the Enterprise heads to Starbase 11. Kirk, Bones and Spock beam down and learn that former Captain of the Enterprise  Christopher Pike is confined to a futuristic wheelchair and can only communicate through a light: a flash once for yes and 2 flashes for no via his brainwaves. There is no way Pike made a "call" to the Enterprise.  While Kirk speaks with Commodore Mendez about this strange occurrence, Spock beams aboard the ship, overrides the all the computers, has tape recordings of Kirk giving commands, has Bones to beam aboard, beams up Pike and takes off in the Enterprise toward the forbidden planet of Talos IV leaving Kirk behind. Mendez and Kirk jump into a shuttle craft to follow, Spock gives the command to beam the two aboard the Enterprise and orders Bones to arrest him. A court martial follows and Spock pleads guilty to mutiny.  The cliffhanger is in the middle of Spock's court martial hearing.

This episode ties into the original pilot episode The Cage, with parts of The Cage being shown by Spock at his own trial.

I really like this particular episode.. it's different. Spock's behavior is intriguing but will be fully explained in the second half of this episode.

8.5/10
8 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Someone left the Cage open a little.
poppyooooo7 July 2013
Warning: Spoilers
I loved this two part episode as a young man, and i still love it today. I wanted to get that out of the way first.

I love it despite all the inconsistency in the script. I know a lot of people will say you can pick apart any show or film you want. And that is probably true. However, "The Menagerie" parts I and II have errors in the script that go to the very heart of the story and makes it weaker and less believable.

At the core of these problems are the planning by Mr. Spock and the long range abilities of the Talosians.

How in the name of Vulcan did Spock plan all this when he had no contact with the Talosians? When Kirk and Spock first visit Captain Pike it appears (to me anyway) that Pike already knows what Spock is up to and tries to stop him from carrying out his plan. But Spock had no contact with Captain Pike prior to the visit at the beginning of the episode. So when did Spock sit down with the Talosians and Captain Pike and plan all this? The Talosians even say, "Spock related Kirk's strength of will to us." Really? When exactly?

However, even worse than this mistake is the fact that the Talosians "created" the image of Commodore Mendez at Star Base 11 as Captain Kirk boards a shuttle craft to chase the Enterprise.

Really? The Talosians power is so great they can project an image all the way to a Federation Star Base! Really? If this is true, then why didn't the Talosians just project an image of Captain Pike at Star Base 11 so that nobody would know he was gone?

Even worse, if Commodore Mendez was still at Star Base 11 during this entire time why didn't he try and contact the Enterprise or the Federation and let them know that he(Mendez) was not aboard the shuttle craft? Near the end of the episode the Federation contacts the Enterprise and orders "Mendez" to take command of the Enterprise. Why doesn't anyone in the Federation know that Mendez is still at Star Base 11?

I am not sure how to solve the first problem of the planning, but the second part would have been easy to solve. Commodore Mendez should never have been a Talosian image. Mendez should have been real all along. There was no reason to make him an image. By having the real Mendez on board the Enterprise would have solved all this. After seeing the evidence the real Mendez would have been convinced of the need for Pike to remain with the Talosians and Spock's innocence of all charges. I think this would have made the entire episode much better.

As it is I can only give this episode 7 out of 10. Although I want to make it higher as this is a great concept of a story.
13 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A Very Intriguing Plot
Hitchcoc26 April 2014
I am always a sucker for this episode, even though the producers saw fit to use footage from the pilot of the series. Obviously, this was to try recoup some of the money they had thrown at this project. Christopher Pike, who was Kirk's predecessor on the Enterprise, is basically left with his thoughts. His body was destroyed in a fire where he heroically save a group of children. He is in a kind of box/wheelchair where his brain can answer questions by way of a light that flashes. Mr. Spock, out of loyalty to his old Captain, kidnaps Pike and takes him to Talos IV, a planet forbidden to the Federation. Spock actually lies about his reasons and is brought up for court martial and potential execution. During the trial the evidence is damning and the judges, including Kirk, have pretty much seen enough. There is a tape of the whole thing. Spock insists on them watching the whole tape, but must beg at the end of the episode. Trying to gerrymander a plot around a previous piece of film doesn't work very well, but in this case it keeps us guessing. It ends with a great narrative hook and we are coaxed into watching the next installment.
8 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
confused but intriguing two-part episode
HelloTexas1110 February 2009
Warning: Spoilers
For a long time, 'The Menagerie' was my favorite 'Star Trek' episode though in recent years it has been eclipsed by 'City on the Edge of Forever.' What I used to prefer about 'Menagerie' was that it's more hard-core Star Trek with this fascinating back-story to the then-current Trek storyline. I still think it's fairly ingenious the way Gene Roddenberry incorporated the original pilot into a two-part episode. Though the 'new' part of the story is largely an excuse for Kirk and a few others (and us) to watch the pilot, the idea of Spock being court-martialed is a clever one. You can poke holes in the plot if you want. For instance, given the Talosians' mind-control abilities and Captain Pike's condition, why is it even necessary to physically bring Pike back to their planet? And there are other confusing questions about Pike and Commodore Mendez... best to not think too hard about the details and just enjoy ST's only two-parter.
8 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
A Senior Trekker writes..............
celineduchain2 April 2022
For more than twenty years this two part episode, Menagerie, was all that viewers were able to see of the first pilot, The Cage. Despite the confusion that comes from watching it too soon after the original, this story-within-a-story made good use of the unused footage and created a memorable adventure. The opening scenes are something of a homage to early depictions of space exploration, with futuristic cityscapes in the background and huge, noisy computers complete with multi-coloured flashing lights.

The story opens with Kirk confronted with another interchangeable, soft-focused female assistant; this one a brunette who teases him about all she has been told by her friend Helen. This was probably a reference to Dr Helen Noel from an earlier episode but someone got the surnames mixed up. After all, Kirk's endless parade of lovelies didn't merit being treated as real people, did they? Not so the real women who played these roles through: actress Julie Parrish whom played Miss Piper spent the ten years leading up to her untimely death in 2001 campaigning for and working with the victims of domestic violence.

However, let's get back to the story.

Who could forget poor Captain Pike's dreadful tragedy or Mr Spocks' deeply disturbing treachery? They make a clever envelope for the Pike/Vina story, most of which falls within the second episode. The extra scenes weres written by Gene Roddenberry himself after he was unhappy with the draft provided him. Apparently, he also entered into some dispute over who would direct but, after all, The Cage had been his special creation, something that has probably been circulating in his mind for years before he finally got the opportunity to make it. If financial necessity dictated that the footage had to be used then he must have been absolutely committed to choosing the form in which audiences were going to see it.

Senior Trekker scores every episode with a 5.
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Best of the series
savagesteve1318 February 2011
Warning: Spoilers
I'm sure I will get a lot of gruff for that claim, but this 2 part episode has it all, and Roddenberry managed to make it dovetail perfectly with "The Cage" in terms of plot. This is one of those episodes that is far more than gorilla monsters or planet killers, it has intrigue, secrets within secrets, and what seems like the idyllic Star Trek world falling apart before our eyes as the two top characters look to be finished career-wise, and one may even be executed! The end of part I has a sobering pan-away as Captain Kirk is alone in a room, quietly pondering what to do next. You feel his confusion and sadness and the tension is gripping. You just can't wait to watch part II. The masterful re-use of The Cage pilot gives you insight into the way two starships are run, first with the serious all-business Captain Pike, and the relaxed swagger of Captain Kirk. The two crews in contrast to each other but both knowledgeable and professional in what they do. Will this culminate in a happy ending for all? Or will it be a disaster for Starfleet and the Captain of the Enterprise? Time to pop in Part 2 and find out...
10 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Re-Edited Part One of the Star Trek Pilot "The Cage"
mike4812816 July 2014
Warning: Spoilers
A necessary set-up for re-using the footage from the original pilot for the series. Some characters are different. Majel Barrett is "Number One", not a nurse. Spock has a different haircut and eyebrows. There is another doctor, not "Bones". Best viewed together along with Part II and, ironically, perhaps the best two shows of the entire series. Using the devise of a fake court marshal, Spock retells the story from 13 years ago of Christopher Pike, former starship captain and hero, now trapped in a totally paralyzed body, (in a futuristic wheelchair) due to a horrific warp core accident. It's all an illusion, from the masters of it all, The Talosians from forbidden planet Talos IV. Pike is captured to perpetuate his species in an intergalactic zoo, and perhaps a new race of beings to tend the planet because the Talosians are all brain and no brawn. Strangely, no other alien "prisoners" are shown, with the exception of the mysterious female "Vina". Good EFX further enhanced by CBS in the remastered version. I still love "Vina" as the sexy green Orion slave girl! Part II is far better, but without this prologue, the whole thing wouldn't make any sense at all. What is not explained is why the Talosians suddenly want to help poor Capt.Pike. They sure didn't before. Mr. Spock obviously had something to do with it.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
More interesting than the usual episode
SusanJL20 February 2019
Warning: Spoilers
Very well-done and interesting episode! I don't like Capt. Pike nearly as well as Kirk, though. I couldn't help but chuckle at the aliens' heads when viewed from behind - looked exactly like butts! The original butt-heads LOL!
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The Best episode of Star trek as for now
nicofreezer16 April 2021
Warning: Spoilers
If you havent watch " the cage" its even better. And 100% of 1966 havent Saw the cage because it first aired on 1986. But now with Netflix putting it first post people Saw it as first. Like I did, and I Like Captain Pike, he could have been as good or even better than Captain Kirk. And Love the fact that they keep a rôle for him, even if the Pilot was not accepted, which is a shame btw, because it was a Classic.

And I love the absolute Loyalty from Mr Spock to his old Captain Pike, he for sure Can Do the same for Kirk.

This episode is an instant classic.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A fine showcase for Mr. Nimoy.
Hey_Sweden11 July 2021
With this solid two-part episode, series creator / writer Gene Roddenberry was able to re-visit the original un-aired pilot, 'The Cage', and make the story part of the official canon. The set-up has Spock following his own personal agenda, behaving in a way that runs counter to his very pragmatic, logical Vulcan half. He kidnaps the former Enterprise captain, Christopher Pike (Sean Kenney, "Terminal Island"), now a scarred invalid, and assumes control of the ship, forcing it to travel to Talos IV, a planet that is usually forbidden to *everybody*. Then Spock allows himself to be arrested, fully ready to accept punishment for what he's done.

This is a good set-up, delivering a healthy back story utilizing ample archive footage from 'The Cage', in which Jeffrey Hunter ("The Searchers") played Pike. Due to some mysterious transmissions which the ship is able to access, we see the tale of the previous expedition to Talos IV, and the beginnings of what fatefully happened to the landing party. It's a wonderful set-up that knows how to leave the viewer hanging, and eager to see the second part of this episode. It's also great to see Spock taking centre stage, as he follows his plan step by step, and presenting his case in a matter of fact way (not that we expect any less from him). He is definitely aware of the consequences - not only to him, but to Kirk - but clearly has the strength of his convictions.

If one is like this viewer and not has yet seen 'The Cage', 'The Menagerie: Part I' does whet their curiosity. It's a well-written, well-acted episode that presents to the audience a potentially dire outcome: the typical punishment for daring to venture to Talos IV is *death*. So the stakes are high, and the level of anticipation is palpable. 'The Menagerie: Part I' also allows the viewer to see some fine supporting performances from 'The Cage': Hunter, Majel Barrett as First Officer "Number One", and top character actor John Hoyt ("When Worlds Collide") as ships' doctor Phil Boyce.

Eight out of 10.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Where One Man Has Gone Before
Samuel-Shovel5 April 2018
Warning: Spoilers
In part one of "The Menagerie", Spock claims that the Enterprise has received a distress call from a starbase. Unbeknownst to Kirk, Spock has lied about this SOS because he intends to kidnap one of the planet's inhabitants, former captain of the Enterprise Christopher Pike. With Pike in tow, Spock plans to use deception to take over command of the Enterprise and make a heading for Talos IV, the one planet Star Fleet forbids ships to even approach. But when Kirk almost kills himself in pursuit of the Enterprise, Spock saves him and turns on the autopilot of the Enterprise, using the computer to force a course for Talos IV. Charged with treason, Spock must now reveal the purpose of all this subterfuge. We cut to flashbacks from the original pilot "The Cage." As Part I ends, Spock is locked up and the Enterprise continues its course for Talos IV.

This episode was probably pretty amazing at the time if you had never seen the unreleased pilot prior to this. Nowadays with Netflix, "The Cage" is the first episode listed and usually the starting point for most bingers. And while already seeing some of this footage from "The Cage" does make the feat of hiring such a robust cast for this episode a little less impressive, I still think this episode is fantastic. This episode may exist because of budgetary and time issues but Roddenberry does a great job of tying it all together.

I love the tone of this episode. The way Spock is portrayed, you really have no idea what his intentions are; the episode leaves this part vague, really causing a sense of tension. Nimoy and Shatner have some great scenes in this one. I also enjoyed how Spock has had every single contingency planned out, even anticipating Kirk's pursuit.

One of the better episodes up to this point, we will see if part two can deliver on a great front end.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A peek at the Trek that could have been
Fluke_Skywalker20 August 2016
Warning: Spoilers
Plot; Spock concocts an elaborate hijacking of the Enterprise in an effort to return his former Captain, now gravely injured, to a planet deemed forbidden by the Federation for reasons only he and Pike know.

Iconic two-parter is a reworking of the original (and ultimately rejected) pilot episode titled "The Cage", with Spock's plot to hijack the Enterprise and the subsequent fallout a wraparound. The mystery of Spock's behavior and the tension it creates is handled fairly well and acts as the driving force behind the story. And it was, to borrow one of Spock's well known sayings, fascinating to get a look at the Trek that could have been.

Jeffery Hunter as Christopher Pike is a very different presence than William Shatner, but he's far from the stiff Ken doll I'd always thought him to be. Hunter, with his powerful physique and matinée idol looks, certainly looks the part of a heroic space captain, but he shows a far broader spectrum than I'd given him credit for. It was also fun to get a look at Nimoy's Spock before he and the writers had gotten a handle on him. The Spock shown in "The Cage" portions of the episodes conflicts with the cool, dispassionate Spock that has become so iconic. In one scene, when the away team land on the planet, he even grins with a child-like glee upon discovering a strange pit of flora.

There are any number of flaws in--if you'll pardon the usage--logic here. Chief among them for me is that there is never a connection between Spock and Pike in "The Cage" portions of the story that would precipitate the former risking death and acting so against character. That it isn't a fatal flaw shows how well the rest of the elements work.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Clever use of the original pilot episode
snoozejonc6 March 2021
Spock takes control of the Enterprise for a personal mission.

I enjoyed this one for the great use of the original pilot episode as part of a different story.

The plot, as other reviewers have stated, does have more holes than a Swiss cheese, but it's very entertaining nonetheless.

This first part includes a compelling sequence involving Spock's seizure of the Enterprise and a look back at some of the best parts of The Cage. Yes, it's a clip show Jim, but not as we know it.

All the characters moments involving Kirk, Spock and Bones are excellent. Even little touches, such as Uhura's reaction to the events unfolding are very well done.

Leonard Nimoy is the star of this one and he carries it fantastically well, but William Shatner, DeForest Kelley and in particular guest actor Michael Throne also make great contributions.
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Death to go to Talos IV
bkoganbing6 December 2014
For those who speculate on how Star Trek might have turned out had the original cast from the original pilot been used, the two part episode The Menagerie is your chance to see. Instead of dying after an injury on a film set Jeffrey Hunter had been with the Star Trek series for it's three season run, would it have become the iconic thing it has? Would Hunter be the cult figure that William Shatner has?

In Menagerie Shatner on a space station lay over with the Enterprise discovers his predecessor Captain Christopher Pike now confined to a futuristic wheelchair, his body destroyed pretty much by an explosion. Leonard Nimoy was part of the crew that served with Captain Pike.

The arrival of the Enterprise at the space station however is all part of a carefully laid plan by Leonard Nimoy. He takes the Enterprise out with Captain Pike on board and they're heading to Talos IV a planet where the Federation has prohibited visiting under penalty of death.

Shatner with Malachi Throne the commander of the space station gives pursuit in a shuttle craft. But when the craft runs out of fuel Nimoy halts the Enterprise and submits himself for court martial. As his defense we see very accurate computer records of Captain Pike's journey to Talos IV when it was unexplored by the Federation.

Here we see Jeffrey Hunter as Pike answering a distress call on Talos IV and when they arrive there he and an away team beam down to get the survivors. But the Talosians take Hunter prisoner down to an underground city where they live.

What they want him for and why visiting Talos IV is death is in the second part, but it has a lot to do with the beautiful Susan Oliver one of the survivors.

A lot of Christopher Pike's character is later incorporated into James Kirk. I would say Captain Kirk is a far more intellectual character than Pike, but Pike's no slouch in the brain department. Spock is not a fully formed character, we really have no point of reference for him in the Menagerie episode only. The rest all come in the cast we all have come to know.
7 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Not too badly mangled by new "Re-Imagined" digital effects
XweAponX18 July 2012
The 10-star rating is for the parts of this that CBS did not walk all over with size 12 digital Doc Marten boots.

They did add some glittery garbage at the beginning of this episode, like where Julie Parrish looks up in the sky and sees a huge Skyscape of ringed planets.

The "Number One" Villain of this digital trampling was David Fosse: It would have been much worse if Mike and Denise Okuda had not been involved somewhat. As it was, Fosse totally ruined the beautiful shot of the USS Enterprise being buffeted at the Galaxy's Rim in the remastered 2nd Pilot "Where No Man Has Gone Before"-Replacing it not with a good digital representation of a classic shot done photographically in the 60's - He CHANGED it, as he changed the Murasaki Quasar in "Gallileo Seven"-Those episodes were No Longer Star Trek.

But in THIS landmark two-part episode which was based on the original pilot of the series, they basically left a lot of it alone, especially in the segments where the Original Pilot footage was used. It looked good in the 60's and it still looks good now.

"The Cage" - The First Pilot starring Jeffery Hunter, Leonard Nimoy and the then Majel Lee Hudec (Later to become Barrett/Roddenberry) is edited to fit within the framing story of the "Court Martial Fantasy" instigated by The Talosians.

This is the core of The Original Series: The fact that we can watch this episode and BELIEVE IT - We do not have to take anything for granted, it is all shown to us here. There is no reason for any "Grains of Salt" - This is Gene Roddenberry's Masterpiece, this is *his* Star Trek, and it was not overly bloated with the "enhancements" of Fosse: Nothing was "Re- imagined" because there was no need for any re-imagining. Majel Lee Hudec as "Number One" brings a Laser cannon down to the planet and they try to blow the top off of a rock face, and that effect remains as beautiful as it originally appeared, to me, over 40 years ago.

That is the entire problem with all of the digital "enhancements" - There really was no need for them, and to CHANGE their nature, to CHANGE those classic images is a crime.

Of all the "enhanced" episodes I've watched, so far, this one remains fairly close to the way the original looked. I can live with it, it was not ruined like "The Doomsday Machine" or "The Gallileo Seven"
8 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
It was the logical thing to do.
thevacinstaller1 April 2022
Warning: Spoilers
This episode is a testament to the talent of Gene Roddenberry to repurpose the failed (but amazing) pilot and create a compelling and engaging episode on what must have been a shoestring budget.

I really enjoyed the experience of seeing Spock's loyalty to Captain Pike play out in this episode. Nimoy's exit from the court martial is classic Spock ---- No need to insult me Captain --- it was logical.

I also enjoy when the writers of star trek episodes are paying attention to potential plot holes ----- How was all of this recorded? Well, it's because the Talosians are super advanced! That's all I needed to know.

Of the many successes of TOS, managing to create a believable bond of friendship between Kirk/Spock/McCoy is the greatest asset to deepening the impact of having these characters in peril in future episodes.

Tight script, great performances, great episode of star trek.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed