Art Carney's Elwood P. Dowd was the quintessential portrayal of the role. I agree with other comments that Art Carney's Elwood P. Dowd had more whimsy and life than Jimmy Stewart's. After fifty years, I still remember this TV production fondly. I believe I saw it in summer re-run as well as the original air date. I, too, saw the 1950 Stewart movie after seeing Art Carney do the part. Jimmy Stewart underplayed the role, while Carney added enough subtle "Ed Norton" to make the character more sprightly. It's not that one performance is better than the other, but they showed different aspects of the character. I also remember Marion Lorne and Jack Weston as hoots. I would like to see it on DVD, also.
6 Reviews
Watching the Fur Fly!
jackbuckley-050491 January 2021
For starters, this version of "Harvey" IS available on dvd, through the Film Collectors Society of America, which is how I obtained it. Picture & sound-quality much-better than I expected. Imagery slightly-faded but acceptably, adequately clear. Pretty-smooth production overall, considering it was performed live, if I understand correctly. I detected no moments of flubbed-lines, uncooperative-props, or clumsy camera-shots. Despite the eccentricities of various-characters, everyone acted naturally within the context of the premise. Watching Marion Lorne can be a trial at times, i.e., her patented confused & flustered portrayals, but she's very-good at it, actually conveying sympathy & affection for her by story's-end. Carney's excellent as Elwood P. Dowd, the fanciful-fellow who's convinced that Harvey's real--and very-nearly convinces others, including the director of the sanitarium! In terms of today, the comedy's a little-strained but remains likeable & pleasantly-amusing throughout. It's fun to see Elizabeth Montgomery in a pre-Bewitched role as the pretty-nurse, who comes to empathize & even a little-infatuated with the ever-gallant Elwood. Now that I've seen this version, I think I prefer Carney in the role of the rabbit-seeing eccentric, as opposed to Jimmy Stewart's version. Stewart inhabits & is very-effective as Elwood but he's such a familiar-actor that one finds this aspect somewhat difficult to get-past. Carney seems fresh & less-mannered or studied than Stewart. One detects the latter as "playing" an eccentric, whereas Carney is completely-natural & totally-believable, usually Stewart's strong-suit. The ending to the story is both sweet & touching, along with a magical-twist. In short, this Dupont Show of the Month from 1958 holds up well & definitely is worth-seeing. In modern movie-terms, I can see Tom Hanks in the role of Elwood, an actor always-capable of conveying likeability, believability, and sincerity. This is what "Harvey" is all about.
Charming film I've always loved.
smokehill retrievers18 August 2014
I remember this film so well, though I was only about eleven or twelve when I saw it. I'm not sure if I had seen the Jimmy Stewart version before, but I THINK I had.
I would love to see this version again. I loved Art Carney's interpretation and would like to see how it stacks up against the "original" that i have now seen ... I dunno, maybe 25 times.
I also thoroughly enjoyed Harry Anderson's version, though to me his performance seemed .... well, rushed. I suppose he was trying to put a slightly different personality into the role, and I believe that is a good thing to do. I just liked the slower-paced, more relaxed Elwood that Jimmy Stewart showed us. That Elwood seemed happier ... or at least more contented ... than Harry's version. And that's the Elwood I would prefer to sit down and have a quiet drink with. And with Harvey, too, of course.
In many ways I preferred Swoosie Kurtz's interpretation of Veda, Elwood's sister, to the admittedly fabulous "original" one. And I did enjoy the rocking chair at the end ... definitely different from the Stewart ending, but I did like it very much. I recall the Carney ending as being similar to the "original," though I believe that we saw Harvey's shadow right before the fadeout. Not positive, though, which is one reason I'd love to see it again.
It would be nice to have Art Carney's version to see, as an adult, so I could really compare it with the others.
I would love to see this version again. I loved Art Carney's interpretation and would like to see how it stacks up against the "original" that i have now seen ... I dunno, maybe 25 times.
I also thoroughly enjoyed Harry Anderson's version, though to me his performance seemed .... well, rushed. I suppose he was trying to put a slightly different personality into the role, and I believe that is a good thing to do. I just liked the slower-paced, more relaxed Elwood that Jimmy Stewart showed us. That Elwood seemed happier ... or at least more contented ... than Harry's version. And that's the Elwood I would prefer to sit down and have a quiet drink with. And with Harvey, too, of course.
In many ways I preferred Swoosie Kurtz's interpretation of Veda, Elwood's sister, to the admittedly fabulous "original" one. And I did enjoy the rocking chair at the end ... definitely different from the Stewart ending, but I did like it very much. I recall the Carney ending as being similar to the "original," though I believe that we saw Harvey's shadow right before the fadeout. Not positive, though, which is one reason I'd love to see it again.
It would be nice to have Art Carney's version to see, as an adult, so I could really compare it with the others.
Art Carney as Elwood P Dowd
mesakid30 October 2006
I saw this TV version many years ago and it stuck in my mind, I believe I saw it before I saw the Jimmy Stewart Movie version For my money I liked this version better, I believe Art Carney brought a little more pathos and whimsy to the role. Maybe I was presold on Carney because I was a die-hard Honeymoooners fan, even as a child Art Carney Fan. For Art Carney fans I recommend the movie Late Show with Lillie Tomlin or Harry and Tonto I believe this production of Harvey was one of the best of the Golden Age of Television productions. The entire cast was very good, and Elizabeth Montgomery was appealing in an early unbewitched role.
I loved this version for Marion Lorne!
tonisavage22 March 2006
I had been crazy about her since her Garry Moore Show appearances, and seeing her as the ditsy sister Veta was wonderful.
She and Josephine Hull (the original Veta) were very under-utilized actresses. Josephine Hull was on Broadway a lot, but only her Harvey and Arsenic and Old Lace were captured on film. A great loss, I'm sure (though I'm too young to have seen her on Broadway).
Art Carney made a wonderful Elwood P. Dowd, too, though not quite as good as Jimmy Stewart. Perhaps Stewart and Lorne would have been too much ditsy!
After nearly 50 years, I still remember this production. I sure wish this was available on DVD!
She and Josephine Hull (the original Veta) were very under-utilized actresses. Josephine Hull was on Broadway a lot, but only her Harvey and Arsenic and Old Lace were captured on film. A great loss, I'm sure (though I'm too young to have seen her on Broadway).
Art Carney made a wonderful Elwood P. Dowd, too, though not quite as good as Jimmy Stewart. Perhaps Stewart and Lorne would have been too much ditsy!
After nearly 50 years, I still remember this production. I sure wish this was available on DVD!
Half a rabbit is better than none
jwpeel-124 February 2006
Warning: Spoilers
In the prehistoric days of the 1950's, parents held firm on children's bedtime. I know, because my own mother told me ahead of time that I could only see half of this wonderful show because the second half was after my bedtime. I already knew Art Carney as Ed Norton from "The Honeymooners" and loved the story of the six foot plus invisible rabbit SPOILER ALERT: (though, I confess that I was disappointed not seeing the rabbit in the show, especially since publicity shots for the show depicted Carney with a man in a rabbit suit, arms around shoulders.) At the time, I didn't really know character actors like Charlotte Rae, Jack Weston or Fred Gwynne though I had seen them in other shows.
What I did remember was how enchanting Carney's Elwood P. Dowd as much as the Jimmy Stewart characterization in the 1950 film. Oh to own this TV production, I hope one day it becomes available somehow.
What I did remember was how enchanting Carney's Elwood P. Dowd as much as the Jimmy Stewart characterization in the 1950 film. Oh to own this TV production, I hope one day it becomes available somehow.
See also
Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews
