Of course, it's just impossible to see this movie without thinking about Marie Trintignant's death and for some sequences (like when Sergi Lopez is shouting at her), it's really hard and sad. But,this movie deserve to be seen also for what it is: a good comedy, funny, pretty original with a lot of excellent musical moments. Even Christophe Lambert is brilliant in it, playing an ex-LSD addict. So, if you like Janis Joplin, if you like to laugh and if you want to see how beautiful, gifted and touching Marie was, just see this film. Bye Marie.
7 Reviews
You'd better go and buy the O.S.T.
rainking_es26 February 2005
"Janis et John" begins with kind of a criticism of the modern life, and ends with such a parabola about love and loneliness. But that only takes us 10 or 15 minutes
in between we got a not very brilliant comedy, with an absurd plot, and such ridiculous dialogs ("¿In which band did Lennon play? Was it the Stones?"). A great soundtrack and a bunch of nice actors. There's nothing else to tell about one of the last works of Marie Trintignant (before his boyfriend beat her to death). Maybe "Janis et john" is not the best epitaph for an actress, but it definitely shows the talent of Marie.
My rate: 5/10
My rate: 5/10
Influence of American culture on French media
FilmCriticLalitRao18 November 2008
The influence of American culture on French media is huge.Most of the French people are passionate about English books,cinema and music.This is because of the fact that American troops were stationed in France on many occasions and their presence has left an indelible mark on the psyche of most of the French people who are not satisfied with what is produced in their country in the fields of arts and culture.This is the reason why since a long time Hollywood cinema is able to dominate cinema culture all over France.Janis and John is a good example of domination of Anglo Saxon culture over French culture.All credit must go to director Samuel Benchetrit for making a film about how French people view two of the most popular musical legends.Janis and John is an intelligent film as it has its own fair share of laughs.It has not been able to become a cult film despite the fact that it was one of the last films in which Marie Trintignant played a leading role before her untimely death.One of the most troublesome aspect of this film is the lack of good music whether in the form of some good songs or some good background score.The positive aspect of this film is the impeccable acting from versatile actors such as Jean Louis Trintignant,Sergi Lopez and François Cluzet.
Funny, moving and intelligent
wrb125 November 2003
In deep monetary trouble, a man must convince an old friend - an ex-LSD addict who believes he met Janis Joplin and John Lennon in the 70s - that his idols have come to visit him to make one last album, for which they will need money.
A highly intelligent script that is extremely well acted and both funny and moving at the same time. The fact that this was Marie Trintignant's last film makes it all the more moving as most of the storyline focuses on her character's transformation from meek housewife to all singing, Janis Joplin impersonating sensation. The performance is among her best and you almost forget that you are watching her play a role. This film is a must-see! I really hope it is released in England too!
A highly intelligent script that is extremely well acted and both funny and moving at the same time. The fact that this was Marie Trintignant's last film makes it all the more moving as most of the storyline focuses on her character's transformation from meek housewife to all singing, Janis Joplin impersonating sensation. The performance is among her best and you almost forget that you are watching her play a role. This film is a must-see! I really hope it is released in England too!
Just No.
jackasstrange9 November 2013
Warning: Spoilers
If there were a prize for the most tasteless comedy film of the year 2003, such award would go to Janis et John. Jesus Christ, that was bad. And despite having a somewhat interesting theme, it basically fails developing it.
The most interesting fact in the film BY FAR is that it seems to be a homage to David Fincher's Fight Club, notably one of my favorite films. It's easy to realize the obvious references to it in this film. For example, the initial sequence of the film utilizes the same narrative of FC(the explanations about the protagonist and his thoughts in fast paced scenes), the job is the same, and even the cinematography and the credits song 'Where is my Mind' by Pixies appears in the film.
OK, there is more in the film than references to FC. But very little,of course. The story itself is not that convincing. The internal logic isn't that great. The actors were mostly bad or if lucky below- average, except maybe for the protagonist. Also, the film missed a few points, i mean , few important points, such as the lack of explanations about what happened to the guy who played 'John Lennon'. And what happened to the mad/high cousin of the protagonist, as well. We don't have any idea of that in the end of the film. And what kind of resolution was that between the protagonist and the old men which wanted his money? And why he did enter in the house? Anyways, a few points which don't makes any sense to me.
Yes, it's not worth of a watch. 4.0/10
The most interesting fact in the film BY FAR is that it seems to be a homage to David Fincher's Fight Club, notably one of my favorite films. It's easy to realize the obvious references to it in this film. For example, the initial sequence of the film utilizes the same narrative of FC(the explanations about the protagonist and his thoughts in fast paced scenes), the job is the same, and even the cinematography and the credits song 'Where is my Mind' by Pixies appears in the film.
OK, there is more in the film than references to FC. But very little,of course. The story itself is not that convincing. The internal logic isn't that great. The actors were mostly bad or if lucky below- average, except maybe for the protagonist. Also, the film missed a few points, i mean , few important points, such as the lack of explanations about what happened to the guy who played 'John Lennon'. And what happened to the mad/high cousin of the protagonist, as well. We don't have any idea of that in the end of the film. And what kind of resolution was that between the protagonist and the old men which wanted his money? And why he did enter in the house? Anyways, a few points which don't makes any sense to me.
Yes, it's not worth of a watch. 4.0/10
an expected nice comedy becoming a cult movie
Alexis-IMDB7 September 2004
The first time I watched this movie, I thought it was a good surprise as I'd never heard about it before: a funny comedy, with good actors and a creative director. But something in that film attracted me to watch it again (what I rarely do) and I really felt in love with it. Sergi Lopez, Francois Cluzet and Marie Trintigant are amazing: in an absurd situation, with extreme characters (especially Cluzet), they are more than credible. Sergi Lopez performance is unique: a subtle equilibrium between burlesque and tragedy.
The text is extremely well written and precise. Technically, the movie is very creative (I'm waiting for the next Benchetrit work).
Each time I see this movie, I love it more. rating: 10/10 as it is a cult movie to me
The text is extremely well written and precise. Technically, the movie is very creative (I'm waiting for the next Benchetrit work).
Each time I see this movie, I love it more. rating: 10/10 as it is a cult movie to me
i saw it in Paris opening night
michael-219510 August 2006
i happened to be in Paris for the opening night. i accidentally made it in to the showing by chance, i knew someone who knew someone, etc. the Joplin family was in attendance. also the family of Marie Trintignant who had just passed away soon before the showing of this. it was all very intense. i don't speak french much and since we were watching this in France there were no subtitles for me to read. even with all that, i could definitely follow the story well even without the words. i actually loved it. later i was able to get a script and a working copy subtitled and then i truly liked it even more. i wish it was out there available for us to see... it's a classic.
See also
Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews
