Fragile as the World (2001) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
It's monotonous but it's beautiful!
mario_c26 April 2006
Warning: Spoilers
It's an artistic movie about the forbidden love of two young teenagers that live in a small village, lost somewhere… It's like a tale, where their love is stronger than anything else, even their own lives…

Vera loves João, but she doesn't want anyone to know her feelings about him, especially her aunt. When her grandfather tells her a popular tale about a Muslim princess that once loved a Christian prince from a near kingdom (in Portugal there is a lot of popular tales about Muslims princesses…) and that they ran into the woods so they could continue their forbidden love, she decides to do the same with her beloved João… They walk into the woods; they want that no one can find them again. They are intentionally lost in the forest. Now these moments are just for them. They share secrets, love, affections, silences (we can hear the birds singing…); they promise to never separate again, not even for one second! But she gets sick after a few days. When he listens hunter's sounds in the forest he goes asking for help, but he got lost. When he finally found her, she was already dead…he carried her in his arms into the river so they could die together…

The poetry has a strong presence in this movie, as the all film was just like a poem on the screen. It's almost all shot in Black and White, except a few scenes in the forest, at the beginning and at the middle, when they are living their fairy-tale romance…The black and white effect gives an artistic touch to the movie (especially when human faces are portrayed…it seems they are like uncoloured paintings!), but I think it would be much more beautiful if the fantastic ambiences of the woods were coloured! And the proof of that is the short scene where we can see the forest with all its colours accompanied by a magnificent piece of music from Renascence… In my opinion, that's the best scene of the film.

It's not an easy movie to watch, you can only enjoy it if you see it as a piece of art! Many people won't like it just because of some "particular characteristics", which are purposed and give it the poetic and artistic style: The black and white colours on the screen, its slowness, the voices are all theatrically spoken, the poetic language, the stilled portraits (sometimes we can hear the characters speaking while their faces are still and their mouths shut!), in one word, the monotony of the movie! It's monotonous but it's beautiful, but it's just my opinion of course…

The title of the movie, Frágil como o Mundo (Weak As The World), is extracted from a Sophia de Mello Breyner Adresen's poem: «Terror de te amar num sítio tão frágil como o mundo» (Terror of loving you in a place as weak as the world). Sophia de Mello Breyner Adresen is one of the best contemporaneous Portuguese writers.

I'll give it 7 out of 10 because of its poetic style.
9 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
RITA AZEVEDO GOMES
mehobulls7 August 2020
A dream of young love as the centre on which all benevolent nature revolves, only for that grace to be revealed as blindness. Quite beautiful in its stillness, & visual immersion as a subjective ideal, evoking a reflection of the floating world to mirror the protagonists emotional response, all is wonder as their reality drifts into a visual inertia, not able to freeze the moment they so desire
3 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed