Falstaff (TV Movie 1995) Poster

(1995 TV Movie)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
A treasure, both as a production and as an opera...
TheLittleSongbird2 April 2012
Note that this is not Verdi's opera of the same name, but Salieri's Falstaff. I admit I am more familiar with the Verdi Falstaff and may perhaps prefer it, but Salieri's Falstaff has many charms of its own, with the obvious reasons being Salieri's skilled and very beautiful music reminding me of Mozart(Le Nozze Di Figaro) and Rossini(Il Barbiere Di Siviglia) a bit- even if the music is not exactly instantly memorable it is still beautifully structured with enough of Salieri's style-, and the hilarious libretto. And this production is a treasure, funny, beautifully designed and very well sung and acted.

The costumes are colourful and sometimes amusing, and the settings are authentic and charming. The picture quality is mostly clear and giving the production a certain charm to it, and while an Amazon reviewer criticised the sound I thought it was fine, one of the better balanced sound quality recordings I've heard recently. The stage direction bubbles along very nicely, with the highlight being Mistress Ford coming on in disguise pretending to speak a bit of German and English and Falstaff professes to speak only English and a little German. Listening closely, you'd find that the two characters are actually singing in Italian with laces of German and even French. The whole scene really is a hoot.

Musically, it is just great, with stylish playing from the orchestra and Arnold Ostmann's conducting brisk and assured while never rushing in the arias/ariosos yet still giving the ensembles a sense of life or plodding in the recitatives. The theater is somewhat small, but considering the style of music this worked better than a large building such as the Met where the orchestra could be slightly swamped. And before I forget, I loved the subtitles, very zesty and witty. The comedic moments are a great many, and there is never a dull moment, if anything the mood builds up as the opera progresses.

Other than John DelCarlo, whose Falstaff is vocally robust and dramatically riveting whether it is the comic timing or his imposing physique, the standout was Richard Croft's Ford. Croft is absolutely wonderful here, one of my personal favourite performances of his and this is coming from someone who likes him very much, making the most of his two jealousy arias, athletic command of the stage and of course his voice which shows real virtuosity especially in his second scene. That is not to dispute Jake Gardner's effective Slender or Carlos Feller's grumbling and very amusing Bardolfo(a character I do prefer here to Verdi's Bardolph, who I personally find is often portrayed as too clownish).

As for the women, they are equally good, if not as virtuosic as the men. Dramatically Teresa Ringholz is the one who impressed me, her comic timing is excellent and a big part of why her scene with DelCarlo(the one I mentioned earlier) worked so well. Her singing is tuneful and resonant, if slightly lacking in agility and style. Two things that vocally Dolores Ziegler does have, and while her scenes are not as juicy as that of Ringholz's, Ziegler matches her with the quality of the comic timing. Darla Brooks is good as Betty, though her role is not as prominent or interesting as the rest I feel.

In conclusion, a treasure. 10/10 Bethany Cox
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Sparkling Salieri!
gpadillo31 August 2004
This production is about as sparkling a work as I've seen in quite some time. Salieri's score shows very heavy influences of his rival, Mozart, in particular his overture reminded me a good bit of Nozze di Figaro. It's perhaps easy to see (or hear) why Mozart outshone Salieri. Mozart (we know) was genius who accomplished the unbelievable and amazing in such a brief span of life. Nonetheless, Salieri is very worthy of exploration and his works, this in particular, should be heard by modern audiences. I can't think of a better production to do the introduction than this ArtHaus DVD.

In the title role, we are treated to a spirited, infectiously joyful performance by John Del Carlo. He looks exactly like my perfect Verdian Falstaff and his music is inspired. Salieri's recitatives are often as exciting as his arias and ensembles, and he's fairly daring in his structure of this work with ensembles, recits, arias, double recits, etc. flowing in and out of each other was masterful creativity.

What a delight to see Delores Ziegler as Mistress Slender. Ziegler's comic timing is nearly the match of Del Carlo's and again Salieri has given his cast some tough music.

Speaking of tough music, the assignment Salieri gives Ford (as opposed to Verdi's Ford, we get a tenor), is met with near athletic aplomb and virtuosity by my favorite tenor, Richard Croft. Croft plays the jealous Ford with the skill of a great actor, his body language, even when he's just listening and reacting to Slender's scheming reveals much about this character. Croft throws out some dazzling vocal fireworks in his 2nd scene's aria and recitative. While some critics complain that even late Salieri sounds older than early Mozart, I won't agree. Some of his music, (aforementioned aria in particular) almost sounds Rossinian! Ditto the Act I quartet with the Slenders and the Fords.

Teresa Ringholz does not possess my favorite type of voice, but as Mistress Ford, she shows herself to be a great comic actress and she shows a sense of Salierian style (?!) and her voice actually grew on me to the point where she had me cheering her on several times.

I can think of a few listers who won't want to hear this, but I think anyone looking for something a bit off the beaten path (okay, more than a "bit" off it), thoroughly tuneful, and with near nonstop comic action by performers who are clearly having a damned good time, I can't recommend this enough.

Michael Hampe's stylish sets and costumes are a perfect fit for the tiny Schwetzingen stage making it appear both much larger and smaller than it really is. Arnold Ostman and the Stuttgart Radio Symphony are inspired sounding like they're racing off to a fire. Once or twice that makes it feel as though a singer might not make it (there really is some virtuoso singing going on) but they do and the time flies by.

It's difficult not to fall in love with Salieri's sparkling opera!
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed