Marine Battleground (1963) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
War Is Grim Business!!!
zardoz-1326 April 2023
Warning: Spoilers
Jock Mahoney plays Nick, an American war correspondent in South Vietnam, who catches up with a young Nurse Young Hi Park (Pat Yi) in a hospital ward where she relates her tragic story about her escapades as a young orphan girl who survived the blood soaked fighting during the amphibious invasion Inchon and became a good luck mascot of sorts for a South Korean Marine platoon.

"Marine Battleground" opens with footage of the South Korean Marines landing on the beach at Inchon. They arrive in armored personnel carriers that disperses troops from the rear of the vehicle. During the merciless combat which ensues, a courageous Marine platoon rescues an adolescent girl Young-hui (Jeon Young-sun) after they watch as her poor mother is riddled by enemy gunfire. The intrepid Marines ignore gunfire galore to rescue the little waif, and then conceal her within their ranks from their officers as they march off into one hard-fought engagement after another.

These 'war as hell' flashback scenes constitute the bulk of this gritty, black & white film about tenacious but outnumbered South Korean soldiers. At one point, Yi's platoon of 'uncles' are sacrificed by their commanders to halt an invasion of Red Chinese soldiers. The enemy swarm like a veritable tidal wave of insurgents from the mountains down into a valley and eventually overrun the stoutly defended South Korean position. Basically, these brave soldiers are whittled down to a mere handful of men as they put stiff resistance. A veteran of the Korean War himself, director Lee Man-hee stages some fierce combat scenes, but characterization remains sketchy at best, with only few of the soldiers fleshed out as characters that we cannot identify with their plight. By the time this war epic concludes, Nick understands why.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
See it for the cinematography
phlbrq5811 December 2020
Clumsy drama doesn't negate the remarkable b&w look of this film. There is a credible authority in this production.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Korean-US production of fine workmanship.
dreist25 March 2016
Warning: Spoilers
Finally after days of waiting, this morning The Marines Who Never Returned I arrived home and I immediately slingshots to see it. Lasciatemetelo say: Truly amazing! This Korean film since it has been realized by means of a co-production with the U.S. We can clearly see that the budget used is more higher than other numerous Korean war movie of the time and this is affected positively. The explosions are spectacular, the weapons when firing are very bad and look real, and the actors look like real soldiers, not only about acting but also by how they move, how they cover, how they attack. It is said that "seen a war movie, seen them all", it is not so because this time this film does not give a sense of already seen, has a soul and a story! I do not know it was based on a true story, but I would just criticize the English title "The Marines Who Never Returned" because virtually anticipates how it ends. Better the other title "Marines battleground". For the rest of recommended movies, and high-involvement!
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
The Mascot
bkoganbing2 May 2020
In Marine Battleground Jock Mahoney plays a war correspondent who finds an intriguing story from Nurse Pat Yi. She's a dedicated anti-communist and Mahoney gets the whole story.

Back during the Korean War Ni's whole family iskilled by the invading north. The Koreans in this Marine company make her a mascot and she tells of their times together the good and the bad right up to when Koreans made a last ditch stand. very few come away from this battle.

This was a sincere effort. Sadly between combat scenes it's dull as dishwater. The film could have used better direction.

For war film fans only.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed