Devil's Island - Within the Palisade (1899) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
The Dreyfus Affair #3
Tornado_Sam15 September 2018
For a good chunk of his output in 1899, Georges Méliès committed himself to creating a series of short films detailing the events of the Dreyfus Affair political scandal, which was still progressing in France as the series was made. The serial, centering around Capt. Alfred Dreyfus who was accused of writing treasonous letters and discharged as a result, flared up the public which had already been divided into two groups: the Dreyfusards and the Anti-Dreyfusards (Méliès was one of the former). In the end, censorship was the answer--theater owners couldn't handle the disputes that the serial caused during showings. Thus, "The Dreyfus Affair" is now considered the first censored political movie.

"Devil's Island--Within the Palisade" is episode three in this serial docudrama, following "The Degradation of Dreyfus" (now unavailable online but not lost) and preceding "Dreyfus Put in Irons". The title of the movie sets the scene for the installment, in which Dreyfus is shown, as we are told, within the palisade on Devil's Island (using an incredibly realistic, not to mention well-painted, backdrop to set the scene). Portrayed by the unidentified iron-worker who bore an uncanny resemblance to him, Dreyfus is shown to be pacing in this enclosure, meditating on a rock despondently. Soon, an officer enters and hands him a letter from his wife (this is not apparent unless you read the summary on Wikipedia) which he reads. Like others in the serial, it no doubt caused controversy because of the depressive state Dreyfus is shown in. Méliès once more proves how pro-Dreyfusard he is. Another well-made feature in the series.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Dreyfus 2 of 8
Michael_Elliott28 March 2008
Dreyfus Court Martial - Arrest of Dreyfuss (1899)

Dreyfus: Devil's Island - Within the Palisade (1899)

Dreyfus Put in Irons (1899)

Dreyfuss Dreyfus: Suicide of Colonel Henry (1899)

Landing of Dreyfus at Quiberon (1899)

Dreyfus Meets His Wife at Rennes (1899)

The Fight of Reporters (1899)

Dreyfus: The Court Martial at rennes (1899)

This here is a eight-film series centering around one character and I must say I don't really understand what Melies was going for unless he was simply trying to make nine different movies to sell to people and earn more money by doing it. None of the nine films are very interesting but put together I guess they hold some interest but none of them are entertaining enough to make the series work. You can read the titles and know exactly what happens as each film runs just over a minute and nothing too special happens in any of them. The most interesting one is Landing of Dreyfus at Quiberon as it does contain some special effects in the form of a lightening storm but these effects aren't too good as several of the lightening strikes hit the people in the action but of course they don't feel it.
0 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed