Ten Ladies in One Umbrella (1903) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Bumbershoot bamboozles
I viewed the Library of Congress print of this George Méliès 'trick' film. As was often the case, Méliès himself plays the conjuror who presides over the magical proceedings.

We see a backdrop with a French inscription which translates as 'Galatea Theatre'. Apparently Méliès expected audiences in 1903 to be literate enough to recognise this as a reference to the Greek myth of Pygmalion. Wielding an umbrella as his magic wand, Méliès uses his bumbershoot to materialise ten different ma'mselles, each of whom is dressed to symbolise a different nationality. The ladies then strike a tableau, the scenery and their costumes transforming to suggest ancient Greece. Méliès magically morphs their clothing into garb appropriate for modern ladies of 1903 vintage: he bows, and exits.

In 1903, and for some years thereafter, it was still popular for stage performers to offer 'tableaux' or 'living statues', in which the actors would freeze in position to illustrate some dramatic situation, while the audience applauded. We get an example of that here. I find Méliès's films more significant for what they reveal about his own time (which is genuine but unintentional) than for their magical or supernatural events (which are intended as the point of his films, but which are of course fake).

The ma'mselles are quite pretty in their cozzies, and any student of the history of theatrical costumes would do well to watch this film. My rating: 7 out of 10.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Amazing stuff for 1903, though very outdated today.
planktonrules6 September 2020
To really appreciate the films of Georges Méliès, you need to understand that all the tricks he used in his pictures were brand new when he created them. So, while making things appear and disappear and change on camera might see old hat today and his films a bit old fashioned, back in 1903 they were cutting edge and were often copied by lesser filmmakers.

In "The Fantastic Umbrella", you essentially have a magician (which Georges Méliès was before he was a filmmaker) come onto the set and do tricks. Using his large black umbrella, he manages to make ten women appear. Then, he changes their costumes, the sets and more until they ultimately dance off stage.

Making things appear or change was simple...he would just turn off the camera, make folks assume the same position and then then make the changes and turn the camera back on...giving the impression that things are really changing before your very eyes. And, like too many of his films, it ends with the women inexplicably dancing off! It's very well done for the time, but also pretty familiar to his many, many other films....as he directed well over 500 short films in only a decade and a half!
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Magic Umbrellas
Hitchcoc14 November 2017
One of the most common bits in these films is using an inanimate object to produce women. In this one, the magician trots around the stage, flipping things that turn into the aforementioned women. After this happens, there are silly encounters with them. Their whole purpose for existing seems to be to fill the screen. The magician leaves the stage in one of those crazy dances. This is the best part of the film.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Ten Ladies in One Umbrella
Michael_Elliott25 June 2008
Ten Ladies in One Umbrella (1903)

** 1/2 (out of 4)

aka Parapluie fantastique, La

Taking place in what appears to be meant as a circus sideshow, this film has Melies playing a magician who magically makes ten women appear out of an umbrella. This isn't one of the director's best films and it's not even that original since he has done previous films dealing with this subject matter but in the end it's still a pleasant enough little movie. The special effects are still very good and the magic tricks appear very fresh today even though these here are easy to spot on how they are being done. Melies himself is very energetic here and is a true delight to watch. Another added bonus is that the ten women are wearing clothing from different parts of the world, which also makes this a good time travel piece.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed