User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
interesting if not arousing
movieman_kev3 November 2005
A collection of early shorts (a combination of old stag films, vintage shorts, cartoons, and films made for the Penny Arcades) is narrated (seldomly) by an unknown voice over guy in this documentary/ Compilation piece by Alex De Renzy, who himself would go on to become a highly regard porn director (his best stuff being made in the late 70's and much of the '80's. The film is interesting if only to see how much porn advanced in some ways, but didn't at all in others. There's nothing to really get aroused to in here, but if you ever were interested in how it all got started, then this will have you fascinated to no end. (well except for some of the filler)

My Grade: B-
11 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Great early stag movie compilation attempt
Schlockmeister28 May 2001
This movie came out, of course, pre-video, and while there are many, many video companies out now who specialize in early stag movies, this was one of the first attempts to put a compilation of some of the oldest blue movies out for the theatre audience. Included are scenes from "Grass Sandwich", one of the earliest stag films known, made in 1915, highly contraversial early loops like "The Nun" and the Candy Barr film "Smart Aleck", to flesh this movie out, as it were, more modern (1960s and 1970) loops are shown as well. Some of the prints shown were of very high quality for their ages, which often surpasses the multi-generation prints we often see in modern video early stag compilations.

If early smoker and blue movies are of interest to you, this is one video worth seeking out.
15 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
History is Made at Night
Nodriesrespect11 September 2007
This is clearly the best compilation of early "stag" footage, the only other one worthy of serious consideration being Bill Osco's Hollywood BLUE. It contains all those fabled favorites that once only saw the insides of brothels and affiliated "gentlemen's clubs" you may just have heard or read about.

The earliest American stag movie (or "smoker", as opposed to "loop", a term which did not enter common usage until the blue movie arcades and peep shows of the '60s) known to survive, A FREE RIDE a/k/a A GRASS SANDWICH (ca. 1915), still contains seriously steamy threesome action between two commendably eager females and one ready, willing and very able male.

The subsequent ON THE BEACH (a/k/a THE GOAT !) adds a remarkably thorough comedic plot to the pornographic proceedings. Excerpts from an explicit cartoon named BURIED TREASURE (possibly the work of the Fleischer brothers...) show a little guy getting into all sorts of increasingly surreal mischief courtesy of his unfeasibly large member.

You can file KEYHOLE PORTRAITS and snippets of '50s stripper reels under F for Filler. Far more interesting is the much discussed Candy Barr movie, SMART ALECK, which sees the stripper, who gained notoriety as the girlfriend of shady nightclub owner Jack Ruby (i.e. the man who shot Lee Harvey Oswald who allegedly shot...well, you know that !), violently refusing to go down on her mate who's chomping at the bit. So a less appealing lady is drafted in to perform just that task with such vigor as to practically mesmerize - and indeed overshadow somewhat - this loop's central starlet.

The movie's true highlight is the legendary NUN'S STORY about a stunning Sister who sheds her habit to make genuinely passionate love with her Elvis-pompadoured boyfriend before re-donning the cloth at scene's end.

Now is as good a time as any to shed a little light - if any were needed - on the man responsible for this collection, the late great Alex DeRenzy. Prior to his emergence as one of the greatest erotic filmmakers of all time with classics like FEMMES DE SADE, BABY FACE and PRETTY PEACHES, his main claim to industry fame was as the proprietor of the Screening Room, one of San Francisco's pioneering (pre-Pussycat) porno palaces.

The latter part of HISTORY kind of belies its title by providing what was perceived at the time as mere publicity for its director's business and place thereof. Of course, nearly 4 decades later, it's easy to state that time has been kind to this particular section.

A massage parlor sequence, pre-figuring DeRenzy's early classic FANTASY GIRLS, has cute acting, copious nudity but no visible penetration as an inexperienced masseuse tries to fend off the amorous advances of her horny client. Beautiful Bonnie Holiday, a too frequently overlooked actress who was instrumental in bringing her goddess girlfriend Annette Haven into the industry, languidly responds to an unseen interviewer as she teasingly strips and pleasures herself in a wonderfully erotic segment.

The last scene has a young couple responding to a modeling ad and turning up at, you guessed it, the Screening Room for an artistically shot audition that already showcases embryonic versions of the type of visual effects DeRenzy was to refine in his later work.

All in all, an important excursion into porno's past and an eloquent charting of the genre's evolution (or lack thereof...) in terms of style and content. Serious students of sex cinema will probably benefit most from this hardcore history lesson though even the occasional porn hound who couldn't care less should find portions of it to his liking.
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Dubious viewing, but kind of interesting too
lazarillo10 August 2008
I would recommend this compilation film to anyone interested in the history of pornography in America, but I would NOT recommend to anyone looking to see a porn film for the purposes of getting turned on. This is mostly a collection of "stag loops" going all the way back to the silent era and including the oddly-titled "Grass Sandwich", which is believed to be the oldest hardcore porn loop still in existence.

The most notorious of these loops though is the one from the 1950's titled (again, for some unclear reason) "The Smart Aleck", which features legendary Texas stripper "Candy Barr". Barr later claimed this was shot when, as a naive 17 year old, she was lured to a motel room and raped at gunpoint. Actually though, Barr neither looks anywhere close to seventeen here, nor like she was being raped. She does clearly refuse to perform oral sex on her partner (something rather unusual in porno as far as I know), but in the next scene she is shown calling a "friend" on the phone, who shows up and does the dirty deed. All this suggests to me, that Barr's was doing "a Linda Lovelace" (i.e. a lying to cover up something she was ashamed of), at least to some extent. Still, who knows? It's definitely strange in any case.

The film comes up to the present day (as of 1970) and some of the director's own work. These scenes are both unappetizing and excruciatingly boring. The hairiest moment (in more ways than one) involves a skanky 70's-era "actress" pleasuring herself in a scene that seemingly goes on forever. (Thank god for the soft focus or you might actually be able to see the crabs). All in all, this is rather dubious viewing. If you're looking for eroticism, you're better off going with one of those cable specials hosted by recent porn sensation Katie Morgan (as kind of a naked professor),which show a lot of the same basic footage (minus the Barr loop), but leave out the skankier "modern" stuff. Still as a purely historical curiosity this is kind of interesting. (This film itself was one of the first "mainstream" porn films back when it was first released).
7 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed