Le crâneur (1955) Poster

(1955)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Parisian noir directed by Kirsanoff worth watching
markwood27211 June 2015
Warning: Spoilers
Saw this via YouTube 6/10/15. A predictable storyline (chumpish good guy falls for the wrong woman who involves him in illicit "jobs", then the guy falls in love with a purer sort of female, decides to make a break...etc.) Raymond Pellegrin's Philippe resembles Mickey Rooney's Eddie Shannon in "Drive a Crooked Road" (1954), but somehow Pellegrin fails to achieve a similarly strong emotional connection. The Dora Doll/Marina Vlady – good-vs. evil contrast comes off a bit better, with chanteuse Vlady believable as initially unapproachable. Director Kirsanoff years earlier proved himself one of the best cut men in the business with "Menilmontant" (1926), and unsurprisingly the recombinant narrative technique of meshing flashbacks works well -- so well that near the end, with its "this is where we came in" closing of the loop, "Le Craneur" anticipates "Pulp Fiction"'s Klein bottle by nearly four decades.

The version I saw was muddy and blurry, resulting in the loss of much of the impact expected from Roger Fellous' realistic nighttime Parisian street photography. The dialogue track was about as fogged, which combined with the lack of subtitles and my limited French made some patches hard to follow.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Nylon stockings,you bet!
dbdumonteil20 May 2015
Dimitri Kirsanoff reportedly made good silent movies ;there is also a worthwhile talkie, "rapt" (1934).

"Le Crâneur" (="the show-off":as nobody's bragging is the movie,the title is a misnomer).

Raymond Pellegrin was a very good actor ,who made indifferent films Noirs by the dozen and found a good part as a schoolteacher in the first version of "Manon Des Sources" by Pagnol.

He portrays a stuntman (the actor he stands for is a real braggart on his part:" yes,he said to his female fans,I'm sporty;that's why I'm not doubled in my movies) ,torn between two women:a good one (Marina Vlady) ,who sings in a nightclub and a bitch (Dora Doll), a choreographic artist ("topless dancer" says the cop).The bad woman gets her new lover involved in her dirty job with drug traffickers. (she tells him he transports nylon stockings !)

In this hackneyed story ,the most salutary quality is a certain sense of humor ;"it could not be the English guy who committed the crime!he would have strangled her!" .The Chanteuse to her sister who blames the place where she works: " There are decent people there;sister: " decent people for sure ,selling morphine !"

The film is a long flashback,as it is often the case in this kind of thriller ;the suspense is not really sustained and the ending totally bland.

Marina Vlady(17) has rarely been as good-looking as in this movie ;she claims that she writes her own songs :maybe it fooled some viewers at the time; but since, Brassens ' s "Chanson Pour L'Auvergnat" has become a timeless classic of the Chanson Française and her words are now a little ridiculous.

NB: Marina Vlady's real life sister,Hélène Vallier,plays the part of her straight sibling.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed