Asylum (I) (1997) User Reviews

Schlock Treatment

[wes-connors · 4/10 · 9 May 2010]

Slightly maladjusted, due to a troubled childhood, private investigator Robert Patrick (as Nicholas "Nick" Tordone) is suspicious when his psychiatrist, Peter Brown (as Frank Meyers), is reported to have hanged himself. Mr. Patrick thinks his shrink, who happened to have been a good friend of his suicidal father, was murdered. So, Patrick goes undercover at the "Fallbrook" insane asylum where Brown worked. There, he meets mental Malcolm McDowell (as Sullivan Rane aka "Doc"), crazy costumed Jason Schombing (as Tommy aka "Captain Destructo"), and Deborah Worthing (as Amanda aka "Mary Pickford").

Patrick (as "Magnum") teams up with Mr. Schombing to solve the mystery. Institution head Henry Gibson (as Edward Bellichek) and patient doctor Sarah Douglas (as Emily Hill) are among those considered to be sane. James Seale's "Asylum" seems curiously unattended - patients are free to wander around without much supervision. Additionally, the building has been equipped with loose, human-sized vents for easy escape, spying, or travel - even in a solitary confinement room. This is all more laughable than suspenseful, but the scene where Patrick goes to the edge of the roof is nicely done. Passable on late night TV.

**** Asylum (5/6/97) James Seale ~ Robert Patrick, Malcolm McDowell, Jason Schombing, Henry Gibson

A great way to pass some time

[eric20other2002 · 5/10 · 1 December 2012]

Now I just got done watching this off of Netflix and felt the need to say a few words on it. It isn't a bad film, but it isn't a film I'd say you have to go out and buy. If I had bought this on DVD and spent more than 5 dollars on it I would have been a bit disappointed in myself, but its not a bad film to watch if you happen to go passed it or just on something like Netflix. Robert Patrick, plays a detective, good at going undercover and uncovering hidden truths, after the death of a friend at a mental institution, he uses his deep rooted suicidal tenancy to commit himself in hopes of finding out who killed his friend. Robert plays the role well, he is certainly the highlight of the film and the reason I felt invested in the film. The film itself plays with your head a bit, it can be slow moving at times and really picks up when the 3rd act begins. There is another patient in the film, a woman, who seems to be abused by hospital staff. that Robert's character seems to really wanna protect more than anyone else. The only other thing I can really comment on this film is that it has some star power. Besides Robert Patrick, who is best known for T2: Judgment Day and Die Hard 2: Die Harder, we also have Sarah Douglas, who is best known for Superman, Superman II(both cuts)and Conan the Destroyer and Malcolm McDowell, who is known for Clockwork Orange and more recently Rob Zombie's Halloween and Halloween II.

Sort of Falls Short

[gavin6942 · 5/10 · 5 November 2015]

A private investigator (Robert Patrick), mentally disturbed by his father's suicide, goes undercover in a mental institution to discover the murderer of a friend who was a doctor at the clinic.

This film deserves some credit for the attempt at a clever idea, and for bringing together two great genre actors in one film -- Robert Patrick and Malcolm McDowell. Have they been in any other film together? I do not know. And here they were, in one that probably had no budget, with a writer-director who has not gone on to distinguish himself.

Sadly, it does seem to be a bit convoluted. Any time you set something in an asylum, and you have a protagonist of questionable reliability... you get some goofy outcomes. You can be straightforward, or full on David Lynch. This seems to try to work between those poles, which is difficult and not fully successful.

An unintentional laugh-fest...

[metalvet · 2 October 2002]

If you're the kind that likes watching bad movies (for instance, if you enjoyed "The Postman" in only the most ironic sense), this is a keeper. A ridiculous script is only the start, and you also get Robert Patrick staying in the laxest insane asylum in the world (undercover in the guise of a patient, he seemingly has no problems at all finding access to the staff's private fax machines, computers, satellite dishes, etc.), develops a drippy camraderie with a fellow inmate that leads to some of the more strained, "heartfelt" moments of the film, and a ridiculous character by Acting's own Prince of Ever-Diminishing Returns, Malcolm McDowell. Reviewing this film makes me feel like I'm admonishing the dog for peeing on the rug. "For shame! Bad, bad, bad..."

WTH Did I Try To Watch?

[Rainey-Dawn · 1/10 · 13 September 2017]

This is bad. Really, really bad. Not the so bad, it's good - it's more of so bad I'd rather pluck out my own eyes than finish watching this type of bad - just plain awful.

How on earth did they get Malcom McDowell to do this one? He's way too good of an actor for a crappy role and film like this!!

I tried to watch - really I did. I had to hit the fast-forward button not to long after the film started. I'm sorry but I can't watch this. This one is too awful for me to view... I'm gonna find another "B" horror to watch... I hope to get at least a few giggles and eye rolls from it.

1/10

Miserable piece of Celluloid (Spoiler ahead!)

[ChrisHawk78 · 2/10 · 30 May 2001]

There is a very interesting plot and one or two reasonably good actors but the script is average and most of the performances are not very convincing. The Idea of something fishy going on in a mental home has been there since the invention of mental homes and should by now have reached a higher level. The shockers in this movie are plump and the pace is really slow. And who has not guessed from the very first that the guy in the surgical clothes was Rane? And who was silly enough to believe that Rane was the bad guy? Who would have considered the director of the mental home (the poor rotter in the wheelchair) to be good and sane? It is altogether rather obvious. I really do not know what kept me watching this movie. Perhaps it was just the hay-fever that prevented me from sleep.

By The Book

[refinedsugar · 5/10 · 18 May 2023]

'Asylum' didn't have a hard time selling me on giving it a go. A big Robert Patrick fan after T2, I'd sit thru any of his DTV titles available. Having played 'Wing Commander III: Heart of the Tiger' at the time, I also enjoyed that Malcolm McDowell was involved.

A private detective (Patrick) with his own mental baggage enters an insane asylum / mental hospital undercover in the hopes of getting to the bottom of who murdered his doctor friend. Of course it was labeled a suicide, but he believes differently. Amongst the patients is the cooky Doc Rane (McDowell).

Things proceed pretty much as you expect dealing with mental crazy business and an obvious red herring. The air of believability isn't high, but there is adequate atmosphere. If your a fan of either actor it's an okay watch. Debra Wilson (of MadTV) makes a brief appearance as well.

Entertaining Thriller

[claudio_carvalho · 6/10 · 7 January 2023]

The private investigator Nicholas "Nick" Tordone (Robert Patrick) is a man with a childhood problem since he saw his father committing suicide. His friend Dr. Frank Meyers (Peter Brown) works in the Fallbrook mental institution and was a great friend of his father. He helps Nick since he lost his father. When Dr. Meyers is found dead in the clinic after committing suicide, Nick does not believe and decides to investigate his death. He goes to Fallbrook as if he has amnesia and is interned in the clinic. Soon he finds that four patients are missing and his further investigation shows that all of them were suicidal inmates. He also discovers that the dangerous criminal Dr. Sullivan Rane (Malcolm McDowell) is hidden in the clinic. What is happening in Fallbrook?

"Asylum (1997)" is an entertaining low-budget thriller by James Seale. The plot is not original but well written, with funny moments and good performances. My vote is six.

Title (Brazil): "O Limite da Loucura" ("The Limit of the Madness")

Patients go missing

[nogodnomasters · 5/10 · 23 November 2018]

Nicholas Tordone (Robert Patrick) is an investigator with daddy suicide issues. He is seeing a psychologist Dr. Frank Meyers (Peter Brown). Dr, Meyers also works at the local asylum. When he commits suicide, Nick suspects foul play and goes undercover as a patient. Clues point to "The Surgeon" (Malcolm McDowell) as he snoops around the most unsecured loosely run asylum.

The film was a mystery with inadequate clues. The main character was dull, while the supporting cast was not.

Guide: F-word. No sex or nudity. Implied attempted rape.

Disappointingly low budget asylum thriller

[Leofwine_draca · 4/10 · 29 September 2017]

ASYLUM is a disappointingly low budget thriller set within the confines of a mental asylum, perhaps wanting to bask in some of the reflected former glory of the likes of ONE FLEW OVER THE CUCKOO'S NEST. Unfortunately, many of the asylum films made in the last two decades - I'm thinking of the likes of GOTHIKA - have been disappointments and this one's no different. The murder mystery storyline is overly familiar and the direction insipid, leaving the viewers to check their watches on a regular basis.

Robert Patrick is the grizzled hero of the piece, revealing how far he had fallen since his breathtaking role in blockbuster TERMINATOR 2 just six years previously. He plays a cop who goes undercover as an asylum inmate to solve a murder. The script is pretty bad, it has to be said, and the stylistics have dated in that '90s way. It's only really worth watching for the various supporting roles for actors including Sarah Douglas (CONAN THE DESTROYER), the reliably intense Malcolm McDowell, and the great Henry Gibson.

Dark Thriller Keeps You Guessing

[condor-7 · 10/10 · 5 October 1999]

Cool movie. Robert Patrick is awesome as a suicidal detective who must find his shrink's murderer by going undercover in a psych hospital. Performances were above average for this kind of B-thriller and there were some genuinely creepy moments -- although it could have used a few more. Much more of a drama than a horror film, but a lot better than the usual straight-to-video fare. *** out of ****

Smart, Stylish Mystery --

[Ape2512 · 8/10 · 12 June 2003]

Not the first thriller to take place in a mental institution, but one of the better. Leading man Patrick does a nice job as an unstable P.I. who goes undercover to find the killer of his shrink. Nice mix of suspense and humor - might have been better without all the laughs.

Malcolm McDowell is fun to watch as a murderous patient named Rane. Is he the killer or does he hold the secret to the mystery?? Good acting outshines the slick camerawork. Nice surprise thriller.