Mother (1991) Poster

(1991)

User Reviews

Review this title
16 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
The Armenian Tree: roots in Christianity, trunk of bloodshed and branches flowering under the sun of Exile...
ElMaruecan8212 June 2017
Warning: Spoilers
"The more specific a film is, the more universal, because the more it understands individual characters, the more it applies to everyone".

I already quoted Ebert in my review of "Lion" and despite my dislike for repetition, I don't think a movie better illustrates that statement than Henri Verneuil's "Mayrig", the story of Armenian refugees, who escaped the genocide to live under the protective sun of Marseilles. The film is impregnated by Armenian culture and that indelible red stain still denied by the Turks, but we share the joys and tears of the Zakarians, regardless of any cultural belonging. Indeed, the title "Mayrig", meaning "Mother" couldn't have been more universal.

It is less about the mother than the idea of a mother, the sacred bond with anything defining who you are, where you come from, like a land, like family. The narrator (voiced by Richard Berry) often mentions his trinity of mothers: Aunt Gayane (Nathalie Roussel) is young, with a beauty that could have taken her places but she settled down with the family and Aunt Anna (Isabelle Sadoyan) looks so old and plump she could have pass as a grandmother.

The rest of the family portrait) includes the father, Hagop, played by the late Omar Sharif, a rock of a man with the sweetest heart, and Claudia Cardinale is the titular "Mayrig" whose smile and goodness never cease to irradiate the screen. And all these 'little' people of gigantic 'hearts' gravitate around the last of the clan and the hope of the family: little Azad. But you can't understand the education of Azad without previous insights about the Armenian past.

"Mayrig" opens with the voice of Verneuil reminding his audience that the Armenians are the first Christian nation, and maybe like a symbolical embodiment to Jesus' martyrdom, they underwent countless aggression through history, yet that never defeated their spirit. The introduction is followed by the murder of infamous Taalat Pacha, the "Turkish Hitler" as often called, the following trial of Soghorian, his 'murderer', enlightens the international community about the atrocious crimes ordered by Ottoman rulers.

The introduction was necessary not just as a historical reminder but so we can see the Zakarian's less as immigrants than survivors, the last branch of a decimated family. A friend, Apkar (Jacky Nercessian) relates his experience in the genocide and how he stayed alive not because of survival instinct but for transmission. Christianity from the dawn, genocide and the exile to Europe (some would go as far as Venezuela), history marked the identity of Armenians. Yet their spirit is never self-centered.

There's a scene where Hagop tells Apkar, that there's no room for nostalgia, it's a sickness one must get rid of, they must honor their exile and since France showed enough heart to take them under her arm, they'll give France their son. It's not just about "remember who you are" but "where you are", and that today, most Armenians are totally assimilated to the French nation, says a lot about their spirit. The film defies all the usual archetypes by showing people who didn't even try to fit but to fit better.

For instance, the Zakarians don't like the idea of public school, if it was so good, why would people pay for other schools, are state schools about charity? They send Azad to a religious school, even if that means nighttime working for everybody, Hagop in the factory, the trinity of mother spending sleepless nights sewing shirts and buttonholes. The hardworking mentality also affects little Azad who sees from the start that he's dressed too well not to fool the kids at school about his real status, and the grimace when the teacher calls his name or the contempt from the catechism teacher achieves to make an outcast of him.

He couldn't care less. The story of the genocide he eavesdropped on convinced him that the point isn't to please his friends but his parents. And when they asked them how his day at school was, he doesn't lie for the good marks but he does for his friends, if it can make his father go happily at work, it's worth a wise lie.

In a similar scene, after sneaking into a theater to see "Queen Christina" with Garbo, he comes in the house shouting that he wants to be a movie star. Seeing the devastation on their faces, he pretends it's a joke and after a quick glance at a newspaper, says he wants to be a naval engineer, the face of his father immediately illuminates, he listens to the world like a symphony. The film always finds sadness in humor and reciprocally.

In another scene where Azad is stricken by pleurisy, when asked to cough, to say 33 or to breathe loudly, his "three mothers" imitate him as if they were as sick as he was. And to check how tolerable the hot poultices are, poor Aunt Gayane places them on her cheek and let a crisped smile reassure Azad. They are, sad, happy and even sick together. As if the family was a microcosm of people who always stayed united through history.

The film spans two decades of the life of the Zakarians, taking a few artistic licenses with the chronology: Azad is 7 in the early 20's but is 20 at the beginning of the war. But I didn't mind because the whole film is told like a book, even the parents express themselves in a poetic eloquence that is not realistic, but it works as an additional support to the film's imagery which is rich and eloquent enough.

When the film closes with that magnificent waltz between a mother and her son and the beautiful score of Jean-Claude Petit, you understand more about this culture, that provided names that go from Aznavour to Kazan and of course, Achod Malakian aka Henri Verneuil.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A very realistic picture on the life of Armenians after the genocide
vee-vee1 November 2009
I am Armenian. Well… my father is Armenian and he was born and raised in France. He then decided to move to Quebec (Canada) to study but ended up staying here and bringing his parents. My mom is French-Canadian. I went to Armenian school and so I speak, write and read it. My grand-mother was one of the survivors of the genocide. She passed away a few months ago at the age of 98.

What does this have to do with the movie you ask? Everything. It has everything to do.

This movie made a lot of sense to me. Yes, the parts about the genocide were heartbreaking but I'm also speaking about the alienation the family feels after moving to France and how they try to adjust their values with the ones from this country they now live in.

Being Armenian and French-Canadian has caused me many headaches. And though today I am very proud of both cultures, the major differences between them sometimes still leaves me in a place of no man's land.

And the love we feel between the family members in the movie is VERY realistic.

After the genocide, it is love that saved the survivors from a life full of resentment. Sticking together and loving each other with all of their hearts and souls was the only way to move on.

Not forget. We can never forget.

But in order to put those dark days behind us and be happy again, we needed this love.

The way the parents genuinely sacrifice themselves for the happiness of their son is something I am very familiar with. My father did the SAME thing for me and for my brother. Armenian parents are like that.

But with this great generosity and unconditional love comes great expectations.

Of how we should live our lives. About what we need in order to be truly happy. And they care SO much. They literally live and breathe through us in a way. If we succeed, they succeed. If we are happy, they are happy. If we are sick, they are sick.

I'm not saying that if we fail, they fail. They are very supportive and as long as you do your best, they are always proud of you. And trust me when I say that we love our parents with all our hearts and are grateful for all that they did and all that they still do.

I am so proud to be Armenian. I am so proud of the strength of my people who not only lost everything and had to build from scratch but did it in the best possible way to give the children of tomorrow the chance to hope for something better.

But being Armenian gives you a responsibility. In memory of those who died but mostly, of those that survived and made it possible for YOU to be alive today. We have a responsibility to never give up on ourselves and on those who brought us into this world. And this feel of responsibility will be passed on to our children and so on. And as a child of the third generation, I find it sometimes hard to know what part of me wants what it wants because I really want it or because I know that this is what my family wants for me.

It's not a bad thing... but it's a thing and at the age of 26, I'm not done trying to figure it out.

So I guess this movie helped me in a way... It helped me understand myself. Understand where I come from. And where I'm going...
44 out of 48 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A tribute to the Armenian people, but also to all those who had to live their lives in exile
nchapron11 January 2002
This is a very moving film about the big tragedy of the Armenian people who were slaughtered in millions by the turks in 1915, or rather about the ones who escaped and who after seeing their whole families murdered, had to make a life in a foreign country, while trying to deal with the past, or at least not to let the past destroy them. Superb acting from Claudia Cardinale, Omar Shariff, Isabelle Sadoyan and Nathalie Roussel. It goes in the line with films like "La Gloire de mon pere" and " le chateau de ma mere". Giving a very good description of what was life was in the South of France at the beginning of the centuries, and what were the people expectations (at least, that is how I feel it). If you are expecting violence and gore, that is not what you will get here. Also, let us not forget that the "Armenian Genocide" has never been acknowledged by the Turkish Government, and was only recognised last year by the French one.
43 out of 51 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Film describing life of the Armenians rescued from genocide
Axel Emesiz13 May 2001
You may watch this film and not pay so much attention on it. But being Armenian, you would understand the whole meaning which the author wanted to explain. If you are not Armenian, you would never understand the tragedy of our people.As in the beginning of our century about 1,5 million people were killed and this is a film which describes the life of a simple Armenian family which could rescue. They rescued and started to live an absolutely different life in a foreign country among foreign people. Watching this film, the parts describing the genocide my eyes get wet,as I know that all this horror really took place.I read a lot about it. Children,pregnant women,the old were cut with jataghans. the turkish soldiers and kurdist bandits cut noses,ears,lips of the priests,people from big villages were killed in a day.And so on, and so on. Forgive them,God.Now we are to live with this tragedy in our hearts.Our grandfathers were killed.And till now the Turkish dare to say that there was no genocide and even the Armenians made a genocide,meanwhile many countries in the world realizing everything proved this fact in their parlaments. "Mayrig" is a tragic film making each Armenian person think about his life.I feel that this film gave me a lot.Thanks to the makers of "Mayrig".
39 out of 47 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
One of the best movies I have ever seen.
urartu997 November 2007
This movie is about an Armenian family who was forced to leave his homeland in order to escape certain death from Turkish army during Armenian Genocide in Ottoman Empire. This movie is a masterpiece not only because it is based on real happenings and that with the story of one family it represents the story of survival of the whole nation but also because it shows, in a very sensitive way, the life of one man from his difficult but happy childhood until the very heights of his successful career. It demonstrates that the care and unity within family are the cornerstones of the happiness, even when you pass through the hardest times. It is about the sacrificial care and boundless love of every Father and every Mother for their child. And nothing is more important for a person in his life than to make his parents proud and happy.
24 out of 29 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
A touching movie about an Armenian family during and after the genocide of 1915
moviebuff12078 September 2001
Turks say it never happened , they even imply that the Armenians are the ones who committed that atrocity against the turkish , The truth is until now denied but many people recognize it so do many countries .

It's a story about a boy and his family , how his surroundings were able to remain , in a foreign country among foreign people how they managed to make a place for themselves and were able to survive . It is a human story that shows a glimpse of the horrifying things that happened , but mostly it is a story about survival , re_birth , trying to make a new life , and carrying on with a legacy : the fact of being Armenian .
26 out of 32 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The best film ever!!!
sasryan-974501 November 2020
A film which shows the whole horibility of genocide (without any big bloody scenes of that) and how a nation have overcome that with it's generations.It's a film about true Armenian family values,about hope and love,about willingness to live and to create!!!
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
The bedt in the world movie
vaheazizyan-323902 November 2020
Incredibly emotional film, one of the best movies in the history
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Deeply touched while watching this piece of art. Highly recommended to watch
harutyunyanjuliettalaw2 November 2020
Not only this movie is based on a real story, it also displays breathtaking scenes of bravery, drama, melodrama. It is hard to stay an indifferent towards human tragedies after watching this. This movie is also a story of one family-that bears wisdom of its ancestors to start a fresh new life in France. Just watch and you will not regret.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Escaping genoside
shushangevorgyan-898463 November 2020
A very impressive film about Armenian family escaping Armenian genoside in 1915
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Great Movie
inulya-812323 November 2020
Great Movie, great actors, incredible plot. Have watched it thousands of time and every time I open something new for me. Highly recommend to watch
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Extraordinaire
karouimail10 April 2019
Un film tout simplement extraordinaire, c'est très bien fait
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Can fully relate to the heroes and their story.
dianadarbinian14 May 2021
As if I am watching the story of my very own family. Very touching.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Great film
liliku-319475 November 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Very emotional true story, taken from the life! Recommended to watch!
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Just a Single Word: "MASTERPIECE"!!!
quasitheone12 December 2001
A piece of art from the talented director Henry Vernoil.A great distortion of truth.A perfect self-sided view to such an important event.The film totally smells "hate&revenge".The trick that telling the story as the real memories of his own parents is so wise.A "Must See" film for Armenians, but only for Armenians!
14 out of 52 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Awesome movie
Awesome movie, tribute to all armenians world wide.

Shows the armenians suffer and tragedy during turkish ottoman brutal empire at 1915 when they killed 1.5 million civillians .

Armenian genocide april 24 1915.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed