Shadow of Angels (1976) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
Angels in the Shadow
hasosch2 February 2009
Warning: Spoilers
"Schatten der Engel" or "Shadow of Angels" (1976) is based on the theater play "Der Müll, die Stadt und der Tod"/"The Garbage, the City, and the Death" (1975) by Rainer Werner Fassbinder which himself had based his play on the novel "Die Erde ist unbewohnbar wie der Mond"/"The Earth is Inhabitable like the Moon" (1973) by Gerhard Zwerenz. Since Fassbinder, a theater director at that time besides making up to ten movies per year for cinema and television, was very much involved in the anti-fascist aggressions against him, he let a friend of his, the late Swiss film and opera director Daniel Schmid, direct this movie. However, Fassbinder took over the male main role at the side of his former wife, Ingrid Caven, who played Lily Brest (anticipating, without doubt, the character of Querelle de Brest in Fassbinder's last movie, Querelle, 1982).

For connoisseurs of Fassbinder's film-universe, you will find in the "Shadow of Angels" an ingenious performance by Adrian Hoven (1922-1981) as the transvestite father of Lily Brest and an ex-Nazi. Hoven actually plays the Burg-Theater actress Annemarie Düringer who plays his wife, in the background. His terrific play has the more to be mentioned since Hoven, although present in practically all Fassbinder movies, had hardly ever gotten a big role after his great time in the Austrian "heimatfilms" (sentimental films) of the 50ies and 6oies was over.

Thus, it is really hard to believe that this movie, which had been in competition for the Golden Palm at Cannes in 1976, and which had been made with such a crew of prominent people, has never been released on international DVD. However, from the 66 movies, counted by Fassbinder friend and professor of film science Christian Braad Thomsen, that Fassbinder had made in his short life, about a quarter is still not released on DVD, a few of them have even never been released at all. Amongst them are such masterpieces like "Game Runway", "World on Wire", "LIke a Bird on a Wire", "Women in New York", "Theater in Trance", etc.
11 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
More obscene than interesting Warning: Spoilers
"Schatten der Engel" or "Shadow of Angels" is a West German / Swiss co-production from 1976, so this movie has its 40th anniversary this year. The writer and director is the late Swiss filmmaker Daniel Schmid and he got help with the script from a certain Rainer Werner Fassbinder here. The latter also played a crucial role in terms of acting when it comes to this film. It is one of the fairly rare occasions when Fassbinder is not directing but just playing, and writing of course. His impact on the movie is easy to see as the dialogues are exactly in a way that you would expect them in a Fassbinder film. They are filled with obscenities and vulgar language, but there is also quite some depth in here when it comes to the characters and their emotions, what they feel and how they interact with each other. It may see completely void of respect at times, but the strong language also means strong emotion in a way. The movie runs for 100 minutes and includes a handful of actors that regularly starred next to Fassbinder, such as Caven, Lommel, Hoven and Hermann. I personally cannot say, however, that I really cared a whole lot about any of their performance or about the plot and story in general, maybe because this film was really more a collection of scenes and impressions than really one with a well-refined story and a memorable plot, or a plot at all for that matter. It's okay for Fassbinder completionists and certainly not a failure, but I myself have zero interest in watching it ever again. That's why I give it a thumbs-down. Not recommended.
2 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed