Shatter (1974) Poster

(1974)

User Reviews

Review this title
26 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Monte Hellman's "Lost" Flick.
ndrejaj19693 March 2002
Long unavailable on home vid, this was just one of the many projects that cult maestro Monte Hellman ghost-directed. So when the good folks at Roan decided to release this on LD, I jumped at the chance to get a copy. At forty bucks, it was worth it. But I had to order off the Dollar Menu for the rest of the week.

It was a long-held belief that Hellman only directed a small portion of the film before being sacked and replaced by producer Michael Carreras. But in the running commentary, Hellman, upon seeing the movie for the very first time, was surprised to see that at least 80% of the final cut is his.

Though no "Background to Danger," this is a very passable B-adventure, with Whitman a fine hero/foil. Whitman's Shatter is another in the long line of Hellman loner-man-on-the-outside-looking-in protagonists. The film also bears striking similarities with the long forgotten "Karate-the Hand of Death" (1961)about an American Karate expert returning to Japan after the war and runs afoul of some mob types. "Shatter" is a decent way to spend an hour and a half on a rainy afternoon, and a find for Monte Hellman completeists.
15 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
SHATTER (Michael Carreras and, uncredited, Monte Hellman, 1975) **
Bunuel197623 July 2011
Warning: Spoilers
In my review of Joseph Losey's THESE ARE THE DAMNED (1963), I had written that Hammer Films' way out of their conventional rut (particularly during the early 1970s) was by recruiting talented film-makers who operated not so much within the mainstream but rather around its edges. Expatriate American Losey was thus an ideal choice to kick-start this intriguing venture (having conveniently relocated to the U.K.) but, while his first effort for the company – the excellent short thriller MAN ON THE BEACH (1956) – adhered reasonably close to the Hammer standard (they were still to gain a reputation for garishly-colored horrors and complexly-plotted chillers), the second (the above-mentioned title) was easily their hardest-to-categorize and most pretentious – if undeniably brilliant – outing...which, I guess, put paid to the notion of their continuing this 'shaky' practice!

Still, out of the blue (and when they were probably at their lowest ebb, since the company would basically fold in a couple of years' time!), they made another attempt in this direction by persuading cult American film-maker Monte Hellman to make an action thriller – as part of a current deal with famed Hong Kong producers The Shaw Bros. – for them. Apparently, he had recently undergone an extensive location tour of the Orient for a project that had subsequently fallen through – indeed, he claims he was only approached by Hammer in view of his familiarity with the place (which obviously saved them the time and money another director would have spent there in pre-production)! However, this time around, the subject matter was not congenial – especially since the company were contract-bound to incorporate martial arts sequences by a Bruce Lee wannabe – and, frankly, it all looked pretty desperate from the outset (crossing POINT BLANK {1967} with ENTER THE DRAGON {1973})! To make matters worse, the cost-conscious Shaw Bros. liked to shoot their pictures back-to-back utilizing the same crew so that, by the time they came to the SHATTER lot, they would be all but exhausted! – similarly, star Stuart Whitman (past his prime and haggard-looking) would have started boozing by then and prove just as unfocused on his work! Faced by all this, Hellman unsurprisingly fell behind schedule and, yet, Hammer chief Michael Carreras took it out on him and, three weeks into the shooting, had the director fired, eventually taking over control himself (as he had done on BLOOD FROM THE MUMMY'S TOMB {1971} following original helmer Seth Holt's death) and even got sole credit…but it reportedly took him 6 months to finish the picture considering that, by all accounts, some two-thirds of it were already pretty much in the can (actually, Hellman had subsequently refused to edit his footage, so Carreras must not have had an easy time getting the whole to make sense and, frankly, work)!

Anyway, Whitman is a hit-man (elaborately utilizing a gun hidden inside a camera for the job) duped into working for the mob to eliminate an African dictator. When he turns up to get paid, the hero is not only given the cold shoulder (by his nefarious contact Anton Diffring) but himself becomes the target of assassination thereafter (these include taking a pot-shot with a bazooka at what is thought to be his hotel room)! Complicating matters further is the vague presence of a sinister/eccentric secret-service official (Hammer stalwart Peter Cushing in his inauspicious last theatrical appearance for the company, though his own personal contribution is dignified as ever). Somehow, Shatter (presumably the protagonist's code-name: his rough manners rendered more prominent by the American retitling CALL HIM MR. SHATTER – complete with a title song better suited to some "Blaxploitation" offering!) befriends a couple of local siblings: he being the Kung-Fu master and she obviously falling for the American tough guy. For no obvious reason, they join him in his crusade to get even with the mob and, even more pointlessly, the Oriental is involved (and naturally emerges victorious) in a martial-arts competition; in the end, the girl dies stopping a bullet meant for Whitman and Cushing (after having had his men beat up Shatter, a 'compliment' our hero later returns!) emerges from the shadows to reveal himself a benign figure after all – with Diffring and the dictator's own brother being fingered as the real villains (who expire in a hilarious joint fall, after being riddled by bullets, through the large glass-pane of the former's office)!

Incidentally, the edition of the film I watched includes a couple of censored violent moments (the inserts immediately recognizable from the sudden drop in picture quality) missing from the R1 Anchor Bay DVD. The accompanying Audio Commentary is, however, available and Hellman was certainly a sport in opting to take part: he dutifully points out the scenes he did or did not shoot but readily takes the blame for the film's ultimate lameness (amazingly, it came in-between two of his best-regarded American works i.e. TWO-LANE BLACKTOP {1971} and COCKFIGHTER {1974}, whose own viewing is upcoming in my ongoing Hellman retrospective)! The track proves just as laid-back as the movie itself (incorporating the occasional interjections from a separately-recorded Whitman who seems to be quite fond of it and Hellman, despite apparently bearing a grudge against The Shaw Bros., taking as he does every opportunity to denigrate them!) with moderator Norman Hill (who presumes this may well have been Whitman's last gasp as a leading man, but he was actually still good for another 10 years or so – including the somewhat similar Italian poliziottesco SHADOWS IN AN EMPTY ROOM aka BLAZING MAGNUM {1976}) querying the director about his other work and influences (singling out the outsider protagonists in the films of both John Huston and Carol Reed), and even about his own opinion on Hammer's more typical output (which he tackles in an off-handed, albeit diplomatic, fashion).
4 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Not bad of its type.
Hey_Sweden12 March 2023
Collaborating for the second and final time, Hammer Studios and Shaw Brothers Studios again tap into the martial arts market for this watchable crime fiction that has the benefit of being filmed entirely in Hong Kong. Stuart Whitman ("The Mark") stars as the title character, a hitman who completes a job in Africa, assassinating a dictator. Then he goes to HK to collect payment from a weaselly banker named Hans Leber (Anton Diffring, "Circus of Horrors"), and of course the guy reneges on the deal. Shatter must take it on the lam, being unable to trust most people. However, he does receive crucial assistance from Kung Fu expert Tai Pah (Lung Ti) and masseuse Mai-Mee (Lily Li).

The story goes that this was a very troubled production, with Hammer producer and sometime director Michael Carreras ("The Lost Continent") stepping in to replace original director Monte Hellman, the American cult-favorite filmmaker who made such classics as "Two-Lane Blacktop" and "Cockfighter". This, after Hellman had already shot *at least* half of the picture. Given its problems, it's fortunate that the finished product manages to tell a reasonably coherent story, although it's required of special guest star Peter Cushing (wonderful as always) to utter quite a bit of exposition. Even then, Shatter doesn't know the whole story until the movie is almost over.

The action scenes are very well done, in any event, with Lung Ti showing off great athleticism and having a relaxed presence on screen. Whitman is fine as usual, Li is simply adorable, the great German actor Diffring is appropriately slimy, and Cushing remains a delight. Several Shaw Brothers players, Li and Lung Ti among them, have roles large and small. The movie is full of HK sights and sounds, possessing a very exotic appeal, and also has a jaunty score composed by David Lindup.

While not as invigorating as "The Legend of the 7 Golden Vampires", this entertains its audience fairly well. Fans of both Hammer and the Shaw brothers will want to see it for curiosity's sake.

Six out of 10.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Lotsa action in Hammer kung-fu flick.
PIMannix12 May 1999
Kicking, shooting and beating aplenty in this Hammer/Shaw Brothers co-production starring Whitman as a hitman with a conscience. Not much here you haven't seen before, but Whitman is OK, the music is kinda funky and, while he doesn't have much screen time, it's always great to see Peter Cushing.
11 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
The last Hammer movie
BandSAboutMovies8 April 2020
Warning: Spoilers
The last film the classic Hammer made, Shatter was also their second film with the Shaw Brothers after The Legend of the 7 Golden Vampires. Directed by Michael Carreras (The Curse of the Mummy's Tomb).

It starts Stuart Whitman as Shatter, a hitman who is in the midst of international chaos after killing an African leader and heading back to Hong Kong.

Shatter then learns that he is the next target, as he's being used by his client for a political agenda. He enlists the help of a martial artist named Tai Pah for help against the many killers coming his way.

This is Peter Cushing's 23rd and final Hammer film. His scenes were shot by Monte Hellman (Cockfighter, Silent Night, Deadly Night 3: Better Watch Out!).

Lung Ti, who plated Tai Pah, would go on to appear in A Better Tomorrow and Legend of Drunken Master. Anton Diffring (The Iguana With the Tongue of Fire) is the bad guy.

This was intended to be a TV series, but it never really even makes sense as a regular movie. Oh well - it has some fun parts at least.
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Final Hammer feature for Peter Cushing
kevinolzak3 May 2014
Warning: Spoilers
1974's "Call Him Mr. Shatter" was nearly the last gasp for Britain's renowned Hammer Films, followed as it was by only three more titles and a pair of 13 episode teleseries. Second of a two picture deal with Hong Kong's Shaw brothers, preceded by "The Legend of the 7 Golden Vampires," its lone returning cast member being Peter Cushing, in a sad finale to a sterling run at Hammer that began with the 1957 classic "The Curse of Frankenstein" (completing one episode of HAMMER HOUSE OF HORROR in 1980, "The Silent Scream"). Stuart Whitman stars in the title role, that of a professional assassin whose latest successful hit, the president of a (fictitious) African nation, results in his payment deferred by recalcitrant international banker Hans Leber (Anton Diffring). Not keen on losing $100,000, Shatter quickly learns that it was neither the US nor Britain that actually hired him, but the drug syndicate that found the president's lookalike brother a better fit for their nefarious needs. Paul Rattwood (Cushing), British security agent in Hong Kong, advises Shatter to leave or sacrifice his health, but with support from martial artist Tai Pah (Li Tung) and sister Mai-Mee (Lily Li), plays off both Rattwood and Leber for greater financial gain, ultimately left no choice but to remain in Hong Kong for the rest of his life. The opening builds nicely through Cushing's introduction 21 minutes in, then goes into a slumber as over a half hour of staged kung fu fights stops the plot dead in its tracks. The choreography is fine, but none of the blows actually hit their targets, the stunts consisting of men simply leaping or falling (no match for Bruce Lee's authenticity). Any film that requires its audience to root for a professional hit man for hire is asking quite a bit, so its really Cushing's three scenes, and Diffring's solid evil presence that truly keep it from sinking completely. Cushing's cynical character initially comes off as quite villainous and never really shakes that image, even when he come through at the end with Shatter's final remuneration. Despite its reputation, it remains quite watchable, perhaps due more to director Monte Hellman's yeoman efforts, filming roughly 80% of the finished film before being unceremoniously dumped toward the end of shooting by Hammer producer Michael Carreras, who took sole directorial credit (he'd been hired because of his familiarity with the location).
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Doesn't make a dent, much less a Shatter
movieman_kev15 October 2005
Stuart Whitman (Tender Flesh, Eaten Alive, the "Superboy" TV show) is Shatter, an international hit-man who goes into hiding when he carries out the assignment of killing an African general that he thought was given to him by someone that it wasn't. Now everyone is gunning for him and he just wants the money owed to him. I usually dig Hammer films quite a bit, however this is one I just couldn't get into. It's just way to slow and badly acted to keep my interest. It felt like it would have been made into a TV show if it did better than it wound up doing. No big loss either way, in my opinion.

Eye Candy: Some random Chinese girl shows T&A

My Grade: D+

DVD Extras: Commentary by Ousted director Monte Hellman & Actor Stuart WhitmanThe World of Hammer episode: "Chiller"; 2 TV spots; and Theatrical Trailer
3 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
East meets West
kosmasp1 August 2019
So shooting this might have been a mess (according to the people involved that is, as they tell us in the audio commentary), but it's still more than fun to watch. So it's Hammer and Shaw Brothers in connection. Actually as the filmmakers reveal Shaw Brothers gave Hammer permission to use their equipment and personell. Which wasn't exactly what they delivered.

Now this seems something to dig your teeth into and find out more about (I might do some further research myself on a later date), but what is fascinating, that the movie still kinda works. All the trials and tribulations, all the sticks and stones thrown into their way, everything that made it more difficult to complete the movie ... and still they got their movie done. And the fight scenes (with a Shaw Brothers regular to complete a rather odd couple -Stuart Whitmann and Tung Li that is) are quite something.

The movie overall has dated and you can feel this is from a different era ... but it is fun to watch and isn't that what it's about after all?
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
bad acting, good music, so-so script
robot-cat21 February 2004
It seemed to have pretty low production values for a Hammer film.

The music was pretty good, but I imagine it's not original to film.

There were a few nice kung-fu fights, but nothing you couldn't find elsewhere.

Stuart's character seems to be somewhat clever at times and extremely dim at others.

Some of the locations were neat, but only in a documentary way (a look into 70's Hong Kong)

You probably won't hate it if you see it, but it's basically a low budget action film with not much to offer.

3/10
3 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
"Remember Shatter, you are on your own"
hwg1957-102-26570419 October 2020
Warning: Spoilers
An ageing assassin acts in Africa then goes to claim his payment for the killing from a Hong Kong banker but falls foul of the syndicate instead. A decent enough thick-ear with lots of martial arts, as this was a Hammer/Shaw Brothers co-production, and filmed colourfully on location in Hong Kong. Stuart Whitman growls as Shatter adequately. Even better are Peter Cushing as a cynical security chief called Rattwood, Anton Diffring as the perfidious paymaster Hans Leber and the great Ti Lung as Shatter's bodyguard Tai Pah. The latter three keep the movie interesting. Familiar actors from the Hong Kong film industry, many uncredited, pop up now and then. Music composer David Lindup proves he isn't Lalo Schifrin. Easy to watch and easy to forget.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
A story about assassinations, martial arts and deception SHOULD be a lot more interesting.
planktonrules22 December 2012
The film begins with a rather nifty assassination by a top hired killer (Stuart Whitman). However, when he goes to collect his fee for this job, he's repeatedly attacked and learns that he supposedly bungled the job. However, it's very obvious there's a lot more to this and he's just a pawn--but can he discover the truth or will one of many, many hired goons put an end to his career...and life?!

While all this sounds very exciting and the film is set in Hong Kong with lots of martial arts action, it isn't particularly compelling. Too often the film just seems to meander and plot holes are filled in by lengthy expositions (a sloppy story telling technique). But the biggest problem for me is that Whitman just didn't make that interesting a character and he didn't seem very believable. Not a terrible film but certainly not a very good one--proving that Hammer Studios might have been much better off sticking with horror films and not venturing into this sort of genre. A time-passer at best.
2 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Shaw Brothers meets Hammer Films, part two!
Captain_Couth13 May 2004
Shatter (1974) was the second time Shaw Brothers and Hammer Films worked together. This time around the results are not as wild and as entertaining as their previous collaboration (The Seven Golden Vampires) but it's worth your while.

Stuart Whitman plays your stereotypical all American actor (a type of role that would later be defined by two other great actors Scott Glenn and Fred Ward). He stars as Shatter, man of many skills. Like all people of his ilk, he has completed a job and all parties want him. Like all movie professionals he runs into the same problems (i.e. reneged contract, can't trust anybody, etc.). Peter Cushing guest stars as an English Special Agent as well as several Shaw Brothers' players (Lily Lee as the love interest and Ti Lung as Shatter's protectorate). Throw in Wei Lo (staff director of the Shaws) in a cameo and bit parts from Fung Hark-On and Lee Hoi Sang and viola! You have Shatter! Despite the lack of an interesting action direction (like Liu Chia Hua) the fight scenes are above average and they aptly showcase Ti Lung's skills (it's a shame that he never made it big time, his English wasn't bad and he has charisma).

Fun for all, recommended for Hammer Films fans and Shaw Brothers marks.
20 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Hammer goes to Hong Kong
neil-douglas201024 January 2022
Decent little Hammer film. Whitman is ideal as the world weary lead actor in this 70's Hong Kong set Kung Fu / Thriller. Ably assisted by Lily Li and Ti Lung, the fight scenes are very well done. Hammer veteran Peter Cushing has a side role as a shady character, all in all a film that could've been a lot worse with different actors.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
Kung Fu Foolishness
AaronCapenBanner24 November 2013
Michael Carreras and Monte Hellman co-directed this crime/Kung Fu hybrid that stars Stuart Whitman as Shatter, an international hit man in Hong Kong who, after killing an African leader, finds himself double-crossed by his employers, and now forced to go on the run not only from them, but the police and the family of the African leader he killed. How can he survive this mess? Peter Cushing costars in a brief role. Perfectly awful film has nothing going for it; unappealing characters, uninteresting story, silly action scenes, and wastes Peter Cushing in his last film for Hammer studios. Only reason to watch this is if you're forced to buy the double-feature DVD for the other film!
1 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Hammer and Kung Fu
BaronBl00d16 September 2001
An African dictator is assasinated by a secret serviceman unbeknownst that he was hired by a mob rather than his government. He goes to Hong Kong to collect his fee and finds that the mob, his own government, and the African nation are all after him. Stuart Whitman plays the very tired looking Mr. Shatter. He looks like Jack Riley playing Mr. Carlin on the Bob Newhart Show! He meets up with a couple kung fu fighters, one a young man who is the best fighter in Asia and the other a young girl who falls in love with Whitman's lack of charm and exhausted looks. The film has some great fight scenes and the young kung fu expert Lung Ti is an exceptional martial arts expert. Despite the film's obvious flaws, it is a pretty good action-thriller. The acting takes a back seat to the martial arts and the great scenery of a bustling Hong Kong. Peter Cushing has a small role as a British secret service agent and his cameo is the best thing in the film. The role gives Cushing a great part as a rather sadistic, sharp-tounged man with a great sense of ironic humour. He chews his lines with obvious relish(must have been happy he got the free trip to Hong Kong when he heard he was going to be billed below Stuart Whitman in a film named Shatter!). Whitman is also bested by Anton Diffring as the banker for the mob and Whitman's chief nemesis. Diffring had a way playing men of low moral character. Hammer worked with the Shaw Brothers(they produced numerous martial arts films) and came out with a pretty entertaining film. Though not nearly as exciting or innovative as The Legend of the Seven Golden Vampires, Shatter still delivers some punch...and flying feet!
15 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Dullish at times, but bolstered by Kung fu fighting, Whitman and Cushing
coltras353 September 2022
Shatter, an international contract killer, has been assigned to assassinate the President of a small African country and collect his fee from a bank in the Far East. On arrival in Hong Kong his life is threatened and when the bank denies all knowledge of payment arrangements, he realises he has been drawn into a dangerous game where there are no rules. Amongst the players are the Mafia and several foreign intelligence services and the stakes being played for are deadly.

Stuart Whitman as hitman Shatter looks suitably shattered and world weary. He does a fine job in a film that isn't a James Bond-style film. It's more of a gritty action thriller that benefits from aforementioned Whitman's presence, Peter Cushing ( who can make anything good), Hong Kong location, and Ti Lung's fighting. A lot of kung fu fighters lack Bruce Lee's brand of to-the-point, bone-crushing speed and dynamically charged school of hard knocks, but Ti Lung achieves this to a certain degree. I was impressed. Without the kung fu fighting and other attractions I had mentioned, it can be rather dull, lacks spark and muddled; it isn't great, but just ok.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
The other Hammer / Shaw Brothers Collab
DanTheMan2150AD22 March 2024
The other Hammer / Shaw Brothers collaboration, Shatter's conception predates The Legend of the 7 Golden Vampires, as it was originally pitched as a Canadian co-production before being confined to a shelf for a few years and then resurrected as part of the collaboration deal. Rather than a period drama as both companies were used to producing, Shatter sees the action transported to contemporary Hong Kong and it's used to great effect, even if it amounts to nothing more than a lot of glorious eye candy. The film ran into many problems during production and this is evident in the finished product, the editing is off by a beat, it doesn't go anywhere very fast and isn't helped by a mediocre script. Stuart Whitman doesn't care about his role, an entirely one-note performance, but he's carried by the indomitable Peter Cushing who always gives 100%, remaining a joyous presence in this otherwise substandard kung fu exploitation. Ti Lung is the actual star here even if he struggles with his English dialogue, the same problem befalls Lily Li. In the end, the novelty value of Shatter probably makes this more of interest to Shaw fans than Hammer fans; although I enjoyed the film, like Golden Vampires, it just left me wanting more from its initial promise, ultimately coming across as incredibly sloppy and rather underwhelming.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Shattering the cellar.
morrison-dylan-fan29 January 2022
Warning: Spoilers
When looking round Talking Pictures free online catch-up service,I was intrigued to find a section titled "Cellar club", where Scream Queen Caroline Munro introduces two genre titles each week. A Hammer title I've not heard of before,I got set to see the glass shatter.

View on the film:

A production so troubled that Hammer studio head Michael Carreras made himself the director,after getting rid of original director Monte Hellman, this results in a number of amusing crash-zooms and sudden screen-wipes, when attempts are made to force the odd ends of disjointed footage together.

Whilst lacking the touch of Hammer glamour, the directors do edge towards the exotic glamour of the 60's Euro Spy movies, with extensive, hand-held shots down the streets of Hong Kong (which judging by the looks straight into the camera by the locals, was illegally filmed, giving it a much needed pinch of rawness.)

Becoming entangled not only in the under world, but also a muddled script, Stuart Whitman (who clearly did workouts for the role) gives a very good, blunt performance as Shatter, whilst in his final Hammer appearance, Peter Cushing brings a touch of class to proceedings as boo-hiss baddie Paul Rattwood, whose plans are left shattered.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Boring the pane.
bbjzilla7 February 2023
Strangely boring action film about a mumbling stone faced assassin touring Hong Kong after being betrayed by his employers.

Completely unaware of it's own nonsense (the camera gun?) Shatter takes on the bad guys with some particularly gory head shots and a camp as buttons falling-out-of-a-window finale. In the meantime his new pals; a kung fu wizard takes out the trash and a hooker with a heart of gold....oh dear. Who could have predicted that?

The story is basic but there's no hope of following it as plot elements are explained only using exposition heavy dialogue and things happen for no real reason and make less sense. (The missile? Severing his vocal chords won't stop him writing things down? Surely there were easier solutions to the syndicate's woes than double crossing a third party?) But at least there are no secret underground layers and no one goes into space. There's misfiring dialogue like "(Shatter)'s not just a name. It's a way of life" Eh?

(In what way? I'm Scottish and I if I was "shattered" I'd be exhausted.

"I'm not just tired. I'm really tired" Tired like this movie.)

He doesn't know who he was working for, does no investigation and makes terrible decisions, his plans are awful and he gets lucky in the end. Just what you need from the world's top hitman. Why try harder?

Apparently the original director got fired after Michael Carreras didn't like the early footage but still lays claim that it's 80% his original cut, it's easy to see why he was replaced; a city as exciting and cultural, exotic even, as Hong Kong should make excellent eye candy but looks dull and impoverished, the action sequences are adequate but introduced far too late after nearly 60 minutes of one-dimension Shatter wandering around and getting beaten up a few times. It's as if they thought "we're in Hong Kong and we need to make a movie but we haven't got a script or any time or money but we've got some actors." And then cobbled together some spy/ hitman shenanigans from the cliche mill, just so long as it goes all the way to the top...

A back alley, a harbour and a hilltop. And some cable cars. It's desperate stuff.

The only good bit is the fight scene in the club full of tension and kinetic drama, but ironically is of no consequence plot-wise and seems to come from a different film. Second unit?

As a Hammer film; it's near the end. The studio had more or less lost its identity and was attempting to break new ground in order to continue but duffers like this only served to accelerate its collapse. Tellingly it also ended the brief friendship with Shaw Brothers.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Watchable Hammer-meets-Shaw thriller
Leofwine_draca17 December 2016
Warning: Spoilers
SHATTER is Hammer's second attempt at a Hong Kong-backed movie after the cult classic that is LEGEND OF THE 7 GOLDEN VAMPIRES. Whilst not an inherently enjoyable film like the former, SHATTER is a mildly interesting diversion with a good enough cast to make it worthwhile. Although the film has a fair few slow patches where the interest wanes through lack of action, generally the plot, which concerns a hit-man trying to collect his fee, is engaging and the action realistic.

This isn't a James Bond-style adventure as the title might suggest; the movie strives for realism over comic book style and the result is a gritty, downbeat, sporadically exciting foray into the world of the international thriller. The unconventional lead is played by Stuart Whitman, who enjoyed a brief status as a leading action man in the 1970s after he appeared in this and some Italian thrillers. Whitman is hardly an athletic hero, but his hang dog looks and his steely determination go part way in letting the audience empathise with his character's situation.

Things begin with some stock footage of African race riots and moves into a bloody assassination scene, where Whitman uses a gun disguised as a camera to take care of his contract! From then on we see him hiding out in a seedy Hong Kong hotel room and biding time while he tries to figure things out. SHATTER isn't a film which shows Hong Kong in a very good light – in fact the film has a sleazy, depressing atmosphere and the crowded setting only makes things worse.

Whitman visits his German contact Hans Luber (played by genre favourite Anton Diffring) but is unable to collect his fee, and instead finds himself beaten up by violent policemen. These two scenes highlight two excellent cameo performances. The first is Diffring's; the typically sinister character of Luber is a great role to play and Diffring is his usual snide, evil self in the part. Secondly we have Peter Cushing in the role of Paul Rattwood, which is more like an extended cameo. Rattwood is an official in the secret police and a rather nasty character who knows more than he lets on and who keeps a gang of thugs under his command. Cushing is of course excellent in the role and gets some nicely sharp-tongued dialogue to himself; but sadly this proved to be his last role for Hammer Studios and a rather inconspicuous swan song for the golden age actor. Still, the moments when he is on screen sparkle and he seems to be enjoying himself, which is enough for me.

Whitman moves into a seedy massage parlour/restaurant owned by Ti Lung, at the same time beginning a tragic romance with Lily Li who works there. The rest of the film shows him basically hanging out and eventually doing a trade with Diffring (an unbearably suspenseful scene), who wants the top secret documents in Whitman's possession. But the treacherous Diffring betrays our down-at-heel hero, leading to an action-packed finale where Whitman and Lung storm the enemy's retreat.

Most of the action towards the end of this film focuses on Lung, who is portrayed as a young, unstoppable martial arts hero in the line of Bruce Lee. Lung is a tour-de-force in the action stakes and the scenes of him fighting are tremendously exciting and violent. Lily Li is also pretty good as Mai, although she doesn't get to fight in this movie. SHATTER isn't a very engaging movie, but the direction is solid, there is enough action and gore to satisfy the male crowd, and the cast alone makes it worthwhile. Don't be fooled, this is no classic, but it remains watchable enough if you're in the right mood.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Perfect 10
PlasticActor22 January 2022
It takes failure to find success - - 10/10 for a film that has had every bit stripped away for ideas found in many, many other films to follow. Besides that it's a great Hammer film (not Hollywood pretentiousness) with a real natural, honest gritty feel to it. Hong looks run down as ever, and Peter Cushing is brilliantly British rattling off dialogue as only he can. Nice one liners. Stewart Whitman looks like he will Shatter at any moment and his face has more lines than shattered crystals. So much the better for it adds more realism. Kung fu scenes are super pro- gives Bruce Lee (love him) a real run for his money. There is even a Kung Fu fighting academy with Thai and Japanese martial arts. Wicked. The fighting looks real, not that fake Jackie Chan BS with all the obnoxious squealing. The ending? Shattered.
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
passable Hammer action flick with strange sense of morality
Matt Moses12 May 2001
Hammer helped define the gothic vampire genre, for which we should be thankful, but they also found need to dabble in other fields with mixed results. Shatter did not have the most inspired mixture and doesn't stand the test of time very well. Perpetually grouchy killer for hire Stuart Whitman fails goes to Hong Kong where he fails to collect from disreputable banker Anton Diffring. Corrupt government official Peter Cushing has his men beat the pulp out of Whitman, who stumbles off to a massage parlor where kung fu master Lung Ti treats him to a freebie from adorable Li-Li Li (whose name sounds like the refrain to a doo-wop song). Whitman finds his apartment blown up so he takes refuge at his new friends' dojo. He slips underground for a while but gets attacked at a martial arts invitational won by understated Ti. Without questioning the moral validity of his instincts, they help him in his quest to extort a mil from Diffring. International affairs gets somewhat sticky from here, and the bullets fly freely until the predictable climax. Carreras tries his best to present Whitman as a then-prevalent philosopher killer, but the weak introspective sequences that show Whitman roaming around his apartment fail to do the trick. The apparently sensitive regret he feels for his victims comes off as a brooding doom with little real emotion backing it up. Shatter's intolerance for international culture makes a few unexpected peeps from its veneer of acceptance. Snooty references to eating snakes evidence a discomfort with the behavior of a foreign country. The background story sets this attitude in stone: Whitman's being tracked down for getting involved with political affairs in Badawi, a corrupt puppet country in Africa in which brothers contentedly murder brothers for money and power. Such situations may perhaps at time truly occur, but the same can be found in Shakespeare with less disapproval asked of the audience. The degree of acceptance present can be seen as a sense of tragedy, completely disconnected with the random slaying of evil black or Asian characters. I don't mean to push the point, but I found it odd that both major black characters were played no-name Yemi Ajibade in an otherwise internationally well-known cast. Cult director Monte Hellman apparently assisted Carreras, far more experienced as a producer, but did not receive credit. Writer Don Houghton produced the other Shaw/Hammer co-production, The Legend of the 7 Golden Vampires and also takes credit for the awful but amusing Dracula AD 1972. Scenes allegedly shot in Badawi, a country that does not exist, were probably done in Hong Kong.
7 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
So Bad it's Good
jcrveatch27 August 2019
It's one of those movies that is so bad it's good. Found it by accident when my friend was looking for a scene from "Top Secret" with Val Kilmer, but we found this abomination instead. It's a cult classic. And we learned about the downfalls caused by this movie, and that made this movie so much better. This movie caused the director to swear off directing ever again, stuff like that. Peter Cushing refused to work with Hammer Studio with co-produced it after making 23 movies with them. Both Hammer Studio and the Hong Kong company that made this ultimately were defunct because of this movie. And the main actor, Stuart Whitman go divorced the same year, coincidence...I think not. All this stuff is so bad and so funny that I had to buy and frame a poster of the greatest movie failure. 10/10 would watch again.
0 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Nice-looking but slow-moving
Wizard-87 March 2003
Stuart Whitman was a good choice to play the burly and rough-edged hitman of the movie, but it's a pity that he doesn't get much of substance to do. The main fault is a slow-moving screenplay; after the first 20 minutes, it takes about half an hour before things really start to move again, and even after that point things don't really move that much faster. The various action scenes are only okay at best. Though the behind-the-scenes problems the movie suffered from don't make for any real glaring problems, there are still some notable holes here and there. However, the movie does give us a really scenic tour of early 1970s Hong Kong; if you are curious about what it was like to live there back then, the movie may be worth a look.
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Whitman, Stuart Whitman
inspectors7122 November 2005
I have almost no memory of this film, yet I'm writing a review. Go figure!

I seem to remember Stuart Whitman as some sort of hit-man in Hong Kong. It was entertaining and badly dubbed and fairly gory; the sort of movie HBO used to fill up their schedule with when they weren't showing more traditional features and before they went off the air at midnight.

My suggestion is to read the ten other reviews and, if this long-lost and forgettable Kung Fu/Spy flick piques your interest, rent it or buy a used copy.

Enjoy!
2 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed