Give 'em Hell, Harry! (1975) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
13 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Folksy, Plain Vanilla Politics.
rmax3048239 February 2015
In this one-person filmed play, James Whitmore gives it everything he's got as Harry Truman between 1945 and 1952. He looks rather like Truman -- from the front, anyway -- but he speaks more quickly than the president and in clipped cheery tones. He strides purposefully around the stage. When he stops, he stands stiffly and seems to stare at the ceiling. He hardly pauses for an instant. If he left the room, the walls would pant.

Whitmore speaks to imaginary visitors like Herbert Hoover and Franklin Delano Roosevelt. To the latter, he complains that he, Truman, is sometimes called "Your Accidency." I suspect some of the younger folk of today might have to reach a bit for that gag. When he describes his experiences as a battery commander in World WarI, he dons an ancient khaki uniform and soup-bowl helmet. Otherwise he's in suit or shirt sleeves.

It's one interesting anecdote after another. His start in Independence, Missouri; his sponsorship by Boss Pendergast. He uses vulgar language from time to time -- nothing drastic -- and has down-home habits such as clearing his nose by the snort and swallow method. It's all quite amusing.

Once in a while, there is a fiery speech about the plight of the Negroes, corruption in government, and other largely liberal pieties. He condemns the Ku Klux Klan and Joseph McCarthy. He describes his opponents in harsh and commonplace terms. No pretension here. But left out is one of his sermons to reporters on the Chinese troops in Korea. The Chinese, he calls "Chinks." Later, "the yellow peril." And finally, "the heathen Chinee." He was quite a guy -- no nonsense, no pussyfooting around.

Some of the material is dated. He has no qualms about dropping the bomb and, as far as apologies go, he's waiting for an apology for Pearl Harbor. And some of the connective tissue is undoubtedly fabricated. There's something oddly resonant in his brash pronouncements about unions and minimum wage and "winning" in Korea -- he seems to put the word in quotes. Maybe it's my imagination.

Mostly, one almost collapses from exhaustion after watching this show. What must Whitmore have felt like when the curtain dropped? Did he drop too?
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Wonderful showcase for James Whitmore
llltdesq1 September 2015
Warning: Spoilers
This is a filmed version of a performance of the stage play. There will be spoilers ahead:

This film has the distinction of having the entire cast nominated for an Academy Award. Granted, the film has a cast of one (James Whitmore) and thus made that a rather easy thing to do. As an aside, the 1972 version of Sleuth had its entire principle cast nominated, because Michael Caine and Laurence Olivier are the only two significant performances. But I digress.

This film gives Whitmore the golden opportunity of doing a solo onstage. He's portraying Harry S Truman in what is largely a monologue with direct addresses to the audience. Occasionally, Whitmore must interact with invisible people and Whitmore carries this off quite effectively.

The play covers Truman's life from his time serving in World War I through the tail end of his presidency, covering the most significant events of his life. The play is funny, bawdy, profane and dramatic. I don't know just how much of the material is drawn from Truman's actual remarks, speeches, letters and so on, but I do recognize a fair amount as being taken from Truman himself.

It covers his career in Missouri, brushes with the KKK, showcases a fictional Oval Office chat with the ghost of FDR and deals with his confrontations with MacArthur and McCarthy. For anyone interested in politics or Harry Truman, this is pretty much required viewing.

As far as I'm aware, this has only been on VHS in Region 1. I know of know commercial release on DVD. I truly wish it would become available on DVD. Recommended.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Whitmore's performance is exceptional.
Rob-1203 July 2000
A filmed version of a one-man stage play (filmed before a live audience), James Whitmore's Oscar-nominated performance is a rare treasure. As Truman, Whitmore gives rapid-fire comments on the highlights of an exceptional politician's career. Truman explains his justification for dropping the atomic bomb at the end of World War II, and his reasons for firing General Douglas MacArthur during the Korean War. He talks of his wife, Bess (whom he refers to as "the Boss"), his home in Missouri, and his early days as a soldier in World War I, and a county commissioner in Kansas City. He offers us his views of Truman's contemporaries, both good (Winston Churchill, George C. Marshall) and bad (Joe McCarthy and Richard Nixon). Whitmore is a joy to watch. If you can find this rare film it is well worth seeing.
10 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Another wonderful Whitmore performance
gary-10921 September 2002
This was a great filmed stage presentation of James Whitmore's one-man show about Harry Truman, written by Samuel Gallu. He becomes President Truman right from the beginning. This show, along with the Will Rogers USA and the not-as-well-known Bully or Bully Boy (Theodore Roosevelt) is the complete list of one-man shows this fine actor has done.
7 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Harry Would Be Proud!
Sylviastel16 October 2006
I am not surprised that this film earned it's star, James Whitmore, an Academy Award nomination. I would think that it would be better aired on television. He would have easily earned an Emmy Award for Best Actor in a Television Film. It is better to get an Academy Award nomination than an Emmy Award but I still think it's one of the best performances that I have seen by an actor in years. James Whitmore really captures the essence and presence of President Harry Truman. In his brilliant performance, staged and film, he is alive in a role that has consumed him. You really believe that he is Harry Truman after awhile. I still think it would have been seen more by people on television than in the cinemas because this little film has that kind of power. I am sure that many more people would have seen it and that is the key to ensuring it's legacy. I am glad that they released it in cinemas but they probably made little or no money on it. It would have been better to have aired it on television. One man performance even with James Whitmore's talent and genius could not hinge the fact that he is the only person on stage. While brilliant to watch, today's standards would never allow somebody in a one person show unless it's a comedian. As for Truman's power, this film is an excellent tool that can be used in the history classrooms to show this former President. I love how he talks about his wife Bess, his mother-in-law Mother Wallace, FDR, and others. Truman also talks about the klan, racism, and others in this performance that he will be best remembered for.
7 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Bittersweet America
dapplez17 March 2011
Warning: Spoilers
To watch "Give 'em Hell, Harry" is to be sad and proud at the same time. It is sad that all politicians are not this honest and dedicated to doing right by the American people. But it makes me proud that there was once a man from Missouri who became a U.S. Senator and President of the United States who always told the truth in plain words, no matter the political price.

I see that one reviewer on another site said he did not know if Truman actually went to a Ku Klux Klan rally to tell them off. It's true. And he did it without any protection; on his way home he encountered some of his friends headed the other way to protect him. He told them to go home, that the Klan were nothing but a bunch of cowards, and they would never attack anyone in the daylight.

If America had had more people like this, it would have saved us a whole lot of trouble.

Sadly, Truman made some enemies on the other side of the political aisle. They spread a lot of lies about him, and some of those lies continue to be circulated today. Sound familiar? One contributor on IMDb.com, Bob Shields, accused Harry Truman of being an active participant in the Missouri organized crime "mob" while President!

You should watch this to find out about the real Harry Truman. And read "Plain Speaking," by Merle Miller, an oral biography, which is the source of much of the material used here.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
On my Top Ten List for certain!
davidyoung9826 August 2007
This movie was made the year I was born, and I only saw it because it happened to be on at midnight on some non-affiliated channel back around 1990. I taped this movie off television, and just about wore the tape out watching it. I did not know much about Truman prior to seeing this movie, but after having watched it at least 100 times, Whitmore makes me feel like I knew the man. Even as a teenager in the early '90s, this was one of my favorite movies. Truman clearly had a quick wit, and it comes through clearly in this masterpiece biopic. If this movie is not released on DVD or some other digital medium, I fear that it will not be seen by future generations. I have never seen it on television since that night almost twenty years ago. I saw the Shawshank Redemption (which was also an excellent movie), and I thought that Whitmore was even better in "Give 'Em Hell Harry".
4 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Thought it was old Harry A-- himself.
weird be3 December 1998
I lived through this time. James Whitmore did such a good job he even made you think he looked like old Harry.
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
what a wonderful time
dtucker8621 October 2001
I have always loved history especially history regarding US Presidents. I think that next to Abraham Lincoln, Harry Truman was our greatest president. This man is the only President of the 20th century who never went to college and yet this common man touched greatness. James Whitmore truly does him justice, I read that Margaret Truman saw his performance and said "my God that is my dad!". I think that Hal Holbrook was the actor who started the great tradition of "one man shows" with his great portrayal of Mark Twain, many have done it since but Whitmore is the best. You get a great history lesson here as Truman talks about his life on the farm, his experiences in WWII, his rise in Missouri politics, his vice presidency and finally becoming President. You think you really are listening to Harry when he talks about dropping the bomb, the 1948 election against Dewey and his firing of MacArthur. This film is a delight from start to finish and I think it should be shown to every child to show him about what a great man Truman was!
11 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
This Film should be available on EVERY STREAMING SERVICE RIGHT NOW!
661jda15 September 2022
Sorry Jack Nicholson - you were awesome in ONE FLEW OVER THE CUCKOO'S NEST, but Whitmore channels Truman and he's on the screen 100% of the time! He looks like Truman, talks and acts like Truman; It's a marvelous performance and the documented items that he discusses, MacArthur, Nixon, McCarthy, White Supremacy, Liars in Public Office, Civil Rights: All are true and just as pertinent today and they were 70 years ago when he said them. It's a great history lesson and a very entertaining one as well. I just can't stress it long or loud enough, this should be on every streaming service for the public to watch. Great quote which is not exact, but paraphrased here: If you have someone in office lying long enough to the public, the public will start to believe the lies. This film was made in 1975 and the original quote is 70 years old - The future is here.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
I very much enjoyed this one-man show of James Whitmore as Harry S. Truman in Give 'em Hell, Harry!
tavm19 February 2018
With today being Presidents Day, I've been watching some movies about presidents. Previously, I saw Wilson about Woodrow Wilson-the 28th President of the United States. This one is about Harry S. Truman-the 33rd President of the United States. As portrayed by James Whitmore, he appears on stage as the only performer on it having "conversations" with various people that come into his office like former President Herbert Hoover. He recounts his fight with General Douglas MacArthur, his taking on the Ku Klux Klan and Senator Joseph McCarthy, a critic saying something not-flattering about daughter Margaret concerning a concert performance, and, near the end, what he thinks about eventual president, Richard Nixon. (It's not good!) After years of only knowing about this, I'm glad to finally have seen this on YouTube just now. So on that note, I highly recommend Give 'em Hell, Harry!
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Super story of Harry S Truman and Super expose' of a great actor.
RSBlain10 August 2004
My comments concerning "Give Em Hell Harry" need only be short and sweet. This was, bar none, one of the finest movies I have ever seen giving a biography of a presidency and it is done as a one-man show. It is just, well, S-U-P-E-R. If you want to learn a little about a man or a presidency, if you want to see a great actor in action, this is a movie for you. Experience the trauma of an era. Experience the greatness of a man. Experience the fantastic portrayal by a great actor by not missing this movie. I can't imagine anyone being sorry they took time out to live within a period of time for a few short minutes by watching/being a part of this great offering in movie making and stage playing. Don't cheat yourself if you have the opportunity of viewing it. It is a 10 in my eyes without a doubt.
10 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
audio taped this back on 7/4/82
james_jones23 October 2008
As a twenty two year old enjoying a blissful summer in 1982, I came home from a day at Zuma Beach and this is what channel 5 was showing. Back then, my hobby was to audio tape(VCRs will rare then)stuff on TV. I recorded about the last twenty minutes of it. His story about McCarthy and his reading of the Tennyson poem were parts I've committed to memory. since my mom had a stroke, I recently began driving her car and it has a cassette player in it. I looked in my dusty old tape box and there it was. I have been playing it over and over again, like I did 26 years ago. Whitemore is priceless as Truman.

A side note: After the Truman show ends on my tape, the next thing you hear is Dan Akroyd as Richard Nixon on a SNL sketch where he turns off the TV in disgust at how Rip Torn is portraying him in a TV movie: Akroyd blurts out on my tape: "Well that was a piece of crap"
3 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed