The Immortals (1974) Poster

(1974)

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Lost Cause Heroes
cires_copt30 December 2005
Warning: Spoilers
On the 21st of October 1599 in Alba Iulia, Michael The Brave was the first to politically unite the 3 historical provinces of Moldavia, Valachia and Transylvania into what was much later to become the modern Romanian state. The times were not good for such an ambitious dream, with the Ottoman Turks and the Austrian-Hungarian pressure coming from all directions. Michael was killed in his tent by a traitor and the unification dream dissipated in the intrigues of the time.

Here is where the movie begins, a few years after Michael's death, with a group of his loyal soldiers wandering the castles and cities of Mediaeval Europe, with nothing much on them but poverty and rags, but still faithfully carrying a heavy stash and the flag of the Great Union. Their sole purpose: to return to their country and with the riches in the stash to build up a new army in order to accomplish Michael's dream.

Unfortunately there had never been a treasure in that stash, but only the group's leader played by Ion Besoiu knows it is filled with rocks. He shares the secret only with Captain Andrei, a former officer of Michael's, because he doesn't want his men to lose hope. They have a lot of adventures on their way home, and at a moment they are captured by their long time enemy Selim Pasha, who wants to take their treasure. (In my humble opinion, this is one of the best scenes in the movies, the 13 heroes are buried in sand up to their necks and horses are herded over them, as a means of torture.) However they escape and they get home. But their leader hangs himself ashamed and not knowing how to confess his soldiers the secret of the stash. Captain Andrei tells them the truth and inflames them once more by planning to put the Union Flag up on one of Michael's former castles, as a symbol for freedom and better times. They faithfully stick together and die together, besieged by Turks and Romanian traitor troops allied with Selim Pasha.

Sergiu Nicolaescu is as usual a flamboyant type of hero;Amza Pellea - fascinating humor; Ilarion Ciobanu impresses through his massive stature and honest look, and Colea Rautu as always, the villain enemy prototype.

But I think most of the people who have seen the movie will agree with me on that the best thing at this movie is the soundtrack, performed by the legendary folk rock band Phoenix. True traditional rhythms are transposed in modern shape in songs which enchanted generations and generations and which still buy all the tickets when the Phoenix have a concert.

7 out of 10 mainly because of Amza Pellea and the music.

******** Sergiu Nicolaescu allegedly said: "Even since l971 I had this idea of a group of "13 immortals", who appeared in history whenever they were needed, showing that courage and readiness of sacrifice which could have served as an example to the masses. 25 years later someone in France took over my idea by making the movies with Cristopher Lambert. In my "Immortals" you can notice the last image in the movie, that place in the fortress of Rasnov where standing near their own graves are the the 13 warriors. Unfortunately the censorship of the time did not like the idea, fearing that other heroes could appear besides Ceausescu. I had started the movie in an original directing approach which unfortunately I had to give up because of the panic who got into the movie's cutting editor. Too bad, it was a new thing which hasn't been yet accomplished by anyone."
12 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
You need something between your ears
hayan1200015 October 2012
You know, there are many songs, movies, stories, dance....reflecting a period in a human life. And sometimes those events in life are reclaimed in your memory. I'm not sure about that, but probably this movie is one of them.

BTW I live in Yokohama but I'm Romanian and that's something impossible to reject and I DON'T WANNA!

Sry for that ""pathetic"" introduction.

The movie is worth watching and analyze.

The real story, I don't know.

The legend I'm sure, I was reading that since I was a boy.

The actors are great!

The screenplay...almost.

The directing also great.

If you have nothing much better to do watch this story and enjoy.
10 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
a good movie for that time...
soto4maya22 March 2005
Like many other movies made under the communist regime, the scenario for "Nemuritorii" reflects the ideology of the time. It emphasizes the serenity of the nationalistic ideas in the history of the romanians. Historically speaking, the film has no value whatsoever. To see a plan (romanian dream) in the actions of Mihai Viteazul is a fact of pure communist nationalistic ideology. The director, Sergiu Nicolaescu, is a master when it comes to combining the art of film making with the art of well dissimulated communist propaganda. On the other hand the film has some strong points: a good casting, very well chosen shooting sets and the best soundtrack for a romanian film made before 1989 signed by Phoenix, a legendary romanian band of the '70s. In conclusion, this film is above average compared to other romanian historical productions.
14 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
marks - from director to the period
Kirpianuscus31 December 2018
One of historical films under Comunism. Not bad, not good. Only decent. Interesting if you do not ignore the context of its birth. Adventures, historical events as scene, Sergiu Nicolaescu mark and good actors. Reasonable performances and heroism helping a noble dream in huge portions. Maybe, nothing else. But, in the context of the Romanian cinematography under the Comunism of eight decade, not so bad.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed