Summer Magic (1963) Poster

(1963)

User Reviews

Review this title
42 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
A Kinder, Gentler America
JamesHitchcock14 February 2015
The decade that brought us the First World War may seem an odd subject for nostalgia, but "Summer Magic", like "On Moonlight Bay" from a few years earlier, is a film which tries to persuade us that, whatever may have been happening on the battlefields of Europe, the 1910s (or the "Ragtime Era" as many Americans called them) really were the time of a kinder, gentler America. (It is, apparently, a remake of a 1938 film called "Mother Carey's Chickens", which I have never seen). Margaret Carey, a recently widowed mother from Boston, is forced to move out of the family home when she discovers that her late husband was the victim of a fraudulent investment scheme. She and her three children, Nancy, Gilly and Peter, relocate to the small town of Beulah, Maine, where they rent a large yellow house. (Gilly- pronounced with a hard "G"- is a boy, not a girl. The name is presumably short for Gilbert, but this is never actually made clear).

There are two main plot lines. The first revolves around the family's friendship with Ossian ("Osh") Popham, the agent for their rather mysterious landlord Mr Hamilton. The kindly Osh is more than just a letting agent; he is also the town's storekeeper and general odd-job- man. The second plot line deals with the visit of the Careys' spoilt, snobbish cousin Julia and the mutual dislike which grows up between her and Nancy, especially when they fall for the same man.

This was the fourth of six films which Hayley Mills made for Walt Disney Productions. Hayley was, of course, originally from England, but during this period of her career was most often cast (as here) as an American, even though she had trouble managing a convincing American accent. (Here she attempts to sound more American by shortening the long "a" vowels, but this only makes her sound closer to Boston, Lincolnshire than to Boston, Massachusetts). This did not, however, affect her popularity, and she became possibly the most popular teenage star of the sixties. In Britain she tended to be cast in more serious roles ("Tiger Bay", "Whistle Down the Wind", "The Chalk Garden"), but most of her American films were comedies, of which this is a good example. It is also a good example of just what made Hayley so popular in her day- her wonderful liveliness and vivaciousness, combined with a gift for conveying sweetness and innocence. By 1963, when she would have been seventeen, she performed a sort of dual role for Disney. To the older generation she was the daughter they wished they had. To boys, she was the girlfriend they wished they had, a sex symbol in the nicest possible way.

Dorothy McGuire, looking much younger than her 47 years, is good as Margaret, as is Deborah Walley as the insufferable Julia. The other performance which stands out, however, is from Burl Ives as the warm- hearted, if occasionally devious, Osh. Ives had originally made his name as a folk-singer, but later became a successful actor, both on Broadway and in the cinema. I had previously associated him with serious dramas such as "Cat on a Hot Tin Roof" and "The Big Country", but here he shows that he could do light comedy as well.

The film is also a musical with several songs, although none of them rally stand out apart from "The Ugly Bug Ball", which was a favourite of mine as a child. (I had no idea at the time that it was from a film). The plot at times becomes a bit hard to follow, especially the various machinations involving Osh and Mr Hamilton, and the ending seems a bit too abrupt. Overall, however, the film's cheerful atmosphere and the contributions of Mills and Ives make this a watchable example of warm- hearted Disney family entertainment. 7/10
17 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Good-natured family film
gee-152 September 2003
Many films are criticized for what they are not, rather than what they are. "Summer Magic" is not a critical, gritty look at the turn-of-the-century life in rural Maine. It is a good-natured, fun film that you don't have to worry about letting your children watch. Hayley Mills is a delight as the ever-optimistic Nancy Carey who misrepresents her family's situation in order to win the sympathy of Mr. Popham, a rural Maine postmaster, general store owner, sheriff, etc. who allows them to rent a house he doesn't own. The plot is complicated by the unanticipated visit of Nancy's snobby cousin, Julia, the dour nagging of Mr. Popham's doom-and-gloom wife, Mariah, and the ultimate arrival of the house's true owner at a most inconvenient moment. Burl Ives as the laconically good-natured Mr. Popham is a absolute treat to watch. And the climax of the film (which I won't reveal here)makes me laugh out loud no matter how many times I've seen it. Those looking for a good family film should look no further.
32 out of 36 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Magical
aimless-468 June 2009
Good or bad, happy or sad, come what may this will always be the most magical of the movies I saw in a theater as a child. Already charmed by its Disney-Norman Rockwell-Hallmark look at the Ragtime Age; this 12 year old boy was simply bowled over 30 minutes into the film by his first glimpse of Deborah Walley. Walley was already a teen queen from her "Gidget" film but had escaped my too-young-to-notice teen actresses consciousness until that day at the theater.

In her period costume this vision was the original "Pretty in Pink" and the most beautiful girl I had ever seen. And might explain my lifelong preference for redheads.

At its core "Summer Magic" is a Disney fairy tale cloaked in a "too-good-to-be-true" production design. If the term expressionist nostalgia ever applied to a film it is this one. Disney simply took basic plot elements form the novel and film "Mother Carey's Chickens" (1938), threw in a bunch of "Cinderella" elements, and had Dorothy McGuire softly reprise her performance in "A Tree Grows In Brooklyn".

If you can't find something here with which to connect, whether it is wistful identification or distanced examination of the film language elements, then you are probably already pretty much used up. Liking this film now is just having the willingness to exercise a little self-knowing whimsy.

Cinderella-wise you have a fairy prince, a glass slipper, a wicked step-sister, a wardrobe transformation scene, cute animals, a coach, songs, and a ball.

The songs are along the lines of those seen recently in "Enchanted" but without the elaborate special effects. A couple of these, "Pink of Perfection" and "Femininity", have been popping in and out of my head ever since 1963. Those two and "Ugly Bug Ball" have held up surprisingly well. "Flitterin" and "Beautiful Beulah" are decent if not especially memorable.

"On the Front Porch" was weak then and hasn't improved with age; it should have been trimmed from the film as that is the film's weakest (insert "boring" here) scene. The sequence should be of interest to film students as it is the only time the director has real difficulty keeping the cast focused; definitely a post-production challenge for the editor who did some damage control but could not salvage anything worth keeping.

Viewing the film today I found Wendy Turner (as Lallie Joy Popham-Virginia Weidler's role in the 1938 film) a revelation. Turner's is the most authentic performance; which is interesting because she was originally cast as the youngest of the three girls simply because she was slightly shorter than the 5' 2" Walley, not much was expected of this novice. Her ability to take acting for the camera direction must have been a pleasant surprise for James Neilson. She gets to do an ugly duckling wardrobe transformation sequence worthy of "Cinderella".

As often happened with Disney, elements were included to insure that it appealed to the widest demographic. So you have a shaggy sheep dog (where have I seen that before?), you have a couple of handsome young television actors (Peter Brown and James Stacy), you have a Moochie Corcoran hammy kid, you have the comedy relief of acting veterans Una Merkel and Burl Ives to appeal to parents, and you have liberal use of Disney's stock nature footage.

Although I was too dazzled by Walley to pay much attention to Hayley Mills this was probably her best performance for Disney, it was certainly the most difficult part she was given. Her acting was more polished than it had been in "Pollyanna" and the out-of-place English accent taught us young Disney viewers all about the concept of suspension of disbelief.

Then again, what do I know? I'm only a child.
15 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Burl steals the show
MoonsofJupiter3 June 2002
What a little pearl of a movie! No smut, no foul language, no violence...just good clean shenanigans. They don't make them like this any more, and it's a shame. Haley Mills is as sweet and feisty as can be, and all the supporting players do good jobs. But for me the real star of the movie is Burl Ives. His down-home folksiness is just perfect for the role of the good-hearted Osh. His singing is timeless. Seeing this movie makes me want to fire up the time machine.
18 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Typical Entertainment from Vintage Disney Catalogue still a winner in Family Entertainment
movieman-20015 June 2005
Warning: Spoilers
Summer Magic is Disney's somewhat dated 1963 semi-musical, semi-melodramatic fantasy. It is a showcase for two talents: the iconic British water sprite, Hayley Mills (Nancy Carey) and the kindly folk singer with a heart, Burl Ives (Mr. Poppem). Nancy's family moves from Boston to New England after their much beloved patriarch dies. Precocious and determined, Nancy manages to convince Mr. Poppem to rent her family a modest but stately home for $60 a year – where can I get one of those? But the family's idyllic existence is soon threatened when an absentee landlord discovers this rental agreement. Tension also mounts after Nancy's cousin, the priggish Julia (Deborah Walley) arrives with preconceived notions of her own. These culminate in an inadvertently painful little scene where Julia and Nancy discuss how to accentuate femininity for the benefit of making a man happy, while concealing and/or sacrificing one's own feelings for 'his' ultimate soul of happiness – oh please! Eventually Nancy learns to live with Julia's prattling and Julia gets a clue to become Nancy's best friend.

Resident Disney song writers, Richard M. Sherman and Robert B. Sherman penned the charming "Summer Magic", "Lavender Blue, Dilly-Dilly" and the corny "The Ugly Bug Ball," with incomparable rag time nostalgia brimming from every note. The direction by James Neilson is adroit and easy on the mind. But on this occasion, the poignancy one is likely to derive comes entirely from seeing the young Haley Mills and elderly Burl Ives, emphatically and musically sparing off of one another's formidable talents, and leaving us all a little bit better for their joust.

Summer Magic has been remastered on DVD with considerably good results. The image is very clean, crisp and smartly rendered. Colors are rich, vibrant and bold. Blacks are deep and solid. Whites are generally white. Only occasionally does film grain hint around the edges. Certain matte shots belie their faux reality on larger monitors. Overall, the picture will surely not disappoint. The audio is another consideration all together. Apart from the songs, which have been lovingly remastered, dialogue on the whole sounds more than strident and completely unnatural. The songs thus appear almost independent in their spread and sonic resonance – offering one a sort of stereo concern buried under a mono melodrama.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A bit twee but still watchable
Leofwine_draca24 February 2015
SUMMER MAGIC is a sickly sweet Disney vehicle designed around blonde starlet Hayley Mills, fresh from the success of THE PARENT TRAP. The plot sees three spoilt city kids moving to the countryside, where they must adapt to rural life.

This is twee indeed and the heartwarming messages certainly weren't appreciated by this viewer! Indeed, Disney is so fond of thrusting 'life lessons' down the throats of its child audience that I generally avoid their movies like the plague. Still, it could be much worse: SUMMER MAGIC is colourful, has some funny scenes, a lovable animal, and Mills actually displays some traces of acting talent here and there. However, by far the best thing about the movie is Burl Ives, a larger-than-life actor playing a larger-than-life character, and his rendition of the 'Ugly Bug Ball' is a real hoot.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Better than today's So-Called family films
spikeundead28 February 2001
This and other films such as "The Three Lives of Thomasina" are shining examples of why Disney's classics are always ten times better than the mindless live-action kiddie dribble that even the Disney companies make today. "Summer Magic" is a fun and pleasant film about two teenaged cousin girls and their amusing rivalry after they both move to the country with their family. One is a care-free country girl and the other is a prompt and prissy city gal. It's fun to see these two ladies come-of-age in all aspects from having to share a room to throwing a party just to get to know the handsome new school teacher (the story is also a lot more interesting to watch than most of today's teen flicks). Hayley Mills is of course the highlight of the film stealing every scene that she's in, a talent she displays in several other Disney films. The rest of the cast is just as charming which makes the movie charming itself. If only Disney could go back to making movies like this instead of making more Mighty Ducks sequels.
20 out of 21 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
1963, it's safe to say, wasn't Disney's strongest year for live-action
r96sk17 July 2020
Another one to put in the 'meh' category of live-action Disney.

'Summer Magic' isn't entertaining. You have Hayley Mills (Nancy), Burl Ives (Osh) and Dorothy McGuire (Margaret) all giving alright performances but most others things in this film are very plain.

The musical numbers are forgettable, as is the overall premise and supporting cast under Mills, Ives and McGuire. I have most definitely seen worse from the studio, this is still at least watchable. Going back to the plot, it just feels a bit slapped together without much thought or solid connection. The film ends quite abruptly, too.

1963, it's safe to say, wasn't Disney's strongest year for live-action. This adds to the disappointments of 'Son of Flubber', 'Miracle of the White Stallions' and 'Savage Sam'. Here's hoping 'The Incredible Journey' will conclude their releases from these twelve months on a high.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Family Fun - Disney Style
alineroberts15 January 2005
Excellent movie, if you liked Hayley Mills in PollyAnna, look no further. This movie exhibits family values and basic human kindness amid the traditional Disney music and humor. There's nothing wrong with some simplicity and optimism. Today we can use them. Burl Ives and Dorothy McGuire are absolutely wonderful. The story is endearing and the life lessons are timeless. This is a classic. Many thanks to the Hallmark Channel for bringing it to us. I don't recall seeing it when I was growing up, but at 45, its never to late to enjoy vintage Disney. Maybe today's Disney execs should review their history for future successes. I highly recommend it.
18 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
This being a Disney comedy of the '60s, naturally there's a turn-of-the-century hot-rodder--named Digby!
moonspinner555 May 2001
As the 1960s progressed, the Disney company got more and more desperate for a hipness factor in their family comedies, bringing in modern artifices to jazz up their relics (here it's Michael J. Pollard playing a hot-rodder). Considering everything else is so archaic, Pollard's appearance is rather odd...the presence of Burl Ives alone should tell you what you're in for. Advertised as a vehicle for sixteen-year-old Hayley Mills, the movie is actually an ensemble piece set during the ragtime era, and the cumbersome outfits and hairdos Hayley wears fail to suit her well; still youthful and spirited, she's heavier here and doesn't have much of a character to work with. Dorothy McGuire glows on cue as the (rather mature) widowed mother of three youngsters forced to move from Boston to a hick-town in Maine. Some of this is pleasant and it's all quite well-scrubbed (featuring yet another Shaggy Dog, and two nature-montages which aren't so much misplaced as they are artistically suspect). Definitely not the best place for one to introduce themselves to Hayley Mills' versatile talents, but as a corny Disney pic for the family it isn't too bad. ** from ****
6 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
In defense of girl movies
snkers3427 October 2002
Men, you will not like the same films that we girls do. Accept that before you accept my critique of Summer Magic.

I have always loved this movie. I love the innocence of the Carey family. I love the stinging rivalry between our heroine, Nancy, and her uppity cousin. I love how different it is from our own time- "be demure, sweet and pure, hide the real you!" Oh yeah, and Hayley Mills is my hero! I watched everything I could of hers, even Pollyanna!

Summer Magic was an old movie when I first saw it, in the 80s. Technology changes, as do the public's taste in films. No amount of pyrotechnics or weapon-play could save Summer Magic for the typical male of today. It's a movie about relationships, familial love, and unquenchable optimism.

I expect no complaints from the gentlemen who disregard my caveats!
31 out of 42 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
It has its fans, but.....
hitchcockthelegend25 May 2010
Widow Dorothy McGuire has to grab her three kids and leave their neat home for a dilapidated house in Maine. Cue songs and eight hundred weight of syrup as Hayley Mills, Burl Ives and co work out this Disney adaptation of Kate Douglas Wiggin's novel Mother Carey's Chickens. Yes a family film that is as safe as the house that Dottie and brood do up, yes I understand it's a kids film, and a musical to boot. But the screenplay from Sally Benson is as dull as dishwater and the cast are way too animated. Particularly Disney's safe card, Miss Mills. The songs from Robert and Richard Sherman are barely memorable, except for the Ives warbled Ugly Bug Ball. While the Technicolor looks off and not in keeping with the Disney stamp of quality.

Harmless is fine, most musicals are just that. But there's a ream of far better harmless musicals than this one. Certainly ones that involve the audience all the way thru the running time. Whatever the age and sex of the viewer may be. 3/10
6 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
The Pink of Perfection? Not Quite, But...
laffinsal8 April 2004
I have fond memories of watching this movie on TV when I was about 7 years old. Looking back on it now, it's pretty typical Disney family-fare from the early 60s. Hayley Mills is cute, as usual, as the older sister in the Carey family. Eddie Hodges is not bad either as her brother. Burl Ives is enjoyable. His "Ugly Bug Ball" sequence with little Jimmy Mathers is cute, corny and memorable. Deborah Walley is fun as cousin Julia, and it's fun to see her and Mills irritating each other. There are some cute songs in here, by the Sherman brothers, but you have to wonder what they were thinking when they wrote them. In addition to the aforementioned "Ugly Bug Ball", we have two of the oddest inclusions in the Disney catalog: "Femininity" (where Walley and Mills teach Wendy Turner how to act like a woman!) and "The Pink of Perfection" (Mills' and Hodges' duet, in reference to Walley's snooty character).

Harmless, good, clean fun for the most part, but not in the same league as "Mary Poppins".
12 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Fun for family bonding
vonnablady18 March 2008
This movie (based on a book called Mother Carey's Chickens) is for anyone who spent their Sunday nights watching The Wonderful World of Disney while growing up and wants to share that same feeling with their own children. Turn on the closed caption, gather up your little girls and sing along with the movie.

The Carey family is saved from having to live in "a hovel...that's not in a very nice neighborhood, either" by a mysterious "Mr. Hamilton" via the town postmaster/constable/general store owner Osiam Poppham. The eldest daughter Nancy's (Hayley Mills) boundless enthusiasm and interaction with a fun assortment of characters such as a homeless cousin that "Thinks she's the pink of perfection" to Mrs. Poppham (Una Merkle-whom Hayley Mills fans will recognize from the original Parent Trap movie) who believes in a "good solid black cloud with no silver linings"
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Utterly Charming
PrettyPuyol30 April 2003
This is one of the little known Disney films, yet it's rife with the same charm and lovability that many of Disney's other films are. It's set in a quaint little town in Maine where a widow and her three children go to live after they lose their house in Boston due to bad investment advice from a relative. City folk meet country folk with a spoiled brat coming to live with them and a scheming daughter whose heart is in the right place. This is definitely a feel good film with catchy tunes and my favorite part, Tom Hamilton, who I wish they showed more of. Anyway, I highly recommend this film for people who are looking for films for their children or for anyone who loves classic Disney films. This film is hard to find I've found, but it's definitely worth the effort!
12 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Even Hayley's Mother Didn't Like This
grypnhmr3 April 2022
This is one of Hayley Mills's sorriest movies. It reeks of phony nostalgia. Worst of all, it has no plot. What is the point of this movie other than to stupefy the audience into longing for "good ol' days" that never existed? Hayley's mother, Mary Hayley Bell, wrote a scathing letter to Walt Disney about this film. She thought her daughter deserved better, and she did. I will say Michael J. Pollard put in a good effort, which is admirable. Burl Ives was creepy, as usual.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
They Don't Make Decent Family Fare Like This Today!
soblessed19 December 2005
I was searching for decent movies for my 3yr. old granddaughter,when I came upon this,and I am so glad that I did. I remembered it and it was such a delight seeing it again when I watched with her. She loved it,and especially the Burl Ives part singing"Ugly Bug Ball". Who wouldn't love that? The whole movie,is fun,entertaining and totally "non-objectionable",which would take a miracle to say that about a film made today! I would not let small children watch and learn the monstrous behavior of the hateful,smart-mouth brats that are in today's films! I thank God so much that old classics like this are available on VHS/DVD so I do not have "settle" for the worthless, valueless, garbage that makes up most of the majority of today's films. Turner Classic Movies makes up the majority of my own film-watching,and I am delighted to see via Forums how many young folks feel the same way,about the offerings of TV/films today. Anyone looking for a delightful film that the whole family can sit down and watch together without having to worry about embarrassing/offensive scenes or language,here is a perfect choice. Wonderful family values lessons as well. How easy is it to find those in a film made today?
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
3/10
Not one of the good ones ....
ducdebrabant2 April 2005
This movie bored me when I was ten and it was new, and a second viewing doesn't improve it much. Oh, it's nice to see Una Merkel through adult eyes, knowing who she is, and the movie has a certain curiosity value as an example of Disney's early 1960's film-making. The fruit basket art direction, the mickey-mousy accompanying score, the sophomoric comedy, all are in place. There's an English sheepdog (same one they used in THE SHAGGY DOG?).

But it's no POLLYANNA (which holds up), and its arch and rambling story -- and the unrewarding conceit of all those mediocre Richard and Robert Sherman songs that characters are always bursting into -- undermine the talents of some reasonably talented people. Hayley Mills is visibly tired of parts like this, and poor Dorothy McGuire -- unflatteringly coiffed but beatific as always -- has to open her mouth so some other lady can dub in the superfluous title song. There's no necessity, what is more, for the likes of Eddie Hodges or Deborah Walley in any movie whatsoever. Walley is an annoying actress playing a character who's suppose to annoy us. The result is exponentially irksome.

This is based on the book MOTHER CAREY'S CHICKENS which Bette Davis went on suspension at Warner Brothers rather than do (they don't credit that book by title in the credits, and no wonder). But really, what is the point of a movie about Bostonians adapting to life in the country when Boston looks like a back lot, rural Maine looks like a back lot, and it all basically takes place in that don't-confuse-this-with-reality Disney world? It was perfectly all right for the island in SWISS FAMILY ROBINSON to look like a ride at Disneyland, because the whole thing WAS a ride at Disneyland (even the original novel).

The nadir may be the time when Burl Ives sings a song called "The Ugly Bug Ball" with nature footage spliced in, all manipulated so that real insects seem to be dancing and playing themselves as orchestral instruments. If a ballet company came to visit this little Maine town and did a performance in tutus in the town square, or if war broke out in Cuba and Michael J. Pollard came home with a medal to be greeted by Sousa and his band, I swear you wouldn't be one bit surprised.

This is the time when Hayley is experiencing her Spring's Awakening, and it's always interesting to see what sort of boy flesh they find as a love interest for her. In IN SEARCH OF THE CASTAWAYS it was Michael Anderson Jr. Here it's (you think at first) sexy James Stacy. Again, through adult eyes, it's strange to see the tragic Mr. Stacy at this age, being the ripe forbidden fruit and future hot bet. The guy she ends up with (sort of; he doesn't kiss her or anything) is professional beauty Peter Brown. But the movie is tiring, slow going, and it took all of my critical distance and personal nostalgia to get me through it.
4 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
remake... musical, love, romance and fun
missylove29 October 2003
This movie is a remake of a movie called Mother Carey's Chickens (1938) Anne Shirley as Nancy Carey, Ruby Keeler as Kitty Carey, James Ellison as Ralph Thurston, Fay Bainter as Mrs. Carey, Walter Brennan as Mr. Popham, and Donnie Dunagan as Peter Carey.

Both are really good family movies. Summer Magic is more on the musical end and Mother Carey's Chickens is more of the romance side. Both have a lot of love, kindness and care one for another.
15 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
my favorite movie ever
jmhv41721 December 2006
I absolutely love this movie. I saw it for the first time when I was about 5 or 6 and I am 27 now. It has some great songs and it is quite funny in some parts. Kids will especially love "The Ugly Bug Ball." It is entertaining enough to keep adults interested, but not too adult for young children. There are lots of actors that appear in other Disney movies from the same era, so most of the people are pretty recognizable. My husband is not a big fan of most "kid's" movies, but he really enjoyed Summer Magic when I made him watch it. I highly recommend this movie to anyone that likes old Disney movies or has children.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A delightful charmer
faith-stencel17 November 2005
My sister and I discovered this movie at least 20 years ago, and fell in love with it instantly. It is just utterly delightful. Hayley Mills plays the oldest daughter of a newly impoverished family that moves to an old yellow house in Maine. Dorothy McGuire plays the widowed mother; Burl Ives is at his incomparable best in the role of Osh Popham, the town's general factotum married to what has to be the gloomiest woman in the state of Maine, if not the United States. Based on the book "Mother Carey's Chickens," by Kate Douglas Wiggin, the story was well adapted for the screen, maintaining the integrity and heart of the novel while making the cast a little more manageable. This truly is a feel good movie that you'll want to add to your collection.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
I like what it tries to be but not what it is
jfgibson737 June 2015
I wanted to watch this movie because I had read that Walt Disney had said it reminded him of his childhood. One of my favorite parts of the the Disney World Resort is Main Street U.S.A., and I also read that this movie had some connection to what they tried to create in the park. The story is about a widower who moves from Boston to a small rural town with her three children. They fix up a big yellow house and adapt to country life. My family enjoys Little House on the Prarie and Pollyana, and we thought this would be along those lines. As we watched Summer Magic, we became increasingly mystified. Rather than progressing through a linear narrative, this movie piles on things that make no sense into a larger and larger pile, like a misshapen heap of gunney sacks. Most of the songs were terrible and poorly placed. None of them added to the story. There were moments when it felt like the movie might work, and some sequences were enjoyable as separate vignettes, but we ended up turning it off before it was finished. I watched the rest of it myself later and didn't care about any of it. I would have liked a better story and characters I could care about.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Summer Magic
sheila-hall6021 November 2006
I have just watched Summer Magic again,it has been many years since I first saw the film. I enjoyed the film when it first came out and I still enjoyed it again today. It was one of those enjoyable films with a story and sheer entertainment, no swearing and a delight to watch. Great names like Burl Ives, Hayley Mills, Peter Brown etc, well do I need to go on, they all made the film. I was much younger when the first came out and my friend and I thought how wonderful it would be to walk down some stairs and have the lovely Peter Brown waiting for you. As I said I was younger then, but when I saw Summer Magic again today, I still had not changed my mind about Peter Brown waiting at the bottom of the stairs for me! I would recommend this film to everyone to watch.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Entertaining at best, Unrealistic at its worst.
mark.waltz21 June 2018
Warning: Spoilers
I never once believed Hayley Mills as the daughter of Dorothy McGuire and sister of Eddie Hodges and James Mathers with her obvious British accent downing any realism of these four in the family way. While in "The Parent Trap", it worked for her uppercrust Boston girl, she also made it more subtle for her California girl who grew up in the great outdoors, not in a wealthy neighborhood. Even though the film opens up in Boston ("Time: Rag", the title says in a very clever observation), she is the only one in the family who has that accent, and while McGuire's voice is very gentle, she is obviously not British. I had a good chuckle too at Mathers' "Buster Brown Bob" (as William Frawley once described it on the "Tallulah Bankhead" "I Love Lucy" episode when he was forced to wear a wig in the play within the TV show) and his "Little Lord Fauntleroy" outfit that reminded me of the nasty little cousin in "Tom Sawyer" and would certainly set off any small town kid, whether a bully or not, to beat him up on first sight. When they arrive in the small Maine town, he is indeed attacked for looking like a girl, and wisely sneaks in with the four kids who beat him up while trying to play "King of the Hill" to get his hair cut and exchange his clothes for more a more country appropriate outfit from the understanding Burl Ives.

This version of the Sally Benson story, "Mother Carey's Chickens", is a bit different than the 1930's RKO Radio version which starred Ruby Keeler and Anne Shirley, and very Disney-fied. In fact, it is films like this that show the certain look that Disney films had, both in their set-up, themes and characterizations, that no other studio would have. The basic premise of this musical comedy piece of Americana has Mills arranging to rent a house in Maine without her mother's knowledge and convincing her to move the family there where, like the Ingalls of "Little House on the Prairie", they seem to become the moral compass of the small town, even with the arrival of a much derided snooty cousin (Deborah Walley) who upsets Mills by stealing the affections of school teacher James Stacey. The heart and soul of this film squarely is split down the middle between the always lovely McGuire, finding another summer place and getting to sing (dubbed) the title song where the editors pull away footage from her and insert documentary footage of the countryside wildlife from one of their many documentaries and the always commanding Burl Ives. Married to the seemingly shrewish Una Merkel, Ives is an overly good natured soul who would give you the shirt off his back even if it was the middle of winter. Merkel wants to tell McGuire the truth about the house, that they were not permitted to rent it, and when the real owner (a very young Peter Brown) shows up, Ives has lots of 'splainin' to do.

As usual, Ives gets to sing a couple of folk songs, one extremely corny about "the ugly bug's ball" that once again splits away to show nature doing its thing. It's ironic that I watched this in a double bill with Disney's 1956 nature documentary "The Secrets of Life" which focused highly on the insect world, and found them to be a perfect double bill together. The Sherman Brothers' score, for the most part, is second rate when compared to "Mary Poppins" and "Bednobs & Broomsticks", with one song, "Femininity", rather lively as Mills (not sounding very good here) and Walley dress up Ives' tomboyish daughter (Wendy Turner) standing out among the rest. Michael J. Pollard, as Ives' oldest son, has very little to do but declare his desire to get out of this one buggy town where the minister's name is actually Mr. Lord. The picture postcard settings are straight out of Currier and Ives and there are some adorable moments and a few genuine laughs. But it is overabundant with corn and schmaltz and sentimentality, and of course, everything wrapped up far too neatly to be believable. Still, I'll always treasure the moment when the portrait of Brown's alleged mother is unveiled and the look on the future soap actor's face as he sees whom Ives is representing as the sole surviving older member of his family.
1 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
sweet and fun
mysterygirl60922 December 2006
this movie is so cute! i've always been a big fan of haylie mills so when i saw this movie i had to get it. it's always been one of my favorites because it's just so fun and you don't have to think when you watch it. it totally takes me out of my world and pulls me into nancy carrey's (mills). the songs are catchy, the cast play their parts extremely well, and this movie easily finds a place in your top favorites. this is definitely one of haylie's best films and i'm sure you'll enjoy it. i've watched it so many times and i can quote it all the way through, but i never get bored with it. you can tell that the actors and actresses had great chemistry together.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed