Spotlight on a Murderer (1961) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
6 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Franju's Third Film
gavin694223 May 2017
When he learns his days are numbered, old count Hervé de Kéraudren decides to hide in a secret alcove and to die there, just to annoy his heirs. As a result of his body not being found the latter will have to wait for five years until they can inherit the count's money.

The actors, for the most part, are not big names and may not be recognizable to American audiences. Star Pierre Brasseur had previously appeared in Georges Franju's "Eyes Without a Face". His co-star, Pascale Audret, was less well-known in film, but happens to be the mother of Julie Dreyfus, who appeared in the Quentin Tarantino films "Kill Bill" and "Inglourious Basterds".

The marketing folks describe the plot as a delightfully playful romp through Agatha Christie territory, which is quite accurate with some nods to "Ten Little Indians", among others. Some critics have said it is a "rehash" of Christie, though this is not quite fair as the references are tongue-in-cheek. The script comes to us from the writing team of Pierre Boileau and Thomas Narcejac, of "Les Diaboliques" and "Vertigo" fame.

If you know Franju, you obviously know "Eyes Without a Face" and have probably seen "Judex". But this one might have escaped you. Indeed, reviews at the time were not favorable and it seems to have gone into obscurity. Current reviews do still warn that the characters are generally flat, and the film really earns its merits on the plot and direction rather than from any deeper message or connection. Perhaps due to Franju's posthumous reputation, "Spotlight" is viewed more favorably today than ever before (and rightly so).

The Arrow Video Blu-ray is a bit light on material, which is unfortunate because they really scooped up a great title here that would have been a nice fit for Criterion. But we do get a vintage production featurette from 1960, shot on location and including interviews with Georges Franju and actors Pascale Audret, Pierre Brasseur, Marianne Koch, Dany Saval and Jean-Louis Trintignant. An audio commentary or video essay would have been icing on the cake, but sometimes just having the cake is enough.
14 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Chateau Nuff
writers_reign11 July 2019
Warning: Spoilers
It's not a masterpiece, it's not even a great film but it is interesting and it's a film that should be seen by anyone with a serious interest in the medium. Franju, even when not firing on all cylinders is not someone to be dismissed because there will always be a germ, an element, that is worth a look, or a second or third. No one seems to have noticed the obvious flaw in the ointment: the premise - not unlike that in Laughter In Paradise - centres on an eccentric personage faced with death and desirous of making his heirs jump through hoops before getting their hands on his money. In this case the heirs cannot inherit until five years have elapsed (unless his missing corpse is located before that time-limit expires. Not only that but during those five years the deceased's large chateau must be maintained. Strangley enough ALL the heirs have nothing pressing to occupy them i.e. no lives, and are free to drop everything and put their shoulders to the wheel. Once you get past this improbability there is much to enjoy, not least atmosphere, Franju's stock in trade.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
A decidedly minor affair
MOscarbradley13 January 2018
Closer to Agatha Christie than to Boileau-Narcejac who wrote the original story and collaborated with Franju on the screenplay, "Spotlight on a Murderer" is a decidedly minor affair, entertaining for what it is but unlikely to set the cinematic world on fire. For starters, it's got a fairly ridiculous plot, (even Christie would have balked at this one); an old count, about to die, hides himself away in a secret room in his chateau so that his relatives won't find his body and will have to wait 5 years for their inheritance. Naturally the corpses soon start piling up. Poiret or Miss Marple would have sorted it out in no time.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Sound and light
dbdumonteil4 March 2006
Georges Franju's best works remain his earlier ones:his shorts ("le Sang des bêtes)and his two first efforts "la Tête contre les Murs" and "Les Yeux sans Visage" (the latter's influence was considerable ,notably on Amenabar's "abre los ojos"(and " Vanilla Sky", its mediocre remake ).

"Pleins Feux sur l'Assassin" is "eyes without a face"' s follow -up.As you do not change a winning team,Boileau-Narcejac (even if their names are not widely known,everyone knows "Diabolique" and "Vertigo" ,both in the IMDb top 250, which were initially their novels) who adapted Jean Redon's novel in Franju 's precedent effort,wrote here the screenplay which is an original and which was never released ,to my knowledge ,as a novel.

It's moderately successful: Boileau-Narcejac ,as they did in "D'Entre les Morts" ("Vertigo") ,tried to mix thriller and supernatural .PLus Agatha Christie's whodunit.

An aristocrat dies but his heirs do not know where his body is .(but the viewer does, for the first minutes -Pierre Brasseur's short silent part- shows the old man dying).And ,which is worse,they cannot inherit ,because the body must be found ,or they would have to wait several years.In order to maintain their relative's desirable property,they set a Son et Lumière show up,based on an old legend from the Middle Ages: two lovers were caught in the act by the woman's husband and tragically died.(something like the old folk song "Matty Groves")

But it seems that someone is slowly doing away with the heirs ,and the culprit might be one of them.And the legend of long ago could repeat itself.

It is entertaining but it's a far cry from "les Yeux sans Visage". Franju was not to reach such heights afterward:his remake of Feuillade's "Judex" had its moments and both "Thomas L'Imposteur "and "Thérèse Desqueyroux" were estimable works which owed a lot to thespian Emmanuelle Riva.

Franju could have become the French Roman Polanski.
14 out of 16 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Passable Murder Mystery Helped Greatly By Fine Cast
gerrythree10 June 2017
Warning: Spoilers
"Spotlight On A Murderer" is a second rate detective story with a first rate French cast. The story deals with a count whose only asset seems to be his massive stone castle. Top billed Pierre Brasseur plays the count and he has a hit and run part, appearing for a total of maybe three minutes and not doing much besides taking a seat in a concealed room and dying.

For me, the big plus of this movie is Dany Saval's performance as the girlfriend of one of the potential heirs of the count. She has a real personality. Maurice Jarre composed the music for this movie and the score is blah, no match to his score for 1964's "Weekend at Dunkirk". Jarre later married Saval, in 1965 and, when they split two years later, he gave her the rights to his movie score for "Doctor Zhivago" as a divorce settlement. A great deal for her.

As to this movie, I watched the Arrow Blu-ray disc of the movie, a Gaumont restoration that has excellent image quality. At the end, when the killer is on the run across across the castle grounds, Edwige (Marianne Koch) tells Saval's movie boyfriend to shoot the killer in the leg. A shot through a high tower window to a moving target at least 150 feet away using a smooth bore single shot antique pistol. With a crowd of visitors to the castle next to the target. Naturally, the shot hits the killer in the leg.

If your time is limited, try to see "Weekend At Dunkirk" instead of this run of the mill mystery. Maurice Jarre's score for that movie is great and director Henri Verneuil was on a roll in the 1960s directing movies, hitting his peak with 1969's "The Sicilian Clan".
5 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
delightful and playful feel of this charming feature
christopher-underwood1 February 2021
Considering this is Georges Franju's third feature, coming only a year after Eyes Without a Face and with a script by Pierre Boileau and Thomas Narcejac of Les Diaboliques and Vertigo fame, this is a surprisingly slight film. But there is mystery, charm and wonder throughout, helped enormously by the fantastic Breton castle setting. It is the soundtrack that quickly alerts the viewer to a musical box element of magic that will fun through the film that is at once dramatic with several deaths and slightly comedic at the same time. There is a charming on set featurette included on the Arrow Blu-ray disc that has the various cast members smiling and laughing, even Jean Louis Trintignant, and seems to epitomise the delightful and playful feel of this charming feature.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed