Stronghold (1951) Poster

(1951)

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Reviving An Old Practice
bkoganbing4 June 2011
During the early sound era in Hollywood several studios filmed simultaneous versions of their better films for a foothold in another language market. The practice was discontinued after about five years. Stronghold from the minor Lippert studios revived that practice with Veronica Lake in the lead in Stronghold and Mexican film star Sarita Montiel in Furia Rosa which was the same film. The practice was not revived after this film.

Stronghold has Veronica Lake as a southern sympathizing woman who has come to Mexico with her Mexican national mother after losing a brother during the Civil War. Foolish people think they'll forget their troubles in Mexico which is having its own Civil War between Maximilian and Carlotta and Benito Juarez and his supporters. But even before they're put ashore the women are kidnapped and used for ransom by the Juaristas to get silver from Lake's cousin Zachary Scott who is the local bigshot and Maximilian supporter.

What I found interesting about this film is that in America Maximilian and Carlotta are treated somewhat even handedly being presented as naive people taken in by the false promises of support from Napoleon III. But in a Mexican production which this Lippert film essentially is, the Austrian pair are the worst kinds of villains. Carlotta here is one evil woman and no doubt her flight into insanity would be applauded in a Mexican film before a Mexican audience.

Veronica Lake walked away from her contract with Paramount and this Lippert film was the best thing she could get three years away from the White Mountain studio. She's not bad in it and Zachary Scott is his usual sleazy villain and ruthless one at that. But this did not revive her career on the big screen. Lake did some television was off the big screen for 14 years until she made three more big screen efforts that added no luster.

Scott in order to capture DeCordova flooded his own mine and drowned several people. The flood scene was nicely staged something in special effects you would not normally get from a poverty row studio.

Stronghold is not a bad film, might have been better if a major studio had done it.
6 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Stronghold & Furia Roja: Two different versions
whatsupomar22 October 2003
The previous commentary might lead people to erroneously believe that both Veronica Lake and Sarita Montiel appear in "Stronghold." Actually Miss Lake appears in the English version only (Stronghold) while Sarita Montiel substitutes her -playing the same part- in the Spanish version whose title is "Furia Roja." There are other casting differences -check entry for "Furia Roja."

Also it is interesting to note the differences in the final edits of both films. The Mexican version has a scene at the beginning which shows the leading lady (Sarita Montiel) still trying to defend her destroyed U.S. Southern plantation while her father's dead body is laid out at a chapel surrounded by slaves. Her brother,(Gustavo Rojo) who is fighting for the North, shows up to check on his family and she almost shoots him since he is wearing the enemy uniform. After the initial confusion, the lady informs her brother that she and their mother (Fanny Schiller) would be moving to their property in Mexico "to forget the horrors of the war and find peace."

The English version starts with both mother and daughter (in this case Veronica Lake and Fanny Schiller) in a vessel arriving in Mexico. My opinion is that the Mexican version is more complete and coherent.
11 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Historical, yes. An epic, no.
mark.waltz23 September 2022
Warning: Spoilers
This isn't the fiasco that I read about this in research. Certainly, a film about the Mexican revolution starring Veronica Lake should bring up some chuckles, but that would only have been the case had she been playing Empress Carlotta. Instead, she's playing an American woman, the daughter of a Mexican born business woman who married a white man and moved to the United States, leaving her mines in what she believed to be safe hands.

With both American countries involved in revolutions or civil wars, Lake and her mother (Fanny Schiller) choose to go to Mexico where they find protection from rebel Zachary Scott who is a Juarez supporter. Ultimately a swordfight in the mines between Scott and his rival for Lake (Arturo de Córdova) culminates in a more dangerous situation for Lake and her mother.

Comic relief is provided by Alfonso Bedoya as a bandit who really isn't a bandit, just Scott's buffoon sidekick. Lake and her mother learn the real reason why there is a revolution on in the first place, and have to deal with the natural disaster of a flood while trying to find out the truth about what's really going on behind the scenes. Pretty lavish for a Lippert film, and entertaining if a bit lacking in historical fact.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A rare gem
politian9 October 2005
Set in Mexico, "Stronghold" is informed by a sense of history and an original screenplay that manages to combine the best of action movie techniques with a genuine insight into the values and mores of Mexico. Its swashbuckling sense of heroism is never dull, or preachy, yet it contains a wealth of characterization and context that make most Hollywood historical films seem dry and sterile by comparison. Perhaps it escapes cliché in part by putting a USian woman into the lead. It is her gradual education into an understanding of Mexico that is the real story beneath the guns and ambushes.

This film deserves to be much better known.
12 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Action-Emotions-Passion... and SARA MONTIEL !!!
a_pleno_sol16 April 2003
Excellent and strange western co-produced among Mexico and US that does not fall before other films of this genre directed by specialists as John Ford, Henry Hathaway, Delmer Daves or John Sturges. This film itself about enough in style to Allan Dwan or Rudolph Maté with an unmistakably Mexican flavor.

The presence of the great Spanish actress Sara Montiel and of the marvelous one Veronica Lake turn out to be very wise.

And there are, of course, all the ingredients of the western: pursuits, shots, horses, hard men and beautiful women.. Unforgettable.
8 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed