North of the Great Divide (1950) User Reviews

A Chance For Everyone

[boblipton · 7/10 · 2 August 2023]

Roy Rogers is an Indian agent sent with comic relief Gordon Jones to find out what's going on with Noble Johnson's tribe. They depend on salmon coming up the river to spawn for their livelihood, and two canneries downstream -- one Canadian, one American run by Roy Barcraft have strung nets across the river. No salmon are getting upstream. In addition, a Mountie has been killed, and Johnson is wanted for the crime. Meanwhile, Barcraft has a contract for $100,000, and is planning to burn down the Canadian cannery so he can fill it and get rich.

One of the notable aspects of the Roy Rogers movies is their tolerance, and willingness to spend a few minutes in the films explaining aspects of different cultures. Whether he's down further south dealing Mexicans or up in the Northwest dealing with indigenous culture, there's respect for other viewpoints, even if the on-screen representations skew towards stereotype rather than sociological accuracy. This one shows the Indians' dependence on the salmon, and their reverence for the chance to pursue their lives. What could be more American than that?

There are also some good songs, a couple of good stunt sequences, and second-billed Trigger, as well as Bullet the dog. Certainly, it's not a masterpiece that notably advances the art of film making, but under the direction of William Witney, and with long-time cameraman Jack Marta's practiced compositions, the willing audience gets what they hope for in an hour's entertainment. For an example of commercial art, that's good value.

North of the Great Divide

[coltras35 · 7/10 · 8 March 2022]

The Indians' salmon supply has been cut off by a crooked fish cannery across the river. Indian agent Roy Rogers comes to the rescue when an Oseka indian chief is framed for murder by the crooked cannery boss.

A pleasant time pass with Roy Rogers and Trigger coming to the rescue by helping his Indian friends who are in state of starvation due to the actions of the b-western heavies Roy Barcroft and Jack Lambert. The pace is nifty, the scenery is splendid, though it's lacking in the action department- however, there's a brutish whipping scene at the finale - but it's social and serious theme that makes this TRucolor western shine.

"The way you're operatin', you're gonna fish your way right out of business!"

[classicsoncall · 6/10 · 30 March 2022]

Roy Rogers find himself outside of his usual Western element to serve as a government Indian agent on the Canadian border. He's a friend of the local Indian tribe, and after trying to broker an agreement between a cannery owner and the natives, the plan blows up when Banning (Roy Barcroft) and his henchman Stagg (Jack Lambert) resort to murder and sabotage against a Canadian canning rival, while attempting to place the blame on the natives. It's sort of a formulaic story line for the genre but made a bit more colorful with the presence of the Indian tribe in their colorful headdress and leggings. Gordon Jones appears as Roy's sidekick in this one as he did in a number of Roy's later pictures. He's not effective as pardners like Gabby Hayes or Smiley Burnette, who earned their B Western credentials as far back as the 1930's. With relations between the Americans, Canadians and Native Americans hanging in the balance, Roy and his native friends Chief Nagura (Noble Johnson) and Tacona (Keith Richards) bring the outlaw cannery owners to justice in short order. The finale is somewhat atypical as Roy borrows a page from the Lash LaRue book of tricks and faces off against Stagg in a bullwhip showdown, right after taking out Banning on a burning barge trying to make a hasty getaway.

Roy Rogers helps the Northwest Indians in Trucolor western

[BrianDanaCamp · 9 June 2002]

NORTH OF THE GREAT DIVIDE (1950) is a late Roy Rogers Trucolor western directed by Republic action specialist William Witney. It has a fairly strong social issue at its core, which makes for a more serious Rogers entry with less comic relief and singing than usual. It also has less action than it needs, although it remains a must-see for fans of Rogers, Trucolor and pro-Indian themes.

The film is set in the Pacific Northwest near the Canadian border and deals with a tribe of Oseka Indians that suffers a loss of their food supply when Banning, a corrupt cannery owner on the U.S. side (played by Roy Barcroft), puts up traps that keep the salmon from reaching the Indian fishing waters. Rogers plays an Indian agent assigned to solve the problem and works closely with Chief Nagura (Noble Johnson) and his son, Tacona (Keith Richards). Rogers gets caught up in an international incident when a Canadian Mountie is killed and the Canadian cannery sabotaged and Nagura is charged with the crimes. Under pressure to turn Nagura over to the Mounties, Rogers goes up against Banning when he tries to get evidence of his duplicity.

It's not clear when the film is set. Everybody rides horses and carries six-shooters. The Mounties are stationed in an old log cabin fort from the frontier era. In a typically Hollywood bit of cross-cultural confusion, the Pacific Northwest Indians look and live like Plains Indians, complete with buckskin, feather headdresses and tepees, with totem poles planted incongruously about. The film mixes a good deal of Trucolor location photography (employing real Indians) with extensive studio work and bits of stock footage of cannery operations and salmon swimming upstream. The three different modes of filming don't always blend well.

Two great western heavies, Roy Barcroft as Banning and Jack Lambert as his whip-wielding henchman, Skagg, make suitably nasty villains. Penny Edwards, looking quite fetching in buckskin, is the leading lady (giving Dale Evans a break) and plays a field nurse assigned to help Roy. Unfortunately, fan fave Penny is given little to do here. The lack of a strong female presence throws the Rogers formula slightly off balance.

Famed Indian actor Iron Eyes Cody is on hand to give his blessings to the proceedings but has no real role. Top acting honors go to Noble Johnson as Nagura, seen here in his final film credit after a 35-year film career. Johnson, a black American actor (and one-time schoolmate of Lon Chaney Sr.) appeared in hundreds of Hollywood films in all kinds of ethnic roles-Egyptian, Russian, Mexican, Polynesian, South Asian, Chinese and, most frequently, American Indian. He is probably best known as the native chief on Skull Island in KING KONG (1933). Interestingly, the role of Nagura may have been the biggest speaking part in Johnson's entire career.

The Trucolor photography is not seen to best advantage in the tape available for review, the initial VHS release from NTA, the corporate predecessor of Republic Pictures Home Video. Republic has since released a new edition, which hopefully improves on the earlier release and looks as good as some of Republic's other Trucolor Roy Rogers VHS releases (e.g. THE GOLDEN STALLION, TRIGGER, JR.). Overall, this is a worthy later Rogers entry, better than some, but not as good as THE GOLDEN STALLION (1949), Rogers' near-masterpiece. It deserves note for its serious intent and social issue theme but is not as rousing or packed with humor and action as a more typical Rogers vehicle of the time.

Roy plays less a tough cowboy and more a nice do-gooder.

[planktonrules · 3/10 · 1 November 2020]

Many of the B-westerns were filmed in TruColor or Cinecolor in the 1950s. This is because it was a very inexpensive color-like process that cost about the same as black & white cinematography. True Technicolor, on the other hand was quite a bit more expensive...and B-movies were made cheaply, so you'd never see a true color look to them. So what is the down-side of TruColor and Cinecolor? Well, they weren't exactly true colors and this is because instead of being made up of three colors, they were two color processes. As a result, you got colors that were heavy on sedia-orange and greenish-blue. And, as the films degraded over time, these odd color blends usually intensified....making for a very muddy looking color film. So, as you watch, this would explain the odd look of the movie.

This later Roy Rogers film is similar to many others of the period....it's really NOT a western and features Rogers as a do-gooder and not a cowboy despite his clothing. Generally, I dislike these film, as they tend to be a bit too nice and lack an edge....and "North of the Great Divide" is no exception.

The story begins with Roy hanging out with his Native American friends. He apparently is an Indian agent for the US government. But things go from great to lousy very quickly when a new salmon cannery is built along the river. Now there isn't enough food for the locals and the newcomers have no problem depleting all the fish...all in the name of money. But these greedy folks now have decided to destroy the other cannery on the Canadian side of the border. In the process, they end up killing a Mountie...and soon the local tribesmen are blamed. Can Roy straighten all this out and stop these mad men?

Apart from seeing Roy fight a whip fight, there isn't a ton about this one to love. Gordon Jones is less a sidekick, and more an idiot. All in all, a disappointing film in most ways...and a film that relies too often on grainy stock footage.

Roy Rogers conservationist

[bkoganbing · 8/10 · 17 June 2013]

One of the best Roy Rogers later westerns is North Of The Great Divide which finds Roy as an Indian agent assigned to the Northwest territory right on the Canadian border. The later Rogers westerns had some good color cinematography, but I'd have to say that this was some of the best.

He's got himself a nice diplomatic tangle as both countries are considering conservation legislation to protect and regulate the salmon whose run in the rivers of the Northwest is the prime source of food for the Indians. Roy Barcroft and his thug enforcer Jack Lambert is building a cannery and whose traps are starving the Indians of needed food. Then to make matters worse Barcroft and Lambert burn down a cannery on the Canadian side and made it look like the Indians did it. A Mountie is also killed trying to stop the fire and the chief's son Keith Richards is held for the crime.

A little cooperation with the Canadian Mounties brings about a solution for all save the bad guys. Roy borrows from his cowboy hero rival Lash LaRue in a savage bullwhip fight with Jack Lambert in the climax. Too bad one of his fine western shirts was sacrificed for art.

Penny Edwards substitutes for Dale Evans in this film who took time away to be a Mom. And Roy gets Gordon Jones who's not Gabby Hayes or Andy Devine as a sidekick. But Jones has a certain oafish charm to him.

The fight for clean water and a decent diet for the Northwest tribes is certainly a good cause for a cowboy hero to fight for. Watching North Of The Great Divide seeing the Indians fight for their salmon put me in mind of the plains Indians and how necessary the Buffalo was to their very existence.

I don't recall that the name of the tribe was mentioned, it could have been the Tlingit, Klamath, Modoc for all I know. I'd like to think it was the Kwakiutls. When I was a little kid my father read me a children's book on Indian cultures in the various regions of the continental USA and for some reason the name Kwakiutl tickled his funnybone. He used the Kwakiutl Indians often as a punchline for something or other. It stuck with me to this day. My apologies to the Kwakiutl tribe of our Northwest.

Anyway this is a fine Roy Rogers western, one of this best.