Cardboard Cavalier (1949) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
9 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Moderately Amusing
boblipton4 January 2020
Sid "What a Performance!" Field stars as an idiot barrow boy in Cromwellian London. He gets involved with Margaret Lockwood and intrigue over efforts to get Charles II his throne.

This was the last film directed by Walter Forde, just as Sid's star-making LONDON TOWN was Wesley Ruggles' last credit as a director; perhaps Sid wore them out. The movie never seems to make up its mind whether it's a comedy with serious interludes, or a serious drama with comic sequences. Much time is spent showing the audience how miserable the Protectorate was, and it isn't until the final third until it turns into the sort of movie that, had it been made in Hollywood, would have starred Bob Hope or Danny Kaye. That's when Sid does a drag act, a Murphy bed shows up, and Irene Handl appears as a helpful ghost with a removable noggin. It all ends in chaos and confusion, and Charles II restored to the throne.

Margaret Lockwood plays the heroine, and she is far more boisterous than her usual polite "English Rose" roles, She seems to be having fun as the irrepressible Nell Gwyn, having a load of snow dumped on her, and calling His Majesty "Charlie".

Although Forde had been a leading movie director in the 1930s, working in a variety of genres, he seems to have grown tired by this point. He had just passed the half-century mark, tastes were changing, and the British film industry was in crisis, just as it had been when he had entered. Perhaps he decided it was time to bow out gracefully and enjoy retirement. If so, I certainly hope he did over the next thirty-five years. He died in 1984, aged 85. Field was not as fortunate. After thirty years in the music halls, he finally hit the West End in the early 1940s and made three movies, with this the last one. He died the following year, only 45 years of age.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
The Cavalier years.
morrison-dylan-fan27 January 2022
Warning: Spoilers
After seeing the superb The Outer Limits episode The Architects of Fear, I took a look at what movies have recently appeared on Talking Pictures free online catch-up site, and discovered a rather obscure Comedy, leading to me going back to the Cavalier years.

View on the film:

Later writing in her memoirs that for all who worked on the title that "We had a romp of a time with Sid Field.", Margaret Lockwood (who replaced the originally cast Pat Roc ) happiness working on the project is visible to see in her cheerful performance as Gwynne, which does lean on the broad side of facial expressions, while in his last movie, (he sadly died just 5 months after filming) Sid Field jumps round the screen in a Slap-Stick turn as Buttermeadow.

Made as part of an ambitious run by the studio to increase film productions in order to meet the introduction of the British movie quota, (a decision that the studio ended up losing money on) the screenplay by Noel Langley (who co-wrote the script for 1939's The Wizard of Oz) plays on a peculiar see-saw, which half the time goes up with playful satirical gags on rationing and Cromwell, (here shown warts and all) and goes down with over-extended broad farce set-pieces, as Buttermeadow becomes a cardboard Cavalier.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
A comical treatment of Cromwell hstory
SimonJack29 April 2023
The British turned out many historical films, including those based on classical novels. And, U. K. filmmakers made some sterling comedies, some of which could rival the best of the Hollywood Golden Era. But I don't recall there being many historical comedies until later in the 20th century. Well, "Cardboard Cavalier" of 1949 is an exception and clearly has some fun with history, including quite a bit of twisting it.

Overall, this film isn't exceptional or very good. But, it is light-hearted, has a silly and sometime far out plot, and it does have some nice shots of humor here and there. Those are almost always around Sid Field's character, Sidcup Buttermeadow. Indeed, except for the obvious historical figures, the choice of names for the fictional people is part of the British humor that I especially appreciate in such films. Some others, beside Field's character are Judge Gorebucket by Miles Malleson, Brother Barebones by Michael Brennan, Sylvester Clutterbuck by Claude Hulbert, and Mosspot by Peter Bull.

Well this whole thing takes place during that nagging interruption of the regal reigns of England - of whatever branch of monarchy, It was during the English civil wars and George Cromwell's reign of the md 17th century. Buttermeadow becomes a courier for the loyalists to the king, and in the end, he's celebrated for helping the cause for King Charles's return. A humorous bit that historians and anglophiles especially should enjoy, is the inclusion of the legendary Nell Gwynn. Margaret Lockwood plays the most famous of a baker's dozen of mistresses of Charles. But in this film, she's admired by the throngs as the actress and consort of Charles, even riding in the parade of the king's return.

This isn't a great laugh fest for viewers, but a pleasant and fun film to watch as the cast (and crew) poke friendly jabs at history. This was one of only two films that the very popular stage show entertainer Sid Field made. That earned it one more star from me.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Field and Lockwood combine to end Fordes career
malcolmgsw3 January 2020
Sid Field only made three,largely unsuccessful films.Forde made hundreds.Their career paths crossed with this film and was in both cases brought to an end.Field was largely a physical comedian and it really comes across as if he is trying too hard.The cinema was clearly not his medium.As for Lockwood,well the most charitable thing to say is that comedy roles do not suit her.After the film flopped Forde retired,which says it all.
3 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Field and Lockwood's Cromwellian comedy
wilvram4 November 2014
A funny and fast-moving comedy, with hapless market-trader Sidcup (Sid Field) falling foul of Cromwell's thuggish soldiery, teaming up with Nell Gwynne (Margaret Lockwood) then running messages for a Royalist infiltrator, played by Field's straight-man Jerry Desmonde. It all ends with a chase in a castle, with Sidcup aided by a friendly ghost (Irene Handl).

Early on, Sidcup's barrow with 'ye private enterprise' prominently marked on the side, is overturned by one of Cromwell's officers and the film is, at least in part, a mild send-up of the Attlee government's retention of some wartime regulations and other controls, increasingly unpopular in 1948. Some imaginatively droll character names include Judge Gorebucket, Murdercasket and Mosspot, the latter played by Peter Bull. IMDb lists the narrator at the start as John Snagge, but he sounds to me more like Hugh Sinclair.

Field's work on stage was highly regarded; he was an inspiration for Frankie Howerd and particularly Tony Hancock, and would surely have been a great success on TV, but sadly died at just 45. No doubt he wasn't stretched by the material here, but is still funny and likable. The revelation is Margaret Lockwood, then Britain's most popular star, who put herself forward for the part as a great admirer of Field, and hopefully to escape the 'Wicked Lady' image, even though it meant second billing. She gives a sparkling performance and is ideal in the role, but typically, the British press, having once helped to build her reputation, now decided that she needed taking down a peg or two, with several notices being hostile and occasionally downright spiteful. Never over-blessed with self-confidence, she didn't attempt a similar role again.
9 out of 10 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Very funny, I wish I'd seen this long ago.
robert_dyball26 May 2000
This is funny, clean, and although only B/W, one of the best movies I've seen.

The main character, Sid Field plays "Sidcup Buttermeadow", who honestly couldn't find his behind with both hands. He accidentally overthrows Cromwell and his nasty cronies.

If you like the Princess Bride, and don't need gratuitous sex and violence, then see if you can find it or persuade your local TV station to.

Now if only I could find where to buy a copy on VHS/PAL...
15 out of 23 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Delightful!
JohnHowardReid3 March 2018
Warning: Spoilers
Culley Forde. Producer/director: Walter Forde.

A Two Cities Film, released in the U.K. by General Film Distributors: 9 May 1949. London trade show: 29 March 1949. Australian release through 20th Century-Fox: 27 April 1950. 96 minutes. Cut by the distributor to 7,307 feet in Australia (81 minutes).

NOTES: Final film of Sid Field who suffered a fatal heart attack at the early age of 45 on 3 February 1950. Although he made only three films, Field was extremely popular on both the legitimate stage (he was the star of the West End production of Harvey when he died) and variety. However, as he himself observed, success didn't come easy: "It took me thirty years to become an overnight star!"

COMMENT: Why this amusingly irreverent historical pastiche is so little known among comedy connoisseurs is something of a mystery. True, the latter part of the movie seems not as consistently amusing as the first and the sudden introduction of a supernatural element proves a little disconcerting. But Fields rates as such an ingratiating comedian - never lapsing into awkward and embarrassing sentimentality, and never indulging in routines that are blatantly self-promoting, like some other "comics" I could name! Furthermore, he acts his part with such relish and enthusiasm he carries us with him over any momentary weaknesses or pitfalls in Noel Langley's otherwise highly entertaining screenplay.

Production values are remarkably lavish. Margaret Lockwood makes a delightful heroine and director Walter Forde, as usual, displays considerable skill.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Hilarious but misleading.
ben-gosling194424 August 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Great, hilarious slapstick with lots of laughs for all ages. However, it's a slander against poor old Cromwell, who enjoyed wine and dancing, and also appreciated the fine arts. He also granted religious freedom and stopped the fines for not attending church. I don't think the Commonwealth was quite as Nazified as is shown here!
3 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A gentleman's guide to love and treason.
mark.waltz6 July 2022
Warning: Spoilers
As funny as the same year's "Kind Hearts and Coronets", this British farce is a complete delight, dealing with the antics of Nell Gwynn (Margaret Lockwood) during the time that Oliver Cromwell intercepted power over Charles II and Gwynn became more than just a lady in waiting. She goes from the courts after a charge of public brawling (giving a peddling street harridan a taste of her own medicine after having custard tossed in her face) to aiding "Sidcup Buttermeadow" (Sid Field) get to where King Charles is being held, helping him disguise himself in drag, then encountering a ghost in the castle. That leads to a ton of hilarity and nothing resembling history.

It's easy to see why this may not have been a hit in its time as it was probably too frenetic for most audiences who preferred their comedy to be more verbal than physical, at least on film. The comedy here resembles more what viewers would expect to see on stage. I could almost see this as a musical! It's almost too much of a good thing with Lockwood cast against type since most audiences would either expect her to be either a great lady or a wicked lady but not a funny lady. She also looks quite different with Nell Gwynn's lighter hair, and some viewers may not even recognize her. Great production design and fantastic direction by Wesley Ruggles, more known for his American films.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed