Another great performance by Nigel Patrick is the highlight of this Post-war British 'Spiv' movie (British crime films with roots in the Hollywood gangster cycle of the 30s, but with far less glamorisation of the criminal protagonists - see also DANCING WITH CRIME, NO WAY BACK and NOOSE, with the latter similarly boasting a superior Nigel Patrick 'Spiv' performance). In this one he plays Simon Rawley, the son of a blind self-made country squire who, believed dead and due to be publicly honoured in a grand memorial service by his doting father, fetches up one night at the family home and is revealed to be a cowardly deserter now plying his trade as a criminal. Rawley demands money, initially to go away but subsequently, upon discovering that his wife has found love in the arms of the doctor son of the neighboring Lord of the manor, seizes the opportunity for blackmail. With his stepmother and wife attempting to keep his return secret from his unknowing father, and with the local police searching the countryside for him (he has earlier assaulted a motorist and stolen the man's car), the scene is set for a tense and unlikely family reunion. Directed by the prolific Lance Comfort, this is a tightly knit, sprightly told crime story, whose limited cast and chamber-piece dynamic tightens and heightens the mounting drama. Well-shot and staged, and featuring occasional moments of intentional humour (especially when Rawley's elaborate and fraudulent explanation for his desertion and absence is juxtaposed with images of his real activities and criminal subterfuge), the film also manages to document some interesting historical class distinctions between the moneyed nouveau-riche Rawley senior and his neighbouring Lordship as it zips its way to a satisfying (if somewhat implausible) climax. Entertaining stuff, and well worth seeking out.
9 Reviews
Silent Dust - Stylish Looking Production
krocheav8 June 2013
It was the curious title "Silent Dust" that drew me to this interesting story. Here is a film that draws on all the characteristics of well made Noir. Talented Director of Photography Wilkie Cooper has certainly worked very hard to give this film a great deal of visual vitality. This versatile D.O.P. certainly has an impressive list of titles to his credit, ranging from high Drama, Comedy, and Fantasy with such gems as: "I See A Dark Stranger" '46, "Stage Fright" '50 "Pickwick Papers" and a string of acclaimed Harryhausen classics that followed one after another...."7th Voyage of Sinbad", "Mysterious Island" "Jason and the Argonauts" the list goes on....Here, he is working with Cameraman Robert Day, who would later go on to Direct 'The Green Man' and 'Tarzan the Magnificent' (also penning the Screenplay) To help enhance their already strong creative moods, they have the talents of celebrated Art Director C.P. Norman known for: 'This Happy Breed', Night and the City, and 'Titfield Thunderbolt'. Little wonder then, with Director Lance Comfort (Hatter's Castle '42) they were able to reel in such an impressive looking drama.
The Cast also impresses, beginning with beautiful Sally Gray who initially trained as a dancer with Fred Astaire. After suffering a nervous breakdown in 1941 and being off-screen for a long five years, she graduated nicely into dramatic roles. Sally resisted invitations by Hollywood and retired following marriage, 'Silent Dust' unfortunately is one of her last performances. She shines in the role of the Daughter-in-Law to blind man Stephen Murray --who brilliantly plays his part-- The Wife, played by Irish beauty Beatrice Campbell tends to be a little stilted in her delivery, the director perhaps needed to work harder here. Sadly Beatrice's career was cut short with her death at 56. The Son, who hides many dark secrets, is performed with nasty skill by Nigel Patrick. Writers Michael and Ronald Pertwee have fleshed out interesting characters for this compelling story based on their play 'The Paragon'. A near-perfect descriptive Music score by classic French composer George Auric (Moulin Rouge '52) adds the final tonal touches to this intriguing tale.
This title remains well worth catching or buying on DVD - especially the newly released Netwerk vers - while not remastered it features well transferred, clear images and sound. If you were as unfortunate as I, you may have first caught this on Gem Digital TV in Australia. This channel has much to learn about presenting classic films, their annoyingly large 'Lolly Pink' graphics appear before and after each add break, often cutting off essential image and lines of dialog ~ please, let's see a little more respect shown for your viewers and the movies. Tone down the colour and size of your overdone logos! (Seven two, get my vote and more of my viewing for this very reason) K. Roche.
The Cast also impresses, beginning with beautiful Sally Gray who initially trained as a dancer with Fred Astaire. After suffering a nervous breakdown in 1941 and being off-screen for a long five years, she graduated nicely into dramatic roles. Sally resisted invitations by Hollywood and retired following marriage, 'Silent Dust' unfortunately is one of her last performances. She shines in the role of the Daughter-in-Law to blind man Stephen Murray --who brilliantly plays his part-- The Wife, played by Irish beauty Beatrice Campbell tends to be a little stilted in her delivery, the director perhaps needed to work harder here. Sadly Beatrice's career was cut short with her death at 56. The Son, who hides many dark secrets, is performed with nasty skill by Nigel Patrick. Writers Michael and Ronald Pertwee have fleshed out interesting characters for this compelling story based on their play 'The Paragon'. A near-perfect descriptive Music score by classic French composer George Auric (Moulin Rouge '52) adds the final tonal touches to this intriguing tale.
This title remains well worth catching or buying on DVD - especially the newly released Netwerk vers - while not remastered it features well transferred, clear images and sound. If you were as unfortunate as I, you may have first caught this on Gem Digital TV in Australia. This channel has much to learn about presenting classic films, their annoyingly large 'Lolly Pink' graphics appear before and after each add break, often cutting off essential image and lines of dialog ~ please, let's see a little more respect shown for your viewers and the movies. Tone down the colour and size of your overdone logos! (Seven two, get my vote and more of my viewing for this very reason) K. Roche.
Dust to dust
AAdaSC6 May 2013
Blind, wealthy Stephen Murray (Robert Rawley) is disciplined and very matter-of-fact. He is wealthy and is the head figure of a country estate. He is organizing a memorial to his son (who was shot dead during WW2) to be unveiled when he is visited by Seymour Hicks (Lord Clandon). Hicks plays a far more sympathetic character and asks Murray to dedicate the memorial to all of the 50 or so villagers who never came back from the war, not just to his son. Murray refuses. At this point, we don't like Murray. One night, Nigel Patrick (Simon Rawley) shows up. Yep - he's the son.....and he's not been killed. He has quietly sneaked back to ask for money to make his escape as an army deserter. He hides in the house and the cast gradually become aware of his presence until he has a confrontation with his dad at the end, for which there can only be one outcome.
Stephen Murray and Nigel Patrick are the standout characters in the film. They are unpleasant people who I find quite likable, and this is due to the way that they deliver their dialogue. Blind Stephen Murray becomes more sympathetic as the film progresses as he stumbles across various anomalies in the household that he runs. Nigel Patrick is great as a lying 'spiv' - his recounting of his life story when he was supposedly on the run is very effectively told against a flashback of what actually happened - a great contrast.
I wasn't sure where the film was going for the first quarter of an hour or so, and was dreading that I had purchased a British comedy because of the comedy music used to accompany Seymour Hicks on his bicycle. Thankfully not. Things pick up with the arrival of Nigel Patrick and its a joy to watch from then on. I do wonder why they pick women that look the same - schoolboy error in the casting department - Sally Carr (Angela) and Beatrice Campbell (Joan) are thoroughly interchangeable. The best female role goes to the housekeeper Yvonne Owen (Nellie).
Overall, some great scenes, some good dialogue and a film worth seeing again.
Stephen Murray and Nigel Patrick are the standout characters in the film. They are unpleasant people who I find quite likable, and this is due to the way that they deliver their dialogue. Blind Stephen Murray becomes more sympathetic as the film progresses as he stumbles across various anomalies in the household that he runs. Nigel Patrick is great as a lying 'spiv' - his recounting of his life story when he was supposedly on the run is very effectively told against a flashback of what actually happened - a great contrast.
I wasn't sure where the film was going for the first quarter of an hour or so, and was dreading that I had purchased a British comedy because of the comedy music used to accompany Seymour Hicks on his bicycle. Thankfully not. Things pick up with the arrival of Nigel Patrick and its a joy to watch from then on. I do wonder why they pick women that look the same - schoolboy error in the casting department - Sally Carr (Angela) and Beatrice Campbell (Joan) are thoroughly interchangeable. The best female role goes to the housekeeper Yvonne Owen (Nellie).
Overall, some great scenes, some good dialogue and a film worth seeing again.
Atmospheric suspense film, Nigel Patrick excellent as usual
paxveritas23 September 2017
Prior reviewers have made very good points, so my view of the film isn't needed, but I do wish to echo admiration for the cast, tight production, fine musical score, sharp dialogue. Particularly pleasing is the wind-up scene at the end, where the legendary Seymour Hicks (please see his bio!!) gently insinuates a satisfactory way to deal with the events fallout (I don't want to give away the ending). Hicks keeps his head, thinking ahead. when the others are understandably off balance, and gives them an out. This was Hicks' last film.
Interesting to note that a couple of years after this film was made, Nigel Patrick married his stepmother in this script, Beatrice Campbell. Another fun fact is that Patrick was born in 1912, the same year Stephen Murray (who plays his father here) was born, but Murray acquires white hair for the movie, and the superb acting carries it all off.
Quiet, steady character development, but no dull spots as this story unfolds well-paced, and gains tension. Well done.
Interesting to note that a couple of years after this film was made, Nigel Patrick married his stepmother in this script, Beatrice Campbell. Another fun fact is that Patrick was born in 1912, the same year Stephen Murray (who plays his father here) was born, but Murray acquires white hair for the movie, and the superb acting carries it all off.
Quiet, steady character development, but no dull spots as this story unfolds well-paced, and gains tension. Well done.
another fine Lance Comfort
happytrigger-64-39051725 March 2019
"Silent Dust" is another brilliant noir directed by Lance Comfort about a soldier who died in WWII but comes back secretly in the family's manor house because in fact he was a deserter, Patrick Nigel is great as always playing that soldier. My favorite character is the blind father, all the scenes with him and Nigel are full of suspense and tension and enlightened with impressively sharp expressionist photography. And gripping musiac score by George Auric. I just can't wait to see another Lance Comfort, "Temptation Harbor" with the beautiful Simone Simon and Robert Newton for example?
Sally Gray - a Blonde Vision!!
kidboots13 March 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Wealthy industrialist Robert Rawley (Stephen Murray) is determined to honour his fallen son with a memorial pavilion at the county cricket club. He is visited by the local squire who implores him to make a general dedication for all the boys in the village who were lost during the war but Rawley is immovable. This all consuming passion as well as his belligerence does nothing to quell his unlikeability in the village.
Lance Comfort ended up giving bits of brilliance to the Bs he was often given but this movie showed he was a fine atmospheric thriller director. Most of the action takes place in the majestic house with dimmed staircases, balconies and shaded rooms. Once Sally Gray arrives, the sunny scenes turn distinctly noirish - she's magnificent, a blonde vision but with sultry overtones. Hollywood would have loved her. She plays Angela, wife of lost son Simon but by looks and intimation it is clear that she doesn't remember Simon in quite the same shining light as his father. Robert is also blind (I thought Beatrice Campbell was excellent as his younger, second wife - she tries so hard to persuade him to show his softer side to the village but to no avail).
Suddenly as night falls they have a visitor, just keeping inside the shadows - it is Simon and from his gestures and speech he is not a returned hero, more an opportunist spiv!! Nigel Patrick is tremendous as the bad penny son - he sets about instantly cajoling one person, then another. He has only returned for money and not for any filial affection. The scene where he is relating the hard time he has had as he stayed on the straight and narrow while the film shows him as a coward, not above picking women's purses to finance his needs, is powerful!!
Once the father realises the son has returned he starts to be humanized, he sees Simon as he really is - cruel and a bully. He also starts to soften toward the women in the family. It will take all in his power to help him through - the talk in the village as the movie opens is of a murderer on the loose - the man whom Simon coshed when stealing his car has died!!
Sally Gray did start out as an actress in her teens but a nervous breakdown kept her off the screen for years. When she returned, in the mid 1940s, she put in her strongest bid for stardom!
Very Recommended!!
Lance Comfort ended up giving bits of brilliance to the Bs he was often given but this movie showed he was a fine atmospheric thriller director. Most of the action takes place in the majestic house with dimmed staircases, balconies and shaded rooms. Once Sally Gray arrives, the sunny scenes turn distinctly noirish - she's magnificent, a blonde vision but with sultry overtones. Hollywood would have loved her. She plays Angela, wife of lost son Simon but by looks and intimation it is clear that she doesn't remember Simon in quite the same shining light as his father. Robert is also blind (I thought Beatrice Campbell was excellent as his younger, second wife - she tries so hard to persuade him to show his softer side to the village but to no avail).
Suddenly as night falls they have a visitor, just keeping inside the shadows - it is Simon and from his gestures and speech he is not a returned hero, more an opportunist spiv!! Nigel Patrick is tremendous as the bad penny son - he sets about instantly cajoling one person, then another. He has only returned for money and not for any filial affection. The scene where he is relating the hard time he has had as he stayed on the straight and narrow while the film shows him as a coward, not above picking women's purses to finance his needs, is powerful!!
Once the father realises the son has returned he starts to be humanized, he sees Simon as he really is - cruel and a bully. He also starts to soften toward the women in the family. It will take all in his power to help him through - the talk in the village as the movie opens is of a murderer on the loose - the man whom Simon coshed when stealing his car has died!!
Sally Gray did start out as an actress in her teens but a nervous breakdown kept her off the screen for years. When she returned, in the mid 1940s, she put in her strongest bid for stardom!
Very Recommended!!
Much too stagy
malcolmgsw9 July 2015
Warning: Spoilers
This is an adaption from the stage play by the Pertwees and it really feels like it.Stephen Murray is well over the top in the central role of the local blind squire who has lost his son towards the end of World war 2.However he has nt lost his son.His son was a deserter and has indulged in mayhem ever since.His supposed widow has remarried Derek Farr in blissful ignorance.However like the proverbial bad penny,the son,played by Nigel Patrick,turns up and attempts to blackmail his wife and her husband.The end when it comes it is very predictable and pure theatre.Other than that it is nice to see Irene Handel fussing about in the kitchen as usual.
Dead but not gone?
planktonrules23 February 2017
When the picture begins, a blind rich guy has been dedicating himself and his fortune to building a new cricket stadium in memory of his son, Simon, who was killed during WWII. However, there's a bit of a problem with this. Unbeknownst to the old guy, the son is very much alive and he shows up to beg for some money from his 'widow' just before the stadium is dedicated. Where was he and why was he gone? It turns out Simon was a cowardly deserter who ran away to save his butt. And, through the course of the film, it becomes apparent he's a career criminal and sociopath! He's also there to shake down his poor wife now that she has remarried! And this is all learned rather early in the film. So what is next?
Nigel Patrick is exceptional in this film as Simon. Slimy, nasty and 100% unrepentant! And, in the process he makes everyone watching the film hate him thoroughly! Stephen Murray is also excellent as Simon's father...particularly when he realizes what's afoot and confronts his wayward son. All in all, this is one terrific film and I am glad I saw it. Quite the thriller and quite the finale!!
Nigel Patrick is exceptional in this film as Simon. Slimy, nasty and 100% unrepentant! And, in the process he makes everyone watching the film hate him thoroughly! Stephen Murray is also excellent as Simon's father...particularly when he realizes what's afoot and confronts his wayward son. All in all, this is one terrific film and I am glad I saw it. Quite the thriller and quite the finale!!
the first time I've known a pair of legs grow wings...
Brucey_D8 January 2021
Warning: Spoilers
In a country slowly coming to terms with the consequences of a terrible war, it is fitting that those lost in the conflict are honoured. But not all of them were heroes and some of them are not really gone, either.
This film is surprisingly engaging and surprisingly well-made too. There practically isn't a duff bit it, and there are odd moments of humour that contrast with the main thrust of the plot and kind of add to things rather than detract from them. Nigel Patrick's louche character is well drawn here.
The overall plot is a little implausible but despite this it is a pretty good film and considering it is 70 years old now it is more engaging than you might expect.
Eight out of ten from me.
This film is surprisingly engaging and surprisingly well-made too. There practically isn't a duff bit it, and there are odd moments of humour that contrast with the main thrust of the plot and kind of add to things rather than detract from them. Nigel Patrick's louche character is well drawn here.
The overall plot is a little implausible but despite this it is a pretty good film and considering it is 70 years old now it is more engaging than you might expect.
Eight out of ten from me.
See also
Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews
