The Materassi Sisters (1944) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
We Never Get Love On Our Own Terms
boblipton29 September 2019
Emma and Irma Grammatica are two old-maid sisters. They run a successful business, making shirts, underwear and wedding dresses. The third sister, Olga Solbelli, lives upstairs and makes sarcastic comments. A fourth sister got married and moved away. Emma and Irma have just returned from a meeting with the Pope, who admires their religious embroidery, when their nephew, Massimo Serato, shows up, fleeing from his widowed father. Emma and Irma spoil him in their tight-fisted way; he is young, attractive, gets into scrape with women, and spends what he imagines he will inherit.

Director Ferdinando Maria Poggioli's movie -- he also edited it -- is about the idiosyncratic expressions of love, and how it never works out as we envision.Serato is heedless, self-centered and really turns out to care for the very people he mistreats. His youthful egotism cannot encompass the pain he brings to other, even as his own pride and delusional belief that he does not care about money, only the things that money can buy, inevitably destroy his own vision of how things should work out. His spinster aunts worry about him and hate how he treats them, but inevitably give way, even as the more worldly one resists. Yet for everyone, it is the tribulations of life that force us to live.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
entertaining gentle comedy from golden age of Italian films
seglora22 April 2016
Warning: Spoilers
This is a gentle comedy based upon a famous Italian novel written a decade earlier by Aldo Palazzeschi. It tells the story of three elderly sisters in Florence who out of compassion invite a young nephew, Remo, to stay in their house and give him everything he wishes for, which is a problem as the young man turns out to be a charming rascal who will ruin them. Two of the duped aunts are played by two acting sisters of certain fame in Italy. However, the actress from this film most known to international audiences is probably Clara Calamai, who played the leading role in a much more famous Italian film from around the same time — "Ossessione" by Visconti. Here she plays a quite different role as a sophisticated South American woman who arrives in Italy from Argentina and takes up with Remo. This is a short film, well acted and with swift tempi. It is amazing that films such as this and "Ossessione" could be produced in an Italy engulfed in the later stages of the war. There is on YouTube a long Italian television version of the novel from 1972, though without subtitles. This older and shorter version on you tube with English hardsubs deserves to be more widely known to an international public.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed