West Point Widow (1941) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
And baby makes trouble.
mark.waltz7 February 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Baby is the sweetest thing, the product of an annulled marriage between nurse Anne Shirley and West Point football hero Richard Denning. A misunderstanding at the hospital makes everybody think that the doctor is Richard Carlson, a fun loving type that genuinely loves mama Shirley. It's a complicated situation because West Point cadets aren't allowed to be married, so Shirley had the marriage annulled and had her baby in secret. Carlson's Dr. Gillespie like boss (Cecil Kellaway) becomes a father like figure to him, but the potential if scandal erupts thanks to hospital gossip.

This pleasant pre-war comedy features some great character performances, especially eccentric Maude Eburne as a landlady who hasn't washed her hair in three months because she believes that a permanent is permanent and Lillian Randolph as the nanny/cook who feeds the baby pork chops. It's obvious from the beginning who the audience will root for Shirley to pick. At only an hour, this is an absolute delight, sweet and engaging from start to finish.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Anne Shirley Shines Again
paufeuu18 July 2021
Underated Anne Shirley leads this movie with her usual charm and wit. The title does not adequately describe the premise of this story. Two young people (Anne Shirley and Richard Denning) marry. The man, a West Point cadet, can not be married as a cadet, so they agree to have the marriage annulled, via the intervention of his mother. Nancy Hill (Shirley) has a baby girl but doesn't tell her former husband, Lt. Rhody Graves (Carlson) so that he will not drop out of West Point. Meanwhile, while working in a hospital as a nurse to support their child, she meets and eventually falls for Dr. Jimmy Krueger (Richard Carlson). This is only after much effort on his part.

With a wonderful supporting cast, particularly Richard Carlson (Dr. Jimmy Krueger) as the young intern and persistent suitor and Lillian Randolph (Sophie) as the babies caregiver, Anne Shirley does not fail to shine and charm in her performance as the long-suffering wife, girlfirtend, nurse, and young mother. Ms. Shirley is one of our most underrated young actresses of Hollywood's golden era, whose career unfortunately never lived up to her vast talents. To better understand this, her performance as the Barbara Stanwycks's daughter Laurel in the movie Stella Dallas (1937), is clear proof of her amazing acting talents.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed