Pot Luck (1936) Poster

(1936)

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
Quaint English Comedy
Incalculacable15 March 2006
"Pot Luck" is a little known comedy from 1936 which features a cast of unknowns. I had absolutely no idea about this comedy but decided to watch because I was curious, and I was pleasantly surprised with what I found.

A criminal hatches a plan to steal a valuable vase from a showcase. The dumb attendant hands it over and from then on he, his sister and a detective try to retrieve the vase. There are some exciting scenes, but then again there are some draggy scenes. On the whole, the movie held my attention quite well (I was not expecting it to).

It is quite funny and clever at times. Of course it is undoubtedly naive, but that doesn't bother me. I do not recommend this to everyone, I'm pretty sure people will be unamused and bored by it, but I enjoyed it and believe it is a little known movie that should have more credit.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Watchable if there's nothing else on
heebie_jeebies1 September 2003
A priceless vase is stolen by a master thief, who uses a very silly and far-fetched plan to dupe a stupid attendant into handing the vase over to him. The attendant then attempts, with the help of an Irish sleuth, to retrieve the vase in time for its owner to collect it without any knowledge of the ordeal. It's a middle-of-the-road C-grade plot for a very middle-of-the-road C-grade film. The first half is watchable; neither good nor bad but a bit of a let-down after the compelling first scene. The second half, which involves the attempt to retrieve the vase, is more exciting. This daft little film is the 30s equivalent of one of those brainless, unoriginal films like Tomb Raider - only with a lot more class and charm. Its strength is its cast - the always wonderful Tom Walls is great as the Irish detective, and Ralph Lynn and Robertson Hare are good as - well, as the sort of twitty characters they always play. This is definitely one of the weaker films directed by Tom Walls, but the cast make it watchable.
5 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Unfunny Aldwych farce
malcolmgsw31 May 2013
The title is a pun and one of the few funny things about this Aldwych farce.Tom Walls plays a retired detective who tries to retrieve a pot stolen from attendant Ralph Lynn.The thieves take it to their lair which is a house owned by Robertson Hare.It has to be said that the last half hour gets sillier and sillier but alas not in a very comic way.It does get a bit better about halfway through when Robertson Hare makes an appearance.He is one of those actors whose face makes me expect to burst out loud laughing at any minute.Although this film only lasts for 68 minutes it does seem a lot longer than that.only for addicts
2 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Pie and Cream
Wayland_Wombat25 August 2020
Warning: Spoilers
Very enjoyable fast paced comedy, Retired Scotland Yard detective Fitzpatrick comes out of retirement to catch some thieves, love the performance of the servant Mr Cream at Wrotten Abbey, the sound track that goes along with his walk made me laugh out loud.

Available to purchase on DVD as part of aldwych farce collection, highly recommended
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Essential viewing!
JohnHowardReid11 December 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Director: TOM WALLS. Screenplay: Ben Travers. Based on his stage play. Photography: Roy Kellino, Arthur Crabtree. Film editor: Alfred Roome. Art director: Walter Murton. Music director: Louis Levy. Sound recording: F. McNally. British Acoustic Film Sound System. Producer: Michael Balcon. A Gainsborough Picture, presented by Gaumont-British Picture Corporation, made at Gainsborough Studios, Islington, London.

Never copyrighted, theatrically released or broadcast in the U.S.A. U.K. release through Gaumont-British. London trade screening: April 1936. Australian release through 20th Century-Fox: 5 August 1936. 71 minutes.

SYNOPSIS: An incompetent jewelry-store manager and his sister (!) hinder/aid an ex-detective's efforts to nail a gang of thieves.

COMMENT: By comparison with the usual Ben Travers farce, this one certainly starts off in an odd fashion with the Walls character capturing a desperate safe-cracker on the run after killing a policeman. This introductory sequence is not handled for laughs at all. Nor does it have any relevance to the main plot. It simply serves as an introduction to the main character, establishing him as a serious foil for the foolish Lynn. Yes, what we do have here is a comic thriller, with the accent on "comic", but it builds slowly and cleverly to a series of slapstick chases and edge-of-the-seat turns in an old abbey.

Walls deftly times his direction neatly to the script. The opening sequences are filmed in rather a flat fashion so that Walls can spring a large number of really effective surprises later on. True, the comic drama of the chases is somewhat undermined by obvious process screen inserts, but this was standard studio practice and can hardly be blamed on Walls. From the moment Diana Churchill asides to Lynn out of the corner of her mouth, "It's the bag!" and he asininely repeats the statement, the comedy moves into really high gear.

The abbey setting is both vast and wonderfully creepy. Aided by an appropriately monkish music score, a Karloff-type butler Gordon James introduces Robertson Hare with a delightful fanfare. Lots of pell- mell chases, near misses and discoveries, captures and escapes later with Walls, Lynn, Hare, Churchill, James, Hunt, O'Rourke, Kirby, Emmerton, Roberts, Stoker, Barrett, Smith and Gray playing hide-and-seek all over the sets, the picture comes to a fitting, if trifle sad conclusion.

Notice how Murton has built the abbey sets slightly out of perpendicular to give them an appropriately "old dark house" look. These sequences are also photographed in a forcefully noirish style — doubtless the work of the more experienced Kellino, whilst Crabtree handled the rather flat lighting in the shop scenes.

Wall and Lynn do their usual agreeably colorful work, ably assisted by Robertson Hare and Diana Churchill (playing Lynn's sister — doubtless to avoid cluttering an already close-to-crowded script with romantic complications).

Among the support players, mention must be made of the grotesquely made up Roy Emmerton as the chief heavy, the already mentioned Gordon James, an unrecognizable Martita Hunt bereft of her usual mannerisms as his wife, O'Rourke's deliciously dialectic chauffeur, J.H. Roberts' most agreeable con man and H.G. Stoker's "respectable" businessman type. Plus Mervyn Johns in an early film appearance (possibly only his third) as the dim-witted, slow-to- react janitor! Despite the multitude of characters, Travers has given them all enough individuality for the players to sharply delineate. Even the introductory cameo of the criminal Lever is memorably etched by Sam Wilkinson.

All told "Pot Luck" is a highly diverting piece of first-class entertainment, most skilfully scripted by a true professional and most ingratiatingly acted by a thoroughly crowd-pleasing medley of players.

Among the support players, mention must be made of the grotesquely made up Roy Emmerton as the chief heavy, the already mentioned Gordon James, an unrecognizable Martita Hunt bereft of her usual mannerisms as his wife, O'Rourke's deliciously dialectic chauffeur, J.H. Roberts' most agreeable con man and H.G. Stoker's "respectable" businessman type. Plus Mervyn Johns in an early film appearance (possibly only his third) as the dim-witted, slow-to-react janitor!

Despite the multitude of characters, Travers has given them all enough individuality for the players to sharply delineate. Even the introductory cameo of the criminal Lever is memorably etched by Sam Wilkinson
0 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed