Mary Jane's Pa (1935) User Reviews

Warner B

[boblipton · 6/10 · 6 March 2008]

This one is another fast and fun example of Warner's B work in this period, timing in at 75 minutes, with the usual cast of supporting actors talking fast to get the words out. Guy Kibbee plays... well, a typical Guy Kibbee role, except he's not a dolt this time, and it's Aline McMahon, usually cast in the pre-codes as the gal who's seen it all and shows it, who plays his love interest -- he's a pressman whose wanderlust made him leave his family and head out over the world ten years before. Now he's back and trying to woo his wife.

Of course the plot is not that simple. There's a bit of a political scandal in town and the rapprochement that's the heart of the story weaves its way in and out of that.

There are the usual fine, now-forgotten supporting actors in this piece. Nan Gey, playing the elder daughter, is cute as a button, and Oscar Apfel, who taught Demille how to direct a movie, has for him a sizable role. It's not a great movie, but there is some real chemistry between Kibbee and McMahon. Definitely worth a look.

A Very Honorable Guy

[lugonian · 7/10 · 16 July 2012]

MARY JANE'S PA (Warner Brothers, 1935), directed by William Keighley, is not a hillbilly comedy nor is Mary Jane the center of attention. The Pa in the title happens to be the main character of the story. Starring Aline MacMahon and Guy Kibbee in another one of their family oriented programmers, MARY JANE'S PA, following the basic pattern of their previous screen efforts of BABBITT, BIG HEARTED HERBERT and THE MERRY FRINKS (all 1934), is actually a better than the title indicates.

The 73 minute comedy-drama introduces Sam Preston (Guy Kibbee), a printer working from his Colorado home where he and wife, Ellen (Aline MacMahon) have established a weekly newspaper, The Silvertown Courier. One night while Ellen and two young daughters are asleep, the restless Sam, after hearing the train whistle from a distance, makes a hasty decision by deserting his family and taking the next train out of town. Awaken by the closing of the door, Ellen finds her husband gone, a farewell note and financial security from the Key State Utility Stock left to her, which turns out to be worthless. During the course of eleven years, Sam, having traveled the world to Calcutta, Paris, London, Melbourne and China, keeping himself financially secured with newspaper work, decides to return home. Upon his arrival, he finds his home has been converted to a local beer parlor and told by its bartender that Ellen had gone broke, sold the newspaper business and moved away with the children without a trace. Unable to locate his family, Sam becomes a side show barker. After the carnival makes a stop in town, Sam encounters a little girl (Betty Jane Hainey), having been separated from her older sister and boyfriend, roaming about alone, watching the shows. After conversing with the talkative child, Sam takes her home riding on an elephant. Coming inside the house, Sam discovers her to be his own daughter, Mary Jane. Told her father is "dead," Sam keeps his identity a secret, going under the name of Joshua Barker. Seeing Ellen has found a new life for herself as editor for the Hempstead Daily News, with the raccoon coat wearing Linc Overman (John Arledge ) as her star reporter, Sam also finds his eldest daughter, Lucille (Nan Grey), has grown to an attractive young lady in love with King Wagner (Tom Brown), son of a local banker (Robert McWade). Though Ellen is bitter towards her wanderlust husband, she does offer him employment as her live-in cook and handyman, much to the surprise of town gossips and dismay of Kenneth Marvin (Minor Watson), a leading candidate for legislature who intends on having Sam leave town in order for he to marry Ellen for reasons of his own.

A familiar plot reminiscent to stories commonly found in melodramas used during the silent era, MARY JANE'S PA, which originated as both book and play, did emerge as a silent motion picture in 1917 from Vitagraph Studios with Marc MacDermott in the Kibbee role. Though the plot was possibly considered old-fashioned material by 1935 standards, the worthwhile script by Peter Milne and Tom Reed, along with the fine chemistry between MacMahon and Kibbee make this an agreeable affair. MacMahon, good as always, gives a remarkable performance all around, especially one where she goes to watch over her young children asleep in their beds after finding her husband deserted her, with sad eyes of emotion silently thinking to herself, "What am I to do?" Kibbee's character may not warrant any sympathy for his decision, but enough pleasing results for why things turn out the way they do.

Aside from "Mary Jane" being the name of Sam's printing machine, Mary Jane, the youngest daughter, is awarded to newcomer, Betty Jane Hainey. Sporting dark curly hair, having a mature face for a little girl, comes across as a pint-size Mary Astor. Though likable, she's become one of those real obscure child performers who naturally failed to achieve any legendary status of Shirley Temple or to a lesser known degree, Jane Withers. Hainey may have enough camera close-ups to warrant some attention, but nothing worthy to generate future leading roles tho revolve around her. Even working with season veterans as Kibbee and MacMahon (in their final pairing for Warners), it would be hard even for a child actress like Hainey to steal any scenes from them. The same can be said for Nan Grey (spelled Gray in credits) and Tom Brown as the young lovers who make their presence known but scarcely noticeable.

MARY JANE'S PA may not win any merits as a sort-after film classic, but worthy entertainment properly viewed for Father's Day or whenever broadcast on Turner Classic Movies cable channel. As much as Mary Jane is not the central figure here, the attention no doubt is drawn mostly to both Ma and Mary Jane's Pa. (***)

Far from perfect but enjoyable.

[planktonrules · 7/10 · 8 April 2015]

Sam (Guy Kibbee) is an irresponsible jerk who has 'itchy feet'. His desire to see the world is so great that he decides to leave his family. However, he's not 100% rotten and he leaves a lot of stocks for them so that they'll be okay financially.

Over a decade passes and Sam is curious about his old family. However, when he returns to his old town, he finds that it's practically a ghost town and the old newspaper they owned is gone. Eventually, he does locate the family--but he doesn't plan on moving back--he just wants to see them. Well, that's his plan at first....but after a while he decides to stick around a bit longer-- especially as his wife's new newspaper is endorsing a man Sam doesn't trust.

This is one of many pairings of Guy Kibbee with Aline MacMahon who plays the long-suffering wife. They worked well together and the film is enjoyable...but it has a basic weakness because Sam is a rather nice but also VERY despicable guy. But somehow it works despite this....

good main story with some extra side plots

[ksf-2 · 7/10 · 9 July 2019]

Aside from the obvious Mary Jane reference, this is a fine black and white film from 1935. Aline MacMahon always played the smart, hard-working, knowing motherly type. Guy Kibbee could play ANYTHING! They both started in films about the same time that talkies started, 1930-ish. Mary Jane's Pa started as a novel and a play, and onto hollywood. Ellen Preston gets up to find that hubby Sam has hit the road, and now she's on her own to raise the kiddies. When Sam comes back into town, he finds his business closed up, and the family is no-where in sight. Can he track them down? and if so, will they take him back? the multi-talented Oscar Apfel is in here as the chief. SO many of his roles were uncredited, the sidekick, the wacky character actor. This starts as a pretty straight-forward story. good picture and sound quality. We were DEEP DEEP in the film production code by 1935, so of course there are also issues with a man living in the same house as a woman. and something about illegal campaign funds. and breaking and entering. and running away from home. many little subplots. gets more complicated than it needs to be. It's pretty good. and all done in 70 minutes. Directed by William Keighley; had directed some GREAT films -- Man Who Came to Dinner, Torrid Zone, The Bride Came COD.

Secondary contract players made a fine leading team.

[mark.waltz · 6/10 · 4 July 2019]

Warner Brothers contract players Guy Kibbee and Ailene MacMahon scored a big hit in "Gold Diggers of 1933" and ended up being paired as leads in nearly half a dozen films afterwards. In spite of the obvious age difference they work well together, a cinematic Fred and Ethel Mertz where the two actors actually got along. Kibbee ran out on his wife and children years before, and MacMahon made good on her own, eventually going on with her life and finding a career as a newspaper editorial editor. His sudden return after a decade throws a fly into the mixture of her life, and being the big dreamer that he is, it's a mixed blessing. His children have no idea that the kindly stranger that their mother hired to work as their cook is actually their pop, and he plays Mr. Fix it in many of their personal issues, even helping his estranged wife in a political issue involving her paper.

Making his entrance on an elephant, Kibbee totally charms the titled character (Betty Jean Hainey) whom he has no idea is his youngest daughter. The fact that they are living miles away in a different state from where Kibbee and MacMahon lived before is of no consequence, and neither is the fact that MacMahon has a new man in her life. The two veteran actors are superb and MacMahon can say more with her eyes than most actresses can with a script filled with words. Her reaction upon seeing him is priceless, especially as the young daughter is being shown by him how to make a bird's nest egg sandwich.

As MacMahon's feelings begin to grow for her estranged husband, the lights in her eyes do too. When she breaks down and calls him dear, you know it's a done deal. Alternately touching and funny, this film lacks in pathos and succeeds simply based on the lovability of its two stars.