The Border Legion (1930) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Honor among thieves?
AlsExGal7 August 2015
Warning: Spoilers
Or at least that is what this precode western implies. Richard Arlen plays a cowpoke falsely accused of murder and rescued by outlaw Jack Kells (Jack Holt) before he can be hanged. As some misled sense of gratitude Arlen's character, Jim Cleve, takes up with Kells' band of outlaws, The Border Legion. The Legion kidnaps a girl, Fay Wray as Joan Randall, mainly to get information out of her. Cleve's job is to guard Joan, but he falls in love with her. Things come to a head between Kells and Cleve after Kells attempts to rape Joan, after he realizes that she has no information, or what she has she is not telling. When Cleves finds out he mounts a horse and now he is AGAINST the Legion, running into town and telling the sheriff and his men of the Legion's whereabouts and the fact that they have Joan. However, the sheriff recognizes Cleves and refuses to believe him.

It's rather ironic that Zane Grey wrote this story, because the characters here are extremely gray. Kells is apparently the kind of man that doesn't mind murdering in the pursuit of thievery, but will sacrifice his life for a friend just hours after trying to rape that friend's best girl. Cleves is a hero that is hard to get behind because he is all for helping Kells take things that belong to others, but that all changes when the girl he loves is involved.

At any rate, the film is somewhat refreshing for a 30s western because it doesn't have the tired clichés of the bad guys being very bad and wearing all black, and the good guys being very good and having glistening teeth and wearing all white. Also, remember this is one of the early sound westerns since westerns could not be made for awhile in the very early years of talking pictures - everything was filmed inside due to equipment limitations. I'd recommend it if you can ever find a copy.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Hard-To-Find Routine Oater
GManfred9 August 2015
Around the time of the Civil War, outcasts from Eastern society gathered out in the Wild West border towns and formed outlaw groups. "Border Legion" is the story of one such band, a story by legendary western writer Zane Grey.

This Border Legion is led by Jack Holt, a Union officer on the run after killing a fellow officer. In his gang are such 'plug-uglys' as Eugene Palette, a card sharp wanted for murder, and worse still is Stanley Fields, a bad guy who is just bad. Holt befriends Richard Arlen, a cowpoke who was framed for murder, and together the group does a lot of bad guy things that don't need recounting. Suffice it to say it is nothing you have not seen before, which is the film's main drawback. In truth, since 1930 it's all been done and we in 2015 are jaded by what once fascinated audiences of long ago.

If you are a western fan it is passable entertainment but if you are looking for something new and exciting, move on, pardner. "Border Legion" was shown at Capitolfest, Rome N.Y., 8/15.
2 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed